Self-similarity study based on the particle sizes of coal-series diatomite

Liang Cheng, Guangming Wang, Zhijun Ma, Hao Guo, Ye Gao, Qi Zhang, Jing Gao, Hanghang FuScientific 2024 · DOI

This study, published in Scientific Reports, explores the fractal nature and internal architecture of coal-series diatomite (CSD)—a common industrial waste product. By combining gas adsorption models with 3D image reconstruction, researchers demonstrated how grinding this mineral into different particle sizes fundamentally alters its "self-similarity" and pore complexity, providing a roadmap for transforming environmental waste into high-value functional materials.

TL;DR

Researchers used fractal mathematics and 3D image processing to map the complex pore structures of coal-series diatomite across various particle sizes. They discovered that finer particles expose intricate mesopore networks previously hidden by impurities, while coarser particles retain a "chaotic" macropore structure dominated by cracks and surface irregularities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diatomite is a highly porous mineral prized for its use in filters, catalysts, and adsorbents. However, high-quality natural sources are depleting. Coal-series diatomite (CSD) is an abundant alternative found in coal mining waste, but it is often considered "low-grade" due to poor structural properties and high impurity levels.

The challenge lies in the fact that CSD’s performance depends heavily on its internal pore structure. Until now, we lacked a precise understanding of how the physical size of CSD particles relates to their "self-similarity"—the way their microscopic patterns repeat across different scales. Without this knowledge, it is difficult to optimize CSD for specific industrial applications, leading to resource waste and environmental pressure.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-scale approach to characterize CSD samples from Heilongjiang Province, China, sieved into nine distinct particle size scales (PSSs).

  • Gas Adsorption Modeling: Beyond standard BET (surface area) and BJH (pore size) analysis, the team used the Frenkel-Haisey-Hill (FHH) model to characterize mesopores and the Menger model for macropores. These models calculate fractal dimensions ($D$), which quantify surface roughness and structural complexity.
  • Image Processing & 3D Reconstruction: Using SEM (Scanning Electron Microscopy) images, the researchers programmed MATLAB to perform optimal threshold segmentation. This allowed them to mathematically separate "pores" from "solid" in 2D images and then reconstruct them into 3D spatial surface maps.
  • Box-Counting Dimension: This technique was used on the processed images to provide a secondary, visual-based verification of the fractal complexity of the pore networks.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset of coal-series diatomite from the Yong’an mining area.

  • Mineralogical Data: XRD patterns identifying opal, quartz, and various clay minerals (kaolinite, illite).
  • Physical Samples: Nine particle size fractions ranging from coarse (-2 mm) to ultra-fine (-0.025 mm).
  • Generated Data: Nitrogen adsorption-desorption isotherms, grayscale histograms, and 3D reconstructed datasets for each size fraction.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Multilevel" Architecture: CSD is not a uniform sponge; it possesses a hierarchical structure dominated by mesopores (2–50 nm) and macropores (>50 nm), but it almost entirely lacks micropores.
  • Grinding as a "Structural Unlock": As particle size decreases, the specific surface area (SSA) increases significantly. The researchers found that grinding breaks down "gangue" (waste) minerals that previously clogged the diatomite pores, exposing a much richer, more complex mesopore network in the finer fractions.
  • Coarse Complexity vs. Fine Intricacy:
    • Fine particles have higher fractal dimensions for mesopores ($D_{F1}$), meaning their internal surfaces are more intricate and "wrinkled."
    • Coarse particles exhibit higher complexity in their macropores ($D_{M1}$) due to the presence of large-scale cracks, steps, and "concave-convex" structures that are lost during fine grinding.
  • Visualizing the Math: The 3D reconstructions confirmed that the mathematical fractal models weren't just abstract numbers; they accurately represented the physical "undulations" and pore distributions observed in the mineral.

Key Results

  • Surface Area Gains: The specific surface area (SSA) rose from 26.8 m²/g in coarse samples to 47.0 m²/g in the finest fraction (-0.025 mm).
  • Fractal Dimensions: For the finest particles, the mesopore fractal dimension ($D_{F1}$) was 2.51, compared to 2.48 for the coarsest. Conversely, the macropore dimension ($D_{M1}$) was higher in the coarse samples (3.79) than in the fine ones (3.75).
  • Pore Volume: The total pore volume reached a peak of 0.1407 cm³/g at the finest particle size.
  • Model Reliability: The FHH model showed exceptional fit ($R^2 > 0.99$), proving it is a highly reliable tool for predicting the surface roughness of CSD.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors noted that while the FHH model was very accurate for mesopores, the Menger model for macropores showed lower reliability in some instances ($R^2$ values as low as 0.16). This suggests that macropore geometry in CSD is highly irregular and may require even more sophisticated modeling.

Future research could focus on:

  1. Functional Testing: Correlating these specific fractal dimensions to actual performance in heavy metal adsorption or catalytic efficiency.
  2. Geographic Variation: Testing CSD from different regions to see if these self-similarity rules hold true globally.
  3. Purification Optimization: Using the structural insights to design more efficient chemical purification stages that target the specific "clogging" minerals identified in the coarse fractions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Coal-series diatomite (CSD) is widely distributed in China and has poor functional and structural properties and exhibits limited utilization of high value-added materials, resulting in a serious waste of resources and tremendous pressure on the environment. Moreover, due to differences in the mineralogical characteristics of CSD, different particle size scales (PSSs) have different functional structures and exhibit different self-similarities. In this study, we took CSD as the research object and PSS as the entry point and carried out a self-similarity study based on gas adsorption and an image processing method to illustrate the microstructures and self-similarities of different PSSs. The results showed that the pore structure of the CSD was dominated by mesopores and macropores and basically lacked micropores. The fractal dimensions were calculated with the Frenkel-Haisey-Hill (FHH) model and Menger model, and the D<sub>F1</sub> values for - 0.025 mm and - 2 mm were 2.51 and 2.48, respectively, and the D<sub>M1</sub> values were 3.75 and 3.79, respectively, indicating that the mesopore structure of the fine PSS was complex, whereas macropores were present in the coarse PSS. MATLAB was programmed to obtain grayscale thresholds, binarized images, grayscale histograms, three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction images and box dimensions, which enabled us to observe the microstructures and self-similarities of the CSD. Self-similarity studies based on particle sizes are very important for functional application of CSD.Please note that article title mismatch between MS and JS we have followed MS, kindly check and cofirm.Yes, I have checked and confirmed.Kindly check and confirm corresponding author mail id are correctly identified.Yes, I have checked and confirmed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cheng2024self,
  author = {Liang Cheng and Guangming Wang and Zhijun Ma and Hao Guo and Ye Gao and Qi Zhang and Jing Gao and Hanghang Fu},
  title = {{Self-similarity study based on the particle sizes of coal-series diatomite}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-57710-x},
}
Figure