Heron: Visualizing and Controlling Chemical Reaction Explorations and Networks

Charlotte H. Müller, Miguel Steiner, Jan P. Unsleber, Thomas Weymuth, Moritz Bensberg, Katja‐Sophia Csizi, Maximilian Mörchen, Paul L. Türtscher, Markus Reiher

TL;DR

Heron is an open-source graphical user interface (GUI) designed to tame the complexity of automated chemical reaction discovery. By bridging the gap between high-throughput quantum chemistry and human intuition, it allows researchers to visualize massive reaction networks, "feel" molecular forces through haptic feedback, and steer automated discovery algorithms in real-time.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In recent years, computational chemistry has moved from simulating single molecules to automatically exploring entire "Reaction Networks"—vast maps of every possible transformation a chemical system might undergo. While powerful, this "first-principles" exploration creates a data deluge. A single starting material can lead to thousands of intermediates and side reactions, creating a "combinatorial explosion" that is impossible to navigate manually.

The challenge is two-fold:

  1. Complexity: How do you find the one relevant reaction path in a haystack of 10,000 nodes?
  2. Steering: How can a human researcher guide an autonomous "discovery engine" toward interesting chemistry without needing to be a coding expert?

Methods

Heron serves as the command center for the SCINE (Software for Chemical Interaction Networks) ecosystem. It integrates several sophisticated modules into a single, modular Python-based interface:

  • Interactive Quantum Mechanics (QM): Users can manipulate molecules in a 3D viewer. As you "pull" on an atom, the software recalculates the system's energy at 60 Hz, providing immediate visual feedback on stability and strain.
  • Haptic Force Feedback: By using specialized hardware (like a Touch™ device), researchers can literally feel the resistance of an energy barrier or the "snap" into a stable intermediate, turning abstract math into physical sensation.
  • The "Steering Wheel": This novel control class allows users to alternate between "Network Expansion" (letting the computer find new reactions) and "Selection" (filtering results based on chemical relevance).
  • Automated Refinement: It integrates autoCAS, a tool that uses quantum information theory to automatically select "active spaces" for high-level calculations—a task that traditionally requires years of expert experience.
  • Pathfinding & Microkinetics: It uses the PATHFINDER algorithm to identify the most kinetically likely routes between reactants and products, filtering out "dead-end" side reactions that don't contribute to the final yield.

Datasets

The authors demonstrate Heron’s capabilities using the Eschenmoser–Claisen rearrangement as a primary case study.

  • They provide a kinetically steered reaction network for this system, which is hosted on Zenodo (Ref 61 & 102).
  • The software itself is open-source and integrates with standard chemical formats like XYZ, PDB, and MOL.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Human-in-the-Loop Discovery: The paper argues that pure automation isn't enough. The most efficient discovery happens when a human provides the "chemical common sense" to prune the search tree while the computer handles the heavy lifting of quantum calculations.
  • Local vs. Global Visualization: Instead of trying to show a 10,000-node "hairball" graph, Heron focuses on "local regions" centered on a specific compound. This allows researchers to traverse the network step-by-step, much like a GPS for chemical space.
  • Interoperability is Key: The real "aha" moment is the seamless data transfer. You can find a transition state using a fast, low-level method, "feel" it with haptics, and then immediately send it to a high-level "black-box" correlated calculation for a final, accurate energy—all within the same GUI.

Key Results

  • Efficiency Gains: In the Claisen rearrangement example, using Heron’s "steered" exploration reduced the number of required reaction trials from 19,400 to 12,600.
  • Discovery Quality: Despite running fewer trials, the steered approach actually found more unique molecular aggregates (2,411 vs. 2,220) because it focused computational resources on the most promising regions of the network.
  • Accessibility: The GUI successfully lowers the "entrance barrier" for advanced techniques like multi-configurational calculations and QM/MM hybrid modeling, making them accessible to non-specialists.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hardware Requirements: While mouse-based interaction works, the full "haptic" experience requires specific force-feedback hardware that may not be available in every lab.
  • Visualization Density: Even with local views, extremely dense networks (like those in combustion or complex catalysis) still pose a challenge for 2D screen representations.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest further integration of machine learning models to provide even faster property predictions during interactive sessions and expanding the hybrid QM/MM (Quantum Mechanics/Molecular Mechanics) capabilities for even larger biomolecular systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Automated and high-throughput quantum chemical investigations into chemical processes have become feasible in great detail and broad scope. This results in an increase in complexity of the tasks and in the amount of generated data. An efficient and intuitive way for an operator to interact with these data and to steer virtual experiments is required. Here, we introduce Heron, a graphical user interface that allows for advanced human-machine interactions with quantum chemical exploration campaigns into molecular structure and reactivity. Heron offers access to interactive and automated explorations of chemical reactions with standard electronic structure modules, haptic force feedback, microkinetic modeling, and refinement of data by automated correlated calculations including black-box complete active space calculations. It is tailored to the exploration and analysis of vast chemical reaction networks. We show how interoperable modules enable advanced workflows and pave the way for routine low-entrance-barrier access to advanced modeling techniques.
BibTeX
@article{muller2024heron,
  author = {Charlotte H. Müller and Miguel Steiner and Jan P. Unsleber and Thomas Weymuth and Moritz Bensberg and Katja‐Sophia Csizi and Maximilian Mörchen and Paul L. Türtscher and Markus Reiher},
  title = {{Heron: Visualizing and Controlling Chemical Reaction Explorations and Networks}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry A},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpca.4c03936},
}
Figure