scaling study of the non-perturbative renormalized quenched quark mass

Thorsten Kurth, Stephan Dürr, Z. Fodor, Christian Hoelbling, S. D. Katz, Stefan Krieg, Laurent Lellouch, Thomas Lippert, Kálman Szabó, G. Vulvert

Abstract

This study investigates the scaling behavior of the 2 HEX action in Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). By computing the $N_f = 3$ hadron spectrum and comparing results to the previous 6 EXP action, we identify a broad scaling window extending up to 0.15 fm. Scaling corrections for hadron masses are minimal, at approximately the 2% level. Furthermore, we examine the non-perturbatively renormalized quenched strange quark mass, finding flat scaling behavior and excellent agreement with existing literature. These results validate the 2 HEX action as a robust framework for high-precision simulations on relatively coarse lattices.

Introduction

In Lattice QCD, simulating the strong force requires discretizing spacetime into a 4D grid with spacing $a$. To reach physical predictions, researchers must extrapolate to the continuum limit ($a \to 0$). However, finer lattices significantly increase computational costs, while coarse lattices introduce discretization errors. To address this, "smeared" actions are used to smooth interactions between quarks and gluons. This paper validates the 2 HEX action, which utilizes two iterations of Hypercubic (HYP) smearing combined with analytic stout (EXP) links, demonstrating its superior scaling properties and numerical stability.

Methodology

The study employs a tree-level improved Symanzik gauge action and a tree-level improved clover-action for fermions. The 2 HEX smearing approach is specifically designed to improve the chirality of quarks on the lattice. The researchers calculated the masses of octet (e.g., nucleon) and decuplet (e.g., Delta) baryons for three quark flavors ($N_f = 3$).

For quark mass renormalization, the non-perturbative RI (Regularization Independent) method was used. A key technical choice was the use of the Vector Ward Identity (VWI) to calculate wave-function renormalization, which avoids the numerical noise typically associated with discrete derivatives. The team tested two scaling assumptions—$O(\alpha a)$ and $O(a^2)$—to characterize the approach to the continuum limit.

Key Insights: Scaling and Stability

A primary finding is the remarkably broad scaling window of the 2 HEX action, which remains accurate up to $a \approx 0.15$ fm. While the action is formally $O(\alpha a)$ improved, the empirical data suggests it behaves more like an $O(a^2)$ improved action, indicating that the smearing effectively suppresses leading-order discretization errors.

Hadron mass scaling for $M_\Delta$ and $M_N$ under $O(\alpha a)$ and $O(a^2)$ assumptions, showing a broad scaling window.

Furthermore, the 2 HEX action significantly reduces the condition number of the Wilson-Dirac operator. This improvement in numerical behavior makes it computationally feasible to simulate lighter quarks with greater stability.

Results and Discussion

The scaling corrections for the Delta baryon mass were observed to be minimal, around 2% even at coarse lattice spacings of 0.16 fm. The study determined the non-perturbatively renormalized quenched strange quark mass to be: $$m_s^{\text{MS}}(2\text{ GeV}) = 101.4 \pm 1.5 (\text{stat}) \pm 1.1 (\text{syst}) \text{ MeV}$$

The renormalization factors themselves showed stable behavior across different lattice spacings, as illustrated by the ratio of renormalization constants at different scales.

Scaling of the ratio of scalar renormalization constants $Z_S^{RI}$ at two different scales vs. $(a/r_0)^2$.

The product of the average light/strange quark mass and the Sommer scale $r_0$ was found to be $[(m_s + m_{ud})r_0]^{\text{MS}}(2\text{ GeV}) = 0.2609(39)(28)$, which aligns perfectly with previous high-profile results in the field.

Conclusion

The 2 HEX action demonstrates excellent scaling properties and numerical stability, providing a reliable path for high-precision Lattice QCD simulations. The broad scaling window allows for accurate results on coarser lattices, reducing the overall computational burden. These findings establish a solid foundation for future large-scale, fully dynamical simulations aimed at exploring particle physics phenomenology with unprecedented precision.

Summary updated

Abstract

The goal of this study is to investigate the scaling behaviour of our 2 HEX action. For this purpose, we compute the N f = 3 spectrum and compare the results to our 6 EXP action. We find a large scaling window up to 0.15 fm along with small scaling corrections at the 2%-level and full compatibility with our previous study. As a second important observable to be tested for scaling, we chose the non-perturbatively renormalized quenched strange quark mass. Here we find a fairly flat scaling with a broad scaling range up to 0.15 fm and perfect agreement with the literature.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kurth2011scaling,
  author = {Thorsten Kurth and Stephan Dürr and Z. Fodor and Christian Hoelbling and S. D. Katz and Stefan Krieg and Laurent Lellouch and Thomas Lippert and Kálman Szabó and G. Vulvert},
  title = {{scaling study of the non-perturbative renormalized quenched quark mass}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of The XXVIII International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory — PoS(Lattice 2010)},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.22323/1.105.0232},
}
Figure