Self-referral of Chinese patients with advanced chronic kidney disease and treatment decision-making: A qualitative study

Yajing Gao, Shan Yan, Tingting Jiang, Xue Li, Xinxin Jiang, Li Cai, Sa Xu, Tianying Chang, Hong WangAuthorea 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Chinese patients with advanced chronic kidney disease (CKD), particularly those from rural areas, frequently bypass local healthcare hierarchies to self-refer to tertiary hospitals. This qualitative study explores the motivations behind self-referral and its impact on subsequent treatment decision-making. Through semi-structured interviews with 22 patients and 8 healthcare professionals, the research identifies three core themes: the self-referral decision process, the lived experience of care in high-tier facilities, and the eventual treatment choices. Findings suggest that while self-referral empowers patient autonomy, it also introduces significant psychological stress and communication barriers. The study advocates for specialized dialysis transition care and the expansion of peritoneal dialysis access to better support these patients.

Introduction

In China’s three-tiered healthcare system, patients are encouraged to follow a structured referral path from primary clinics to secondary and tertiary hospitals. However, a significant number of patients with advanced chronic kidney disease (CKD) opt for "self-referral," independently seeking care at prestigious provincial or national centers. These patients often present at advanced stages of the disease, frequently in a state of shock or denial, seeking a "placebo" or a way to delay the necessity of dialysis. This study investigates the relationship between the act of self-referring and the subsequent life-altering treatment decisions, such as choosing between hemodialysis, peritoneal dialysis, or kidney transplantation.

Methods

The study utilized a qualitative phenomenological approach to capture the nuanced experiences of patients and providers. Semi-structured, face-to-face interviews were conducted between May and October 2019 at the First Hospital Affiliated to Zhengzhou University.

Table 1: Interview topics and areas covered for patient participants.

Participants included 22 patients with advanced CKD (eGFR ≤ 20 mL/min) who had self-referred, along with 8 healthcare professionals (HCPs), including nephrologists and nurses. Interviews were recorded, transcribed, and analyzed using iterative thematic analysis facilitated by Nvivo software. This methodology allowed researchers to explore the emotional, cultural, and familial factors influencing medical journeys.

Key Results and Insights

The analysis revealed a complex interplay between patient motives, organizational factors, and treatment outcomes.

Patient Profile and Motives

A critical finding was that 81.8% of the interviewed patients were already at CKD Stage 5 upon self-referral, highlighting the late-stage nature of these transitions.

Table 2: Demographic and clinical characteristics of the 22 patient participants.

Motives for self-referral often included a psychological "placebo" effect, where patients hoped a renowned hospital might offer a more favorable prognosis. Additionally, the decision to self-refer was frequently driven by family members, underscoring the collectivist nature of medical decision-making in Chinese culture.

The Experience of Care

Self-referral was found to stimulate patient autonomy; these patients were often more focused on choosing their own dialysis modalities than those passively referred. However, this was tempered by an "information paradox": patients had a high desire for involvement but lacked the health literacy to process complex medical risks. Furthermore, the high patient volume at top-tier hospitals often led to "businesslike" interactions, which patients perceived as cold, resulting in a cycle of stress and distrust.

Treatment Decision-Making

The study observed a "cost-benefit redecision" pattern. Patients might select a treatment modality at a tertiary hospital but only finalize the decision after confirming that follow-up care was available at a local hospital to reduce travel and accommodation expenses.

Conclusion

The intersection of self-referral and treatment decision-making is shaped by a mix of demographic factors and psychological motives. To improve the quality of care for advanced CKD patients, the authors suggest establishing more robust CKD screening systems and accelerating the popularization of peritoneal dialysis in rural areas. Implementing specialized dialysis transition care could bridge the communication gap and soothe the negative emotions associated with late-stage diagnosis and self-referral.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rationale, aims, and objectives: Chinese patients with advanced chronic kidney disease (CKD), especially rural patients possibly occur self-referral behavior and then treatment decisions followed. It is unclear the relationship between self-referral and treatment decision-making. Thus, the aim of this study was to explore the perceptions and views of self-referral and treatment decision making among patients with advanced chronic kidney disease. Methods: We conducted semi-structured interviews with 26 patients with advanced kidney disease and 12 nephrologists. Interviews were conducted and analyzed thematically until reaching thematic saturation. Results: We identified three themes reflected: 1) self-referral decision making (self-referral motive, barrier to self-referral, seeking for self-referral information); 2) the views and experience of self-referral care (facilitating shared decision making, imposing psychological pressure, feeling about self-referral communication, challenge to staff-patient relationship); 3) treatment decision making (decisional awareness and roles, cost-benefit trade-off and redicision). Conclusions: Our study identified that organizational and demographic factors, self-referral motives worked together at the self-referral decision-making and treatment decision-making when advanced CKD patients facing with healthcare facilities and treatment options. Those findings suggest stakeholders should accelerate the popularization of peritoneal dialysis technology and establish the CKD screening and management systems. For self-referral patients with advanced CKD, our results suggest specialized dialysis transition care to improve quality of communication and soothe patients’ negative emotion.
BibTeX
@misc{gao2020self,
  author = {Yajing Gao and Shan Yan and Tingting Jiang and Xue Li and Xinxin Jiang and Li Cai and Sa Xu and Tianying Chang and Hong Wang},
  title = {{Self-referral of Chinese patients with advanced chronic kidney disease and treatment decision-making: A qualitative study}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.22541/au.160570625.51499988/v1},
  howpublished = {Authorea},
}
Figure