Searching for exotic scalars at fusion reactors

Chaja Baruch, Patrick J. Fitzpatrick, Tony Menzo, Yotam Soreq, Sokratis Trifinopoulos, Jure Zupan

TL;DR

Fusion reactors are typically viewed as the future of clean energy, but this paper proposes they could also be powerful "factories" for discovering dark sector particles. By leveraging the intense neutron flux within a reactor's lithium-rich breeding blankets, researchers could produce and detect light exotic scalars and pseudoscalars, potentially setting the world's most stringent constraints on how these mysterious particles interact with ordinary matter.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Physicists are hunting for "New Physics" (NP) beyond the Standard Model, specifically light, feebly interacting particles like axion-like particles (pseudoscalars) or exotic scalars. These particles are candidates for dark matter or mediators of new forces.

While previous searches have looked for these particles in the Sun or within nuclear fission reactors, fusion reactors offer a unique, high-intensity environment. Specifically, the deuterium-tritium (D-T) fusion process produces high-energy (14.1 MeV) neutrons. The challenge addressed here is quantifying exactly how many exotic particles these neutrons would produce when they hit the reactor walls and whether we could actually detect them over the background noise of the universe.

Methods

The authors developed a theoretical framework to estimate the flux of new particles from a fusion reactor and their subsequent detection. Key steps included:

  • Production Modeling: They analyzed nuclear transitions in "breeding blankets"—lithium-lined walls designed to create tritium fuel. When neutrons hit isotopes like $^6\text{Li}$, $^7\text{Li}$, or structural $^{56}\text{Fe}$, they can trigger transitions that emit exotic scalars ($\phi$) or pseudoscalars ($a$) instead of standard gamma rays.
  • Theoretical Benchmarks: They used Effective Field Theory (EFT) to describe the couplings between these new particles and nucleons (protons/neutrons). For scalars, where data is scarcer, they employed Naive Dimensional Analysis (NDA) to estimate production rates.
  • Detection Strategy: They proposed using deuterium dissociation ($\phi/a + d \to n + p$). This process has a clear energy threshold (2.2 MeV) and was famously used by the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO) to study solar neutrinos.
  • Recasting Existing Bounds: As a secondary contribution, they took existing data from the SNO experiment (originally intended for axions) and mathematically "recast" it to set new limits on CP-even scalars.

Datasets

The study relied on several established nuclear and reactor physics databases:

  • NGATLAS: Used for neutron capture cross-sections.
  • EXFOR: Used for neutron scattering cross-sections on Li and Fe.
  • FISPACT-II: Provided the incident neutron flux spectra for benchmark reactor designs (specifically the ITER and WCLL DT models).
  • EU DEMO: The authors used the design parameters of the proposed European Demonstration Fusion Power Plant as their primary benchmark for a future facility.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Breeding Blanket as a Target: The very component needed to make fusion self-sustaining (the lithium blanket) acts as a massive, high-efficiency target for producing dark sector particles.
  • Fusion vs. Fission Advantage: Fusion neutrons are much more energetic (14.1 MeV) than those from fission. This allows them to excite nuclear states that are inaccessible in traditional reactors, opening new "windows" into the dark sector.
  • Clean Detection Channel: Deuterium dissociation is an exceptionally "clean" signal. Because the reactor's own neutrino emissions are too low-energy to trigger this reaction, the primary background is just solar neutrinos, which can be accounted for by monitoring the detector when the reactor is off.
  • Scalar Sensitivity: The paper highlights that scalars are actually easier to detect via deuterium dissociation than pseudoscalars (ALPs) because the cross-section is significantly larger (by a factor of $\sim 10^5$ for 10 MeV particles).

Key Results

  • Leading Constraints: A one-year search at a future 2000 MW fusion reactor (like DEMO) could probe nucleon couplings ($g_{\phi p}$) down to $10^{-7}$ or $10^{-8}$. This would surpass current limits from stellar cooling and laboratory experiments.
  • Mass Range: The proposed method is most sensitive to particles in the 0.1 MeV to 10 MeV mass range.
  • SNO Recast: Their re-analysis of SNO data provided a new, robust bound on light scalars that was previously missing from the literature.
  • Comparison to Kaon Decays: In many models, this fusion-based search would be more sensitive than rare kaon decay searches ($K \to \pi + \text{invisible}$), which are currently the gold standard for this mass regime.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Theoretical Uncertainty: The scalar production rates rely on NDA, which carries significant uncertainty. The authors call for more dedicated nuclear matrix element calculations to refine these estimates.
  • Reactor Engineering: The estimates depend on specific blanket materials (like Water-Cooled Lithium-Lead). Changes in future reactor designs (e.g., using molten salts like FLiBe) would require updated flux calculations.
  • Backgrounds: While solar neutrinos are the main background, the authors suggest that future work could explore even more sensitive detection methods, such as coherent scattering on nano-spheres, to push the sensitivity even further.
  • Experimental Integration: The paper is a proof-of-concept; the next step would be studying the feasibility of placing a kiloton-scale heavy water detector within 10-20 meters of a high-radiation fusion environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract Part of the energy created in deuterium-tritium fusion reactors is carried away from plasma by a high-intensity neutron flux, which is then absorbed by the reactor’s inner walls. The neutron flux can be used to sustain the reaction by the following mechanism: the walls are coated with lithium-rich breeding blankets , in which a fraction of neutrons interacts with lithium, creating tritium, which can be, in turn, used a fuel for the main reaction. The interactions of neutrons with the materials within the breeding blanket can also result in the production of dark sector particles, feebly interacting light scalars or pseudoscalars, via nuclear transitions. We estimate the potential size of such dark sector flux outside the reactor and consider possible detection methods at current and future thermonuclear fusion reactors. In our analysis, we take into account all other current bounds, recasting also the SNO axion bound for a CP even scalar. We find that year-long searches at current and future reactors can set leading constraints on dark scalar- and dark pseudoscalar-nucleon couplings.
BibTeX
@article{baruch2025searching,
  author = {Chaja Baruch and Patrick J. Fitzpatrick and Tony Menzo and Yotam Soreq and Sokratis Trifinopoulos and Jure Zupan},
  title = {{Searching for exotic scalars at fusion reactors}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep10(2025)215},
}

Loading related content...

Figure