Scalable Control Variates for Monte Carlo Methods Via Stochastic Optimization

Shijing Si, Chris J. Oates, Andrew B. Duncan, Lawrence Carin, François-Xavier Briol

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for developing scalable control variates (CVs) for Monte Carlo (MC) methods, particularly for high-dimensional and large-sample problems. By leveraging Stein operators and stochastic optimization, they achieve significant variance reduction and computational speedups compared to existing methods, making MC estimation more efficient in complex scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Monte Carlo (MC) methods are fundamental for approximating integrals, especially in Bayesian statistics where direct computation is often intractable. Control variates (CVs) are a powerful technique to reduce the variance of MC estimators, leading to more accurate results with fewer samples. However, for large-scale problems with high-dimensional data or massive sample sizes, the computational cost of constructing and using traditional CVs can become prohibitive, negating their benefits. This paper addresses this challenge by proposing a scalable and efficient approach to learn effective CVs that can handle these complex settings.

Methods

The core contribution of this paper is a unified framework for constructing and learning control variates.

  • Stein Operators for CV Construction: The authors generalize existing approaches (polynomials, kernels, neural networks) by framing CVs as functions derived from Stein operators. This provides a flexible and unified way to define a rich set of candidate CVs.
  • Variational Objective and Stochastic Optimization: Instead of relying on computationally expensive exact solutions, they propose learning the optimal CV by minimizing a variational objective using stochastic gradient descent (SGD). This approach is significantly more scalable for large datasets.
  • Theoretical Guarantees: The paper provides theoretical analysis, including conditions for achieving zero-variance CVs and convergence guarantees for the proposed SGD-based learning strategy.

Datasets

The paper evaluates their method on several benchmark datasets and real-world problems:

  • Genz Test Functions: A standard benchmark for numerical integration, used to test CV performance in challenging scenarios with sharp peaks and discontinuities.
  • Gaussian Process (GP) Integrands: Synthetically generated problems by modeling the integrand as a GP, allowing for controlled variation in complexity.
  • Bayesian Logistic Regression (Sonar and Madelon Datasets): Real-world datasets used to assess CV performance in high-dimensional classification tasks.
  • Ordinary Differential Equations (Lotka-Volterra): A problem from ecological modeling used to test parameter inference.
  • Atmospheric Pollutant Detection: A problem from LIDAR experiments for Bayesian inference.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Framework: The use of Stein operators elegantly unifies diverse CV construction methods (polynomials, kernels, NNs) under a single theoretical umbrella. This simplifies the landscape and allows for systematic comparison.
  • Scalability via SGD: Shifting from exact linear system solutions to stochastic gradient descent is the key to achieving scalability for large-scale problems. This dramatically reduces computational cost without sacrificing much accuracy.
  • Ensemble Methods Shine: Combining different types of CVs (e.g., kernels with polynomials) often leads to superior performance, offering greater flexibility and better variance reduction.
  • Theoretical Foundation: Providing theoretical guarantees for the proposed method builds confidence in its applicability and helps understand its behavior.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates significant improvements in both accuracy and computational efficiency:

  • Variance Reduction: CVs consistently achieve substantial mean absolute error (MAE) reduction compared to standard MC estimation across various problems. For instance, in the Genz benchmark, CVs reduced MAE by orders of magnitude.
  • Computational Speedups: The SGD-based approach offers significant speedups, especially for high-dimensional problems. For example, in the Sonar dataset experiment, SGD-trained CVs achieved comparable MAE to exact linear system solutions but with a fraction of the computational cost.
  • Performance Across CV Types: Ensemble methods (combinations of kernels and polynomials) and neural network-based CVs generally performed best, outperforming simpler polynomial or kernel CVs, especially in complex scenarios.
  • Scalability with Data Size: The performance of CVs generally improves with the size of the training dataset, and the SGD approach scales linearly with dataset size, unlike the cubic complexity of solving linear systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • NN Calibration Overhead: While NNs show strong performance, the paper notes that the "effective" compute time for NNs is higher due to the manual effort required for hyperparameter tuning and SGD calibration.
  • Other Stein Classes: The authors suggest exploring other Stein classes and operators, such as wavelets or different NN architectures, for potential further gains.
  • Parameterized Operators: Investigating parameterized Stein operators and including these parameters in the optimization scheme is proposed as a future direction.
  • General Manifolds: Extending CVs to more general spaces, like smooth manifolds or countable spaces, is also mentioned as a promising avenue for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Control variates are a well-established tool to reduce the variance of Monte Carlo estimators. However, for large-scale problems including high-dimensional and large-sample settings, their advantages can be outweighed by a substantial computational cost. This paper considers control variates based on Stein operators, presenting a framework that encompasses and generalizes existing approaches that use polynomials, kernels and neural networks. A learning strategy based on minimizing a variational objective through stochastic optimization is proposed, leading to scalable and effective control variates. Novel theoretical results are presented to provide insight into the variance reduction that can be achieved, and an empirical assessment, including applications to Bayesian inference, is provided in support.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{si2020scalable,
  author = {Shijing Si and Chris J. Oates and Andrew B. Duncan and Lawrence Carin and François-Xavier Briol},
  title = {{Scalable Control Variates for Monte Carlo Methods Via Stochastic Optimization}},
  booktitle = {MCQMC},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-030-98319-2\_10},
}
Figure