Semi-Grant-Free NOMA: A Stochastic Geometry Model

Chao Zhang, Yuanwei Liu, Zhijin Qin, Zhiguo Ding

Introduction

In the evolution toward 5G/6G networks, Ultra-Reliable Low-Latency Communications (URLLC) face a significant hurdle: the signaling overhead of traditional Grant-Based (GB) transmission. While Grant-Free (GF) transmission eliminates the scheduling "handshake," it introduces unmanaged collisions in massive IoT deployments. This paper proposes a semi-grant-free (semi-GF) NOMA framework, allowing GF users to share spectrum already allocated to GB users, balancing latency and reliability.

System Model and Protocols

The core of the proposed framework is the integration of Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) to facilitate spectrum sharing. By separating users in the power domain through Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC), multiple devices can occupy the same time-frequency resource.

Comparison of signaling overhead for different transmission protocols.

The authors introduce a Dynamic Protocol to manage this sharing. Unlike the standard "open-loop" protocol, which relies on a static channel quality threshold, the dynamic protocol enables the base station to broadcast a threshold tailored to the current GB user's channel conditions. This ensures GF users only transmit when the resulting interference does not compromise the GB user's reliability.

Spatial Scenarios and Stochastic Geometry

To evaluate performance in a realistic environment, the researchers utilize Stochastic Geometry, specifically Homogeneous Poisson Point Processes (HPPP), to model random user locations. They analyze two distinct spatial configurations:

  1. Scenario I: GB users are located near the base station, while GF users are in the far field.
  2. Scenario II: GF users are near the base station, and GB users are far.
Spatial distribution of users in Scenario I and Scenario II with corresponding protocol logic.

This spatial modeling allows for a rigorous derivation of Outage Probability (OP) and diversity gains, accounting for path loss and Rayleigh fading. The analytical expressions derived for OP perfectly match Monte Carlo simulation results, providing a robust mathematical framework for network design.

Key Results and Insights

The study yields several critical insights for future network engineering:

  • Dynamic vs. Open-Loop: Numerical results validate that the dynamic protocol significantly outperforms open-loop alternatives by providing more precise entry thresholds for GF users, thereby minimizing unexpected interference.
  • Diversity Orders: The authors mathematically demonstrate that diversity gain is tied to the SIC decoding order. "Near" users (decoded first or after perfect SIC) achieve a diversity order of 1, while "far" users, limited by the interference of the other user, achieve a diversity order of 0.
  • Near-User Advantage: Regardless of whether a user is GB or GF, the user physically closer to the base station consistently sees superior performance gains in the NOMA pair.

Conclusion and Future Work

The proposed semi-GF NOMA framework offers a robust solution for massive connectivity. While the current model assumes perfect SIC and random pairing, it provides a mathematical foundation for future optimizations. Future research may explore imperfect SIC scenarios, code-domain NOMA integration, and sophisticated user-pairing algorithms to further enhance spectral efficiency in 6G ecosystems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Grant-free (GF) transmission holds promise in terms of low latency communication by directly transmitting messages without waiting for any permissions. However, collision situations may frequently happen when limited spectrum is occupied by numerous GF users. The non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) technique can be a promising solution to achieve massive connectivity and fewer collisions for GF transmission by multiplexing users in power domain. We utilize a semi-grant-free (semi-GF) NOMA scheme for enhancing network connectivity and spectral efficiency by enabling grant-based (GB) and GF users to share the same spectrum resources. With the aid of semi-GF protocols, uplink NOMA networks are investigated by invoking stochastic geometry techniques. We propose a novel \textit{dynamic protocol} to interpret which part of the GF users are paired in NOMA transmissions via transmitting various channel quality thresholds by an added handshake. We utilize open-loop protocol with a fixed average threshold as the benchmark to investigate performance improvement. It is observed that dynamic protocol provides more accurate channel quality thresholds than open-loop protocol, thereby the interference from the GF users is reduced to a large extent. We analyze the outage performance and diversity gains under two protocols. Numerical results demonstrate that dynamic protocol is capable of enhancing the outage performance than open-loop protocol.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2022semi,
  author = {Chao Zhang and Yuanwei Liu and Zhijin Qin and Zhiguo Ding},
  title = {{Semi-Grant-Free NOMA: A Stochastic Geometry Model}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/twc.2021.3103036},
}
Figure