Secrecy Outage Analysis of Mixed RF-FSO Downlink SWIPT Systems

Hongjiang Lei, Zhijun Dai, Ki-Hong Park, Weijia Lei, Gaofeng Pan, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

Abstract

This paper provides a rigorous mathematical framework for understanding the security of hybrid communication systems that utilize both lasers and radio waves while simultaneously powering remote devices. The authors derive the first comprehensive secrecy analysis for a downlink system combining a Free Space Optical (FSO) backhaul with a Radio Frequency (RF) hop supporting Simultaneous Wireless Information and Power Transfer (SWIPT). They identify specific physical factors—such as atmospheric turbulence and antenna counts—that set the fundamental limits of the system's security.

Introduction

Modern wireless networks are increasingly adopting hybrid architectures. A common setup uses a high-speed FSO laser link to connect a data center to a local relay, which then broadcasts data to users via traditional RF signals. While FSO is inherently secure due to its narrow beam, the RF "last mile" is vulnerable to eavesdroppers.

Furthermore, many next-generation Internet of Things (IoT) nodes are battery-constrained. SWIPT technology allows these nodes to harvest energy from the radio signals used to transmit data. However, diverting signal power to a battery leaves less power for decoding information, potentially making the system more susceptible to noise and interception. A core challenge addressed here is the correlation problem: in a downlink scenario, the performance of both the legitimate user and the eavesdropper is tied to the same FSO link, complicating the mathematical analysis of secrecy.

System Model and Methodology

The authors investigate a dual-hop system: Source $\rightarrow$ FSO $\rightarrow$ Relay $\rightarrow$ RF $\rightarrow$ Destination/Eavesdropper.

System model of the mixed FSO-RF downlink with SWIPT and an eavesdropper.

Channel Modeling and Relaying

  • FSO Link: Modeled using the Gamma-Gamma distribution to account for atmospheric turbulence and "pointing errors" (misalignment).
  • RF Link: Modeled using the Nakagami-$m$ distribution. The destination uses Maximum Ratio Combining (MRC) to leverage multiple antennas.
  • Relaying Protocol: A Decode-and-Forward (DF) relay decodes the optical signal and re-encodes it into a radio broadcast.
  • Receiver Architecture: The destination employs Power Splitting (PS) to divide the incoming RF signal between an energy harvester and an information decoder.

Mathematical Derivation

To handle the complex probability distributions, the authors employ Meijer’s G-functions. They use the law of total probability to decouple the correlated Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNRs) of the user and the eavesdropper, allowing them to derive closed-form expressions for the Secrecy Outage Probability (SOP). These derivations were validated using extensive Monte-Carlo simulations based on standard physical parameters like turbulence strength and noise power.

Key Insights and Results

  • Secrecy Diversity Order (SDO): The authors identify that the rate at which security improves as signal power increases is limited by the weakest link. The SDO is determined by the minimum of four factors: RF fading/antenna count, FSO pointing error, and the two atmospheric turbulence parameters.
  • The Secrecy Floor: Increasing power at the relay does not always improve security indefinitely. Eventually, the SOP hits a "floor" because the FSO link becomes the absolute bottleneck for the entire system.
  • Detection Technology: Results show that Heterodyne Detection (HD) at the relay provides significantly better secrecy performance than Intensity Modulation with Direct Detection (IM/DD).
  • The SWIPT Penalty: There is a clear trade-off: as more power is allocated to energy harvesting, the secrecy capacity degrades. Security and self-powering are competing objectives.
  • Atmospheric Impact: The analysis quantifies how pointing errors and strong turbulence can drastically increase the likelihood of a secrecy outage, even if the RF link is strong.

Limitations and Future Work

While the study provides exact and asymptotic expressions for the SOP, it utilizes a linear energy harvesting model. In practice, EH circuits are non-linear, which could alter results at extreme power levels. Future work could investigate dynamic power splitting that adapts to channel conditions and multi-relay systems with active jamming or relay selection to further harden these hybrid networks against sophisticated attackers.

Summary updated

Abstract

We analyze a secure dual-hop mixed radio frequency-free space optical (RF-FSO) downlink simultaneous wireless information and power transfer system. The FSO link and all RF links experience Gamma-Gamma, independent, and identical Nakagami-m fading, respectively. We analyze the effects of atmospheric turbulence, pointing error, detection technology, path loss, and energy harvesting on secrecy performance. Signalto-noise ratios at both the legitimate and illegitimate receivers are not independent since they are both simultaneously influenced by the FSO link. We derive the closed-form expression of the secrecy outage probability (SOP) as well as the asymptotic result for SOP when signal-to-noise ratios at relay and legitimate destinations tend to infinity. Monte-Carlo simulations are performed to verify the accuracy of our analysis. The results show that the secrecy diversity order (SDO) depends on the fading parameter of the relay-destination link and the number of the destination's antennas. In addition, the SDO also depends on the fading parameters, the pointing error parameter, and the detection type of the FSO link.
BibTeX
@article{lei2018secrecy,
  author = {Hongjiang Lei and Zhijun Dai and Ki-Hong Park and Weijia Lei and Gaofeng Pan and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Secrecy Outage Analysis of Mixed RF-FSO Downlink SWIPT Systems}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=dlwHs9RhgVE},
}
Figure