Secure Incentivization for Decentralized Content Delivery

Prateesh Goyal, Ravi Netravali, Mohammad Alizadeh, Hari Balakrishnan

Abstract: Prior research has proposed technical solutions to use peer-to-peer (P2P) content delivery to serve Internet video, showing that it can reduce costs to content providers. Yet, such methods have not become widespread except for a few niche instances. An important challenge is incentivization: what tangible benefits does P2P content delivery offer users who bring resources to the table? In this paper, we ask whether monetary incentives can help attract peers in P2P content delivery systems. We commissioned a professional survey of people around the United States to answer several relevant questions. We found that 51% of the 876 respondents—substantially larger than our expectations—answered "yes" to whether they would participate for suitable financial incentives. Encouraged by the results of the survey, we propose Gringotts, a system to structure incentives and securely incorporate P2P delivery into content delivery systems. Gringotts provides a novel Proof of Delivery mechanism that allows content providers to verify correct delivery of their files, and shows how to use cryptocurrency to pay peers while guarding against liars and Sybil attacks.

The Incentive Gap in P2P Delivery

While P2P technology is technically capable of serving massive amounts of video traffic at a fraction of the cost of traditional Content Delivery Networks (CDNs), it has failed to see widespread adoption. The primary barrier is human rather than technical: there is no compelling reason for a user to sacrifice their bandwidth or battery life without a tangible reward. Previous attempts at incentivization, such as virtual tokens or "tit-for-tat" systems, have failed to gain traction. Monetary payments are the logical solution, but they introduce significant challenges regarding trust, payment scalability, and security against malicious actors.

Gringotts: A Secure P2P Incentive Framework

To address these hurdles, we present Gringotts, a decentralized framework designed to provide secure monetary incentives for P2P content delivery. The system involves three primary entities: the Content Provider (CP), the Client, and the Peer.

Figure 1: The Gringotts system architecture and Proof of Delivery (PoD) workflow.

At the heart of Gringotts is the Proof of Delivery Chain (PoDC). When a client downloads a chunk from a peer, they exchange signed hashes to create a tamper-proof chain of evidence. To claim payment, the peer commits this proof to a blockchain smart contract. To ensure the system can scale despite blockchain transaction limits, Gringotts employs probabilistic payments. Instead of paying for every chunk, the system uses a "lottery" logic where peers only submit proofs that meet specific mathematical conditions, reducing blockchain traffic by orders of magnitude while maintaining fair average compensation.

User Willingness and the Crypto Barrier

A key contribution of this work is a commissioned survey of 876 US-based respondents to gauge the social feasibility of such a system. The results were surprisingly positive: 51% of users expressed a willingness to participate in P2P delivery if offered financial incentives.

Figure 2: Survey results showing (a) willingness to participate for incentives and (b) openness to cryptocurrency payments.

While participation interest is high, the survey also highlighted the "crypto barrier." While 27% of respondents were already comfortable receiving cryptocurrency, 40% remained unsure, largely due to a lack of familiarity with the technology. This suggests that while the economic model is sound, user education or the integration of stablecoins may be necessary for mass adoption.

Economic Feasibility and Scalability

Our analysis suggests that Gringotts is economically viable for the average user. At a rate of $0.05/GB, a user serving content for just two hours a day could earn approximately **$29 per month**—enough to cover nearly half of an average US internet bill. Furthermore, by utilizing probabilistic payments (with a factor of $N=300$), we estimate that a blockchain like Ethereum could support roughly 220,000 active peers simultaneously.

Conclusion and Future Work

Gringotts demonstrates that the infrastructure for a massive, low-cost CDN alternative already exists in the form of underutilized consumer laptops. By solving the security and incentive problems through bandwidth-based "proof of work" and cryptographic delivery chains, we can turn idle resources into a functional delivery network. Future work will focus on reducing ISP friction and lowering the technical barrier for content providers to integrate these decentralized protocols.

Summary updated

Abstract

Prior research has proposed technical solutions to use peer-to-peer (P2P) content delivery to serve Internet video, showing that it can reduce costs to content providers. Yet, such methods have not become widespread except for a few niche instances. An important challenge is incentivization: what tangible benefits does P2P content delivery offer users who bring resources to the table? In this paper, we ask whether monetary incentives can help attract peers in P2P content delivery systems. We commissioned a professional survey of people around theUnited States to answer several relevant questions. We found that 51% of the 876 respondents--substantially larger than our expectations--answered "yes" to whether they would participate for suitable financial incentives. Encouraged by the results of the survey, we propose Gringotts, a system to structure incentives and securely incorporate P2P delivery into content delivery systems. Gringotts provides a novel Proof of Delivery mechanism that allows content providers to verify correct delivery of their files, and shows how to use cryptocurrency to pay peers while guarding against liars and Sybil attacks.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{goyal2019secure,
  author = {Prateesh Goyal and Ravi Netravali and Mohammad Alizadeh and Hari Balakrishnan},
  title = {{Secure Incentivization for Decentralized Content Delivery}},
  booktitle = {HotEdge},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=wmP2H8-GV4x},
}
Figure