Secrecy Rate Maximization of RIS-Assisted SWIPT Systems: A Two-Timescale Beamforming Design Approach

Ming-Min Zhao, Kaidi Xu, Yunlong Cai, Yong Niu, Lajos Hanzo

Secrecy Rate Maximization of RIS-assisted SWIPT Systems: A Two-Timescale Beamforming Design Approach

TL;DR

This paper introduces a two-timescale optimization framework for secure wireless systems that simultaneously transmit data and power (SWIPT) using Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS). By splitting the design into long-term RIS phase shifts (based on channel statistics) and short-term base station beamforming (based on instantaneous effective CSI), the authors maximize the secrecy rate while significantly reducing the overhead and complexity typical of RIS-aided systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In Simultaneous Wireless Information and Power Transfer (SWIPT) systems, a base station (BS) sends data to an Information User (IU) and energy to multiple Energy Users (EUs). A major security headache arises because EUs are typically located close to the BS to harvest enough energy, which also makes them prime candidates for eavesdropping on the IU’s data.

Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS)—arrays of passive elements that "steer" radio waves—can help by boosting the IU's signal and nulling interference at the EUs. However, traditional RIS optimization requires "instantaneous" Channel State Information (CSI) for every single reflecting element. In practice, this leads to massive signaling overhead and computational lag, as the RIS must be re-optimized every few milliseconds. The authors tackle this by asking: Can we achieve high security and energy efficiency without needing full, real-time CSI for the RIS?

Methods

The authors propose a two-timescale transmission protocol:

  1. Long-term (Slow): The RIS phase shifts are updated based on the statistics (distributions) of the channels, which change slowly.
  2. Short-term (Fast): The BS transmit beamforming (for both data and energy) is updated based on the effective instantaneous CSI—a much lower-dimensional version of the channel that is easier to estimate.

To solve the resulting non-convex, non-smooth stochastic optimization problem, they developed:

  • SA-SSCA (Smooth Approximation aided Stochastic Successive Convex Approximation): Since the "worst-case" secrecy rate involves a non-differentiable "max" function (over multiple potential eavesdroppers), the authors used a Log-Sum-Exp approximation to smooth the objective, making it mathematically tractable.
  • CCCP-BCD: An inner algorithm that combines the Concave-Convex Procedure and Block Coordinate Descent to efficiently solve the short-term beamforming subproblems.
  • Low-Complexity Heuristic: A simplified approach that balances the effective channel power between the IU and EUs, providing a "quick and dirty" alternative to the full stochastic optimization.

Datasets

As is standard for theoretical physical-layer communications research, the paper does not use a static external dataset. Instead, it employs Monte Carlo simulations based on:

  • 3D Coordinate Models: Simulating a BS, an RIS, one IU, and six EUs in a defined spatial layout.
  • Rician Fading Channels: Modeling both line-of-sight and scattered signal paths.
  • Path Loss Models: Using standard exponents for BS-RIS and RIS-user links to reflect realistic signal attenuation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Aha" Moment on CSI: You don't need to know exactly how every RIS element interacts with the environment in real-time. Optimizing the RIS based on the average behavior of the channel (statistics) captures most of the beamforming gain while slashing the "CSI tax."
  • Energy Beams as Noise: The energy beams intended for EUs are treated as a form of "artificial noise" for the eavesdroppers. This dual-purpose use of the energy signal helps mask the information signal intended for the IU.
  • Smoothing the Max: The transition from a non-smooth "worst-case" objective to a smooth approximation (Lemma 1) is the key enabler for using stochastic gradient-based methods in this complex environment.
  • Heuristic Effectiveness: The proposed low-complexity heuristic, which simply tries to maximize the ratio of IU channel power to EU channel power, performs remarkably close to the complex SA-SSCA algorithm, suggesting a practical path for real-time hardware implementation.

Key Results

  • Secrecy Gains: The proposed algorithms significantly outperformed benchmark schemes (like random phase shifts or simply maximizing the IU's signal power) across various power budgets.
  • Robustness to Delay: Unlike "instantaneous CSI" schemes, which see performance collapse as CSI becomes outdated (due to processing/estimation delays), the two-timescale approach remains nearly invariant to CSI delay.
  • Quantization: The study found that using just 2 or 3 bits of phase control per RIS element (discrete shifts) achieves performance nearly identical to "ideal" continuous phase shifts, which is great news for low-cost hardware.
  • Scalability: Increasing the number of RIS elements ($N_r$) provides a "higher aperture gain," which the algorithms successfully exploit to improve the secrecy rate even as the number of potential eavesdroppers increases.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Information User: The current model focuses on a single IU. While the authors mention the algorithm is applicable to multiple IUs, the specific interference dynamics of a multi-IU secure SWIPT system remain to be fully explored.
  • Single-Antenna Users: The users (IU/EUs) are assumed to have only one antenna. Extending this to multi-antenna (MIMO) users would add another layer of beamforming complexity.
  • Perfect Statistical CSI: The long-term design assumes the BS has accurate knowledge of the channel statistics. Future work could investigate how "estimation errors" in these statistics impact the long-term RIS configuration.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhao2023secrecy,
  author = {Ming-Min Zhao and Kaidi Xu and Yunlong Cai and Yong Niu and Lajos Hanzo},
  title = {{Secrecy Rate Maximization of RIS-Assisted SWIPT Systems: A Two-Timescale Beamforming Design Approach}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/twc.2022.3225969},
}
Figure