Safe Interval Randomized Path Planning For Manipulators

Nuraddin Kerimov, Aleksandr Onegin, Konstantin Yakovlev

TL;DR

This paper introduces SI-RRT, a novel path planning algorithm for robotic manipulators operating in dynamic environments with known obstacle trajectories. By combining the strengths of randomized sampling (RRT-Connect) and safe interval reasoning (SIPP), SI-RRT significantly outperforms existing state-of-the-art methods in terms of both planning speed and solution quality, especially in complex scenarios with many moving obstacles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Planning safe paths for robotic manipulators, especially those with many degrees of freedom (DoF), is a significant challenge. This problem becomes even more complex when the environment contains dynamic obstacles whose movements must be accounted for. Traditional path planning methods often struggle with the high dimensionality of manipulator configuration spaces and the added complexity of time-varying environments. While some methods consider time, they might not efficiently integrate it with sampling-based approaches for high-DoF systems. This paper tackles the gap of efficiently planning safe, time-aware paths for high-DoF manipulators in environments with known, predictable obstacle movements.

Methods

The core innovation of SI-RRT lies in its hybrid approach, merging two key techniques:

  • RRT-Connect (Rapidly-exploring Random Trees - Connect): This is a bidirectional, sampling-based motion planning algorithm known for its efficiency in high-dimensional spaces. It builds two trees, one from the start and one from the goal, and attempts to connect them.
  • SIPP (Safe Interval Path Planning): Originally a search-based planner, SIPP reasons about "safe intervals" – continuous time periods during which a robot configuration is collision-free. This allows for more efficient temporal reasoning than checking discrete time steps.

SI-RRT integrates SIPP's safe interval concept into the RRT-Connect framework. Each node in the RRT trees now represents not just a configuration but also a safe interval associated with that configuration. The algorithm efficiently computes these safe intervals by optimizing collision checking. For the start tree, it aims to reach configurations as early as possible, while for the goal tree, it aims to arrive as late as possible. A "wait-and-go" strategy is employed to handle temporal constraints, and a path trimming technique is used to optimize the final path.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors generated their own problem instances for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Safe Intervals are Crucial for Dynamic Environments: The paper strongly suggests that reasoning about continuous time intervals (safe intervals) is more effective than discrete time checks for dynamic environments, leading to better performance.
  • Bidirectional Search + Safe Intervals = Synergy: Combining the efficiency of bidirectional RRT-Connect with the temporal reasoning of SIPP creates a powerful planner that overcomes the limitations of each individual approach.
  • Optimized Collision Checking is Key: The authors developed a technique to speed up the computation of safe intervals by optimizing the collision checking process, which is critical for the planner's overall efficiency.
  • Time-Aware Planning Outperforms Reactive Methods: The experimental results clearly demonstrate that planners that explicitly reason about time (like SI-RRT and ST-RRT*) are superior to reactive replanning methods (like DRGBT) in these scenarios.

Key Results

  • Superior Success Rate: SI-RRT consistently achieved a higher success rate than its competitors, especially as the number of obstacles increased. For 200 obstacles, SI-RRT had a 77% success rate, compared to 42% for ST-RRT*.
  • Significantly Faster Runtime: On instances where both SI-RRT and ST-RRT* succeeded (up to 120 obstacles), SI-RRT was up to an order of magnitude faster, particularly for higher numbers of obstacles.
  • Better Solution Quality (Arrival Time): SI-RRT generally produced paths with earlier arrival times at the goal configuration compared to ST-RRT*, indicating more efficient path execution.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The paper assumes that inertial effects are neglected and the manipulator can move with constant velocity. * The current implementation does not include "anytime" capabilities, meaning it doesn't iteratively improve a found solution if more time is available.

Future Work: * Investigate the theoretical properties of SI-RRT. * Develop anytime variants of SI-RRT to gradually improve solution cost. * Explore the application of SI-RRT in multi-agent manipulation planning scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Planning safe paths in 3D workspace for high DoF robotic systems, such as manipulators, is a challenging problem, especially when the environment is populated with the dynamic obstacles that need to be avoided. In this case the time dimension should be taken into account that further increases the complexity of planning. To mitigate this issue we suggest to combine safe-interval path planning (a prominent technique in heuristic search) with the randomized planning, specifically, with the bidirectional rapidly-exploring random trees (RRT-Connect) - a fast and efficient algorithm for high-dimensional planning. Leveraging a dedicated technique of fast computation of the safe intervals we end up with an efficient planner dubbed SI-RRT. We compare it with the state of the art and show that SI-RRT consistently outperforms the competitors both in runtime and solution cost. Our implementation of SI-RRT is publicly available at https://github.com/PathPlanning/ManipulationPlanning-SI-RRT
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kerimov2024safe,
  author = {Nuraddin Kerimov and Aleksandr Onegin and Konstantin Yakovlev},
  title = {{Safe Interval Randomized Path Planning For Manipulators}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the International Conference on Automated Planning and Scheduling},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure