Secure and Energy-Efficient Beamforming for Simultaneous Information and Energy Transfer

Ali A. Nasir, Hoang Duong Tuan, Trung Q. Duong, H. Vincent Poor

Abstract

Next-generation communication networks will likely involve the energy-efficient transfer of information and energy over the same wireless channel, for which the physical layer will become more vulnerable to cyber attacks by potential multi-antenna eavesdroppers. To address this issue, this paper considers transmit time-switching (TS) mode, in which energy and information signals are transmitted separately in time by the BS. This protocol is not only easy to implement but also delivers the opportunity of multi-purpose beamforming, in which energy beamformers during wireless power transfer are useful in jamming the eavesdropper. In the presence of imperfect channel estimation and multi-antenna eavesdroppers, the energy and information beamformers and the transmit TS ratio are jointly optimized to maximize the worst-case user secrecy rate subject to UEs' harvested energy thresholds and a BS transmit power budget. New robust path-following algorithms, which involve one simple convex quadratic program at each iteration are proposed for computational solutions of this difficult optimization problem and also the problem of secure energy efficiency maximization. Numerical results confirm that the performance of the proposed computational solutions is robust against the channel uncertainties.

Introduction

As wireless networks evolve toward 5G and 6G, Simultaneous Wireless Information and Power Transfer (SWIPT) has emerged as a critical technology. These systems enable base stations (BSs) to deliver both data and microwave energy to low-power Internet of Things (IoT) devices. However, the dual nature of these transmissions introduces significant security risks. High-power energy signals can be easily intercepted by malicious eavesdroppers, and the complexity of hardware required for traditional Power Splitting (PS) at the receiver remains a barrier to widespread adoption.

Furthermore, practical implementation is hindered by imperfect Channel State Information (CSI). Most theoretical models assume perfect knowledge of the wireless environment, but real-world channel estimation is inherently noisy. This paper proposes a robust framework using Transmit Time-Switching (TS) to address these security and efficiency challenges under realistic, imperfect CSI conditions.

System Architecture

The proposed system considers a multicell interference scenario where multiple base stations serve two types of users: Energy Harvesting-Information Decoding (EH-ID) users and Information Decoding (ID) users. EH-ID users are typically located closer to the BS to maximize energy harvesting efficiency, while ID users are positioned further away in the network periphery.

System model of the multicell SWIPT network with eavesdroppers.

As shown in Figure 1, the network also includes potential multi-antenna eavesdroppers (EVs) that attempt to intercept the information signals. The BSs employ a Transmit TS protocol, switching between an energy transmission phase and an information transmission phase. This approach shifts the implementation complexity to the Base Station's optimization software rather than the user's battery-constrained device.

Optimization Framework and Methodology

The core innovation lies in "multi-purpose beamforming." During the energy phase, the beamformers are optimized not only to charge the EH-ID users but also to act as artificial noise to jam the eavesdroppers. Since the eavesdroppers are unaware of the switching schedule, they perceive the energy signal as interference, enhancing the secrecy of the subsequent information phase.

The mathematical challenge involves maximizing the "worst-case" secrecy rate—the rate at which information can be sent without being decodable by an eavesdropper—under channel uncertainty. This is a non-convex optimization problem. The authors developed robust path-following algorithms that decompose the problem into a series of simple convex quadratic programs. These algorithms jointly optimize:

  1. Information Beamformers: To maximize data throughput to legitimate users.
  2. Energy Beamformers: To meet energy harvesting thresholds and provide jamming.
  3. Time-Switching Ratio ($\eta$): To balance the time allocated to energy vs. information transfer.

Results and Discussion

Numerical simulations were conducted using a 3-cell topology with Rician fading channels and a path loss exponent of 3. Key findings include:

  • Convergence: The proposed algorithms demonstrate fast convergence, typically within 20–25 iterations, making them computationally viable for real-time applications.
  • Secrecy Gains: The TS-based approach outperformed traditional PS models, achieving a secrecy rate gain of approximately 0.5 bits/sec/Hz.
  • Robustness: The "worst-case" optimization approach proved resilient to channel estimation errors. Even with significant uncertainty ($\epsilon$), the secrecy rates remained close to the perfect CSI baseline.
  • Rate-Energy Trade-off: The results highlight a natural trade-off: increasing the harvested energy threshold for users necessitates more power or time for the energy phase, which naturally reduces the available power for information decoding and the achievable secrecy rate.

Conclusion

This research provides a practical and secure framework for next-generation SWIPT networks. By leveraging Transmit Time-Switching and multi-purpose beamforming, the proposed system achieves high secrecy and energy efficiency without requiring complex receiver hardware. Future work will focus on incorporating non-linear energy harvesting models to better reflect physical circuit behavior and exploring scenarios with high user mobility and blind eavesdropper channel conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Next-generation communication networks will likely involve the energy-efficient transfer of information and energy over the same wireless channel, for which the physical layer will become more vulnerable to cyber attacks by potential multi-antenna eavesdroppers. To address this issue, this paper considers transmit time-switching (TS) mode, in which energy and information signals are transmitted separately in time by the BS. This protocol is not only easy to implement but also delivers the opportunity of multi-purpose beamforming, in which energy beamformers during wireless power transfer are useful in jamming the eavesdropper. In the presence of imperfect channel estimation and multi-antenna eavesdroppers, the energy and information beamformers and the transmit TS ratio are jointly optimized to maximize the worst-case user secrecy rate subject to UEs' harvested energy thresholds and a BS transmit power budget. New robust path-following algorithms, which involve one simple convex quadratic program at each iteration are proposed for computational solutions of this difficult optimization problem and also the problem of secure energy efficiency maximization. The latter is further complex due to additional optimization variables appearing in the denominator of the secrecy rate function. Numerical results confirm that the performance of the proposed computational solutions is robust against the channel uncertainties.
BibTeX
@article{nasir2017secure,
  author = {Ali A. Nasir and Hoang Duong Tuan and Trung Q. Duong and H. Vincent Poor},
  title = {{Secure and Energy-Efficient Beamforming for Simultaneous Information and Energy Transfer}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1109/twc.2017.2749568},
}
Figure