Security-Aware Relaying Scheme for Cooperative Networks With Untrusted Relay Nodes

Li Sun, Pinyi Ren, Qinghe Du, Yichen Wang, Zhenzhen Gao

Abstract

This paper studies the problem of secure transmission in dual-hop cooperative networks with untrusted relays, where each relay acts as both a potential helper and an eavesdropper. A security-aware relaying scheme is proposed, which employs alternate jamming and secrecy-enhanced relay selection to prevent the confidential message from being eavesdropped by the untrusted relays. To evaluate the performance of the proposed strategies, we derive the lower bound of the achievable ergodic secrecy rate (ESR) and conduct asymptotic analysis to examine how the ESR scales as the number of relays increases.

Introduction

In modern heterogeneous wireless networks, such as IoT or multi-tier cellular systems, relays are often used to extend coverage. However, these relays may have lower security clearances than the source and destination, making them "frenemies"—potential helpers that are also potential eavesdroppers. While prior research often focused on securing only the first hop, this study addresses the challenge of securing both phases of a dual-hop transmission to maximize the ergodic secrecy rate (ESR).

Proposed Security-Aware Methodology

The authors propose a two-pronged strategy to maintain privacy in the presence of untrusted infrastructure:

  1. Alternate Jamming:
    • Phase 1 (Broadcast): As the Source transmits to the relays, the Destination sends artificial noise (jamming) to prevent relays from decoding the signal.
  2. Phase 2 (Relaying): The selected relay forwards the signal. Simultaneously, the Source sends artificial noise to jam non-selected relays that might be eavesdropping.
  3. Relay Selection Policies:
    • Optimal Selection: A high-complexity method requiring global channel state information (CSI).
  4. Sub-optimal Selection: A simplified, distributed rule focusing on balancing the signal strength of source-relay and relay-destination links, requiring only local CSI.

Performance Evaluation and Key Insights

The proposed schemes were evaluated using Monte Carlo simulations under Rayleigh fading conditions. A critical finding is the "double-edged sword" nature of relays: while more relays can provide better diversity gain, they also increase the number of potential eavesdroppers.

Figure 1: Ergodic Secrecy Rate vs. SNR for various selection schemes, comparing optimal and sub-optimal policies against existing benchmarks.

As shown in Figure 1, the proposed selection policies significantly outperform existing benchmarks. Notably, the sub-optimal selection policy performs nearly as well as the optimal one, making it a highly practical choice for real-time hardware implementation. The results also validate the accuracy of the derived ESR lower bound at medium-to-high Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNR).

The Impact of Relay Density

A surprising insight from the asymptotic analysis (using Extreme Value Theory) is that the ESR does not scale infinitely with the number of relays.

Figure 2: Ergodic Secrecy Rate vs. Number of relay nodes, illustrating the performance degradation as the number of untrusted relays increases.

As illustrated in Figure 2, the ESR actually decreases as the number of untrusted relays becomes very large. The increased risk of information leakage eventually outweighs the benefit of having a better relay to choose from. This highlights a fundamental limit in securing networks with untrusted components.

Conclusion and Future Work

The study confirms that using the destination as a jammer is essential for achieving non-zero secrecy rates when relays are untrusted. While the current work focuses on Amplify-and-Forward (AF) relays and assumes perfect CSI, future research could explore Decode-and-Forward (DF) relays and the impact of imperfect CSI or dynamic power allocation between the message and jamming signals.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper studies the problem of secure transmission in dual-hop cooperative networks with untrusted relays, where each relay acts as both a potential helper and an eavesdropper. A security-aware relaying scheme is proposed, which employs the alternate jamming and secrecy-enhanced relay selection to prevent the confidential message from being eavesdropped by the untrusted relays. To evaluate the performance of the proposed strategies, we derive the lower bound of the achievable ergodic secrecy rate (ESR), and conduct the asymptotic analysis to examine how the ESR scales as the number of relays increases.
BibTeX
@article{sun2014security,
  author = {Li Sun and Pinyi Ren and Qinghe Du and Yichen Wang and Zhenzhen Gao},
  title = {{Security-Aware Relaying Scheme for Cooperative Networks With Untrusted Relay Nodes}},
  journal = {IEEE Communications Letters},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1109/lcomm.2014.2385095},
}
Figure