Secrecy Outage Analysis for Cooperative NOMA Systems with Relay Selection Scheme

Hongjiang Lei, Zixuan Yang, Ki-Hong Park, Imran Shafique Ansari, Yongcai Guo, Gaofeng Pan, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

Abstract: This paper considers the secrecy outage performance of a multiple-relay assisted non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) network over Nakagami-$m$ fading channels. Two slots are utilized to transmit signals from the base station to destination. At the first slot, the base station broadcasts the superposition signal of the two users to all decode-and-forward relays by message mapping strategy. Then the selected relay transmits superposition signal to the two users via power-domain NOMA technology. Three relay selection (RS) schemes, i.e., optimal single relay selection (OSRS) scheme, two-step single relay selection (TSRS) scheme, and optimal dual relay selection (ODRS) scheme, are proposed and the secrecy outage performance are analyzed. As a benchmark, we also examine the secrecy outage performance of the NOMA systems with traditional multiple relays combining (TMRC) scheme in which all the relay that successfully decode signals from the source forward signals to the NOMA users with equal power. Considering the correlation between the secrecy capacity of two users and different secrecy requirement for two NOMA users, the closed-form expressions for the security outage probability (SOP) of the proposed OSRS, TSRS, and ODRS schemes along with the TMRC scheme are derived and validated via simulations. To get more insights, we also derive the closed-form expressions for the asymptotic SOP for all the schemes with fixed and dynamic power allocations. Furthermore, the secrecy diversity order (SDO) of cooperative NOMA systems is obtained. The results demonstrate that our proposed schemes can significantly enhance the secrecy performance compared to the TMRC scheme and that all the RS schemes with fixed power allocation obtain zero SDO and the OSRS scheme with dynamic power allocation obtains the same SDO as TMRC.

Introduction

In the landscape of 5G and beyond, Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) has emerged as a key technology for improving spectral efficiency by allowing multiple users to share the same time-frequency resources through power-domain multiplexing. To extend coverage and improve reliability for cell-edge users, cooperative NOMA—where intermediate relays assist in signal transmission—is often employed. However, the broadcast nature of wireless channels makes these systems inherently vulnerable to eavesdropping.

While traditional security relies on upper-layer encryption, Physical Layer Security (PLS) leverages the physical characteristics of the wireless channel to secure communications. This paper addresses the challenge of securing cooperative NOMA networks against powerful eavesdroppers capable of multi-user detection. Unlike previous studies that treat user secrecy as independent, this work accounts for the high correlation between the secrecy capacities of NOMA users and their varying Quality of Service (QoS) requirements.

System Model and Proposed Schemes

The system model consists of a source (S), a pool of $K$ decode-and-forward (DF) relays ($R_k$), two NOMA users ($U_1$ and $U_2$), and an eavesdropper (E), as illustrated in Figure 1. The communication occurs in two time slots: first, the source broadcasts to the relays; second, a selected relay set forwards the signal to the users.

System model of a cooperative NOMA network with multiple relays and an eavesdropper.

To mitigate secrecy outages, the authors propose three novel Relay Selection (RS) schemes:

  1. Optimal Single Relay Selection (OSRS): Selects the single relay from the successful decoding set that minimizes the overall system Secrecy Outage Probability (SOP).
  2. Two-Step Single Relay Selection (TSRS): A QoS-driven approach that first filters relays based on the weaker user's security threshold and then selects the one maximizing the stronger user's secrecy rate.
  3. Optimal Dual Relay Selection (ODRS): A cooperative jamming strategy. One relay forwards the data, while a second relay (from those that failed to decode the source signal) acts as a jammer, broadcasting artificial noise to confuse the eavesdropper.

These are compared against the Traditional Multiple Relays Combining (TMRC) scheme, where all successful relays forward the signal with equal power.

Key Insights and Results

Through rigorous mathematical derivation using Gaussian-Chebyshev quadrature and Monte Carlo simulations, several critical insights were revealed:

  • Performance Gains: Both OSRS and ODRS significantly outperform the TMRC baseline. The ODRS scheme, by "recycling" failed relays as jammers, provides the highest level of security, provided the jamming power is optimally allocated.
  • Scheme Equivalence: Mathematical analysis surprisingly shows that the TSRS and OSRS schemes yield identical SOP expressions, suggesting that local QoS-driven selection can achieve global optimality in this context.
  • The Power Allocation Bottleneck: A vital finding is the impact of power allocation on the Secrecy Diversity Order (SDO). Under Fixed Power Allocation (FPA), all schemes exhibit an SDO of zero, meaning security does not improve indefinitely with increased transmit power due to inter-user interference. However, Dynamic Power Allocation (DPA) removes this ceiling, allowing the system to achieve full secrecy diversity.
  • Correlated Vulnerability: The model confirms that if an eavesdropper can compromise one NOMA user, the other is likely compromised as well, highlighting the importance of joint secrecy analysis.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research demonstrates that intelligent relay selection and cooperative jamming can substantially bolster the physical layer security of NOMA networks. While the ODRS scheme offers superior protection, its practical implementation requires precise Channel State Information (CSI) and synchronization for users to cancel out the artificial noise. Future research directions include investigating these schemes under conditions of imperfect Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) and developing closed-form strategies for dynamic power allocation in jamming scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper considers the secrecy outage performance of a multiple-relay assisted non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) network over Nakagami-$m$ fading channels. Two slots are utilized to transmit signals from the base station to destination. At the first slot, the base station broadcasts the superposition signal of the two users to all decode-and-forward relays by message mapping strategy. Then the selected relay transmits superposition signal to the two users via power-domain NOMA technology. Three relay selection (RS) schemes, i.e., optimal single relay selection (OSRS) scheme, two-step single relay selection (TSRS) scheme, and optimal dual relay selection (ODRS) scheme, are proposed and the secrecy outage performance are analyzed. As a benchmark, we also examine the secrecy outage performance of the NOMA systems with traditional multiple relays combining (TMRC) scheme in which all the relay that successfully decode signals from the source forward signals to the NOMA users with equal power. Considering the correlation between the secrecy capacity of two users and different secrecy requirement for two NOMA users, the closed-form expressions for the security outage probability (SOP) of the proposed OSRS, TSRS, and ODRS schemes along with the TMRC scheme are derived and validated via simulations. To get more insights, we also derive the closed-form expressions for the asymptotic SOP for all the schemes with fixed and dynamic power allocations. Furthermore, the secrecy diversity order (SDO) of cooperative NOMA systems is obtained. The results demonstrate that our proposed schemes can significantly enhance the secrecy performance compared to the TMRC scheme and that all the RS schemes with fixed power allocation obtain zero SDO and the OSRS scheme with dynamic power allocation obtains the same SDO as TMRC.
BibTeX
@article{lei2019secrecy,
  author = {Hongjiang Lei and Zixuan Yang and Ki-Hong Park and Imran Shafique Ansari and Yongcai Guo and Gaofeng Pan and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Secrecy Outage Analysis for Cooperative NOMA Systems with Relay Selection Scheme}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=CzMf0Xy9b0e},
}
Figure