Seating preference analysis for hybrid workplaces

Mohammad Saiedur Rahaman, Shaw Kudo, Tim Rawling, Yongli Ren, Flora D. SalimarXiv 2020 · arXiv

Introduction

As global workplaces transition toward hybrid models, the implementation of "hot-desking" and flexible seating has become a standard strategy for optimizing space and reducing overhead costs. However, these organizational shifts often overlook the nuanced psychological and functional requirements of individual employees. This study investigates the impact of seating arrangements on worker productivity and stress, positing that seating is never a "neutral" factor in the professional environment.

Methodology

The research was conducted through a survey-based study at the Melbourne office of Arup, a global engineering and design firm. The study involved 37 volunteer professionals from specialized backgrounds, including mechanical and structural engineers, building scientists, and acoustics experts.

At the time of the study, the office utilized an activity-based working model with no assigned cubicles. In consultation with behavioral scientists, the researchers designed a survey to log specific seating preferences and identify "productivity constraints"—factors that participants perceived as hindrances to their effective performance. The resulting data provides deep insight into the needs of "knowledge workers" who must balance high-concentration tasks with frequent collaboration.

Analysis of Seating Preferences

A primary finding of the study is the debunking of the "no preference" myth. Every participant identified specific environmental requirements necessary for their peak performance. The data reveals a clear hierarchy in what workers value most in their physical workspace.

Distribution of seating preferences among study participants.

Social connectivity emerged as the top priority, with 83.78% of participants expressing a desire to sit near their team members. This suggests that in a hybrid world, the primary utility of the physical office is its capacity to facilitate social and collaborative interaction. Additionally, 70.27% of participants preferred proximity to windows, likely due to the benefits of natural light on mood and circadian health. Conversely, only a small fraction of workers preferred to sit alone or near high-traffic areas like the kitchen or entryways.

Productivity Constraints in the Modern Office

While workers prioritize proximity to their teams, this desire creates a "noise paradox." Although collaboration is sought after, noise level was cited as a primary productivity constraint by 64.86% of respondents. This highlights a significant design challenge for hybrid offices: balancing the need for team proximity with the requirement for acoustic privacy.

Identified constraints affecting worker productivity.

Beyond environmental factors, operational elements significantly impact perceived productivity. The number of project involvements (~80%) and the necessity for face-to-face interaction (78.38%) were rated as more substantial constraints than traditional environmental factors like thermal comfort, air quality, or visual privacy. This indicates that for specialized knowledge workers, the complexity of their workload and the quality of their professional interactions are the most significant determinants of their output.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study concludes that seating preferences are highly individualized and directly linked to productivity. While the sample size is modest (n=37) and the data was collected prior to the widespread adoption of post-COVID social distancing protocols, the insights remain highly relevant for designing effective hybrid work environments.

Future research should explore office seating as a mathematical optimization problem, potentially utilizing AI-driven recommender systems to suggest optimal seating and scheduling based on project requirements. Additionally, the integration of IoT sensors for real-time tracking of noise, light, and air quality could empower workers to better manage their own productivity constraints, whether working from home or in a shared office space.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to the increasing nature of flexible work and the recent requirements from COVID-19 restrictions, workplaces are becoming more hybrid (i.e. allowing workers to work between traditional office spaces and elsewhere including from home). Since workplaces are different in design, layout and available facilities, many workers find it difficult to adjust accordingly. Eventually, this impacts negatively towards work productivity and other related parameters including concentration, stress, and mood while at work. One of the key factors that causes this negative work experience is directly linked to the available seating arrangements. In this paper, we conduct an analysis to understand various seating preferences of 37 workers with varying demographics, using the data collected pre-COVID-19, and analyse the findings in the context of hybrid workplace settings. We also discuss a list of implications illustrating how our findings can be adapted across wider hybrid work settings.
BibTeX
@misc{rahaman2020seating,
  author = {Mohammad Saiedur Rahaman and Shaw Kudo and Tim Rawling and Yongli Ren and Flora D. Salim},
  title = {{Seating preference analysis for hybrid workplaces}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2007.15807},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2007.15807},
}
Figure