Abstract
In this work, an adaptive and robust null-space projection (AR-NSP) scheme is proposed for secure transmission with artificial noise (AN)-aided directional modulation (DM) in wireless networks. The proposed scheme is carried out in three steps. Firstly, the directions of arrival (DOAs) of the signals from the desired user and eavesdropper are estimated by the Root Multiple Signal Classification (Root-MUSIC) algorithm and the related signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) are estimated based on the ratio of the corresponding eigenvalue to the minimum eigenvalue of the covariance matrix of the received signals. In the second step, the value intervals of DOA estimation errors are predicted based on the DOA and SNR estimations. Finally, a robust NSP beamforming DM system is designed according to the afore-obtained estimations and predictions. Our examination shows that the proposed scheme can significantly outperform the conventional non-adaptive robust scheme and non-robust NSP scheme in terms of achieving a much lower bit error rate (BER) at the desired user and a much higher secrecy rate (SR). In addition, the BER and SR performance gains achieved by the proposed scheme relative to other schemes increase with the value range of DOA estimation error.
Introduction
The rapid expansion of the Internet of Things (IoT) introduces significant security challenges, as traditional cryptographic methods often impose excessive computational and management overhead on low-power devices. Physical Layer Security (PLS) has emerged as a promising alternative, leveraging the inherent characteristics of wireless channels to ensure confidentiality.
A key technique in PLS is Directional Modulation (DM), which focuses signal energy toward a specific physical direction. However, practical DM systems often struggle with "noisy" measurements. If the transmitter’s estimate of a receiver's direction is inaccurate, confidential data may leak to eavesdroppers, or the legitimate user may experience a high Bit Error Rate (BER). This paper introduces an Adaptive and Robust Null-Space Projection (AR-NSP) scheme designed to be resilient against such directional estimation errors by adapting to real-time signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) conditions.
The AR-NSP Framework
The proposed AR-NSP scheme operates through a structured three-step process to ensure robust and secure communication:
- Estimation: The base station (Alice) receives signals from the legitimate user (Bob) and potential eavesdroppers (Eve). It employs the Root-MUSIC algorithm to estimate their Directions of Arrival (DOA). Simultaneously, Alice estimates the current SNR by analyzing the eigenvalues of the received signal's covariance matrix.
- Prediction: Utilizing the Cramer-Rao Lower Bound (CRLB), the system predicts the likely interval of directional error based on the estimated SNR. This allows the system to quantify its own measurement uncertainty.
- Robust Beamforming: Alice designs a beamforming vector that accounts for the entire predicted error interval. Artificial Noise (AN) is then projected into the "null-space"—directions where it will disrupt eavesdropping without interfering with the legitimate user's reception.
Performance Evaluation
The effectiveness of the AR-NSP scheme was validated through extensive Monte Carlo simulations using QPSK modulation across various antenna array sizes ($N = 4, 16, 64$). The results demonstrate significant improvements in both reliability and secrecy.
Key Results
- Enhanced Secrecy Rate (SR): As shown in the performance comparison, the AR-NSP scheme consistently achieves a higher secrecy rate than both conventional non-adaptive robust schemes and standard non-robust NSP methods.
- Robustness to Error: A critical finding is that the performance advantage of the AR-NSP scheme actually increases as the directional estimation error grows. This confirms its suitability for harsh or highly dynamic wireless environments.
- Signal Integrity: Analysis of "eye patterns" revealed that while the legitimate user receives a clear, decodable signal, the eavesdropper's signal is effectively scrambled by the adaptive artificial noise.
Conclusion
The AR-NSP scheme provides a robust solution for enhancing physical layer security in IoT networks. By dynamically adjusting security margins based on real-time signal quality, it overcomes the limitations of static directional modulation. Future research will focus on extending this framework to multi-user scenarios and more complex scattering environments where multi-path fading presents additional challenges for DOA estimation.
Summary updated