Abstract
Safe Bayesian optimization (BO) with Gaussian processes is an effective tool for tuning control policies in safety-critical real-world systems, specifically due to its sample efficiency and safety guarantees. However, most safe BO algorithms assume homoscedastic sub-Gaussian measurement noise, an assumption that does not hold in many relevant applications. In this article, we propose a straightforward yet rigorous approach for safe BO across noise models, including homoscedastic sub-Gaussian and heteroscedastic heavy-tailed distributions. We provide a high-probability bound on the measurement noise via the scenario approach, integrate these bounds into high probability confidence intervals, and prove safety and optimality for our proposed safe BO algorithm. We deploy our algorithm in synthetic examples and in tuning a controller for the Franka Emika manipulator in simulation.
Introduction
Bayesian Optimization (BO) is a preferred method for tuning robotic controllers due to its high sample efficiency. In safety-critical applications, such as a robotic arm operating near humans, "Safe BO" is essential to ensure that system constraints are never violated during the tuning process.
A significant limitation of existing Safe BO algorithms, such as the widely used SAFEOPT, is their reliance on the assumption of homoscedastic sub-Gaussian noise. This assumes measurement noise follows a predictable, uniform distribution regardless of the system's state. In practice, sensors often exhibit "heavy-tailed" noise (where outliers are more frequent than predicted by a Gaussian) or "heteroscedastic" noise (where noise levels vary with input parameters). Ignoring these characteristics leads to overly optimistic safety margins and potential catastrophic failures in real-world deployments.
Methodology: Scenario Programming for Safe BO
We introduce a flexible framework for Safe BO that operates across diverse noise models by leveraging scenario programming. This approach replaces rigid analytical assumptions with a data-driven method for bounding noise.
- Scenario-Based Noise Bounding: Instead of assuming a specific mathematical form for noise, we use the scenario approach. By sampling noise from a model or historical data, we solve an optimization problem to determine a high-probability bound on that noise.
- Simultaneous Confidence Intervals: We provide a mechanism to adjust these bounds dynamically, ensuring safety guarantees hold across all iterations of the optimization process.
- Robust Gaussian Process Surrogates: These scenario-based bounds are integrated into Gaussian Process (GP) surrogates. This allows the algorithm to construct "safe sets" that are robust to the specific, potentially complex, noise profile of the system.
- Theoretical Guarantees: We provide mathematical proofs that the algorithm maintains safety with high probability and converges to optimal parameters within a specified tolerance $\delta$.
Experimental Evaluation
The proposed algorithm was evaluated on two primary benchmarks: synthetic functions with heteroscedastic heavy-tailed noise (Student’s-t distributions) and a high-fidelity MuJoCo simulation of a Franka Emika manipulator. The goal for the robot task was to tune an LQR-based impedance controller for set-point tracking while respecting distance-to-target constraints.
Key Results
The core advantage of our approach is its ability to maintain safety where traditional methods fail. In synthetic tests with heavy-tailed noise, classic Safe BO algorithms frequently violated safety constraints, whereas our proposed algorithm remained safe throughout.
In the Franka Emika robot tuning task, the algorithm successfully converged to a high-reward parameter set within 200 iterations without a single safety violation. The algorithm started from a safe but low-performance initial guess and progressively improved performance while strictly adhering to safety constraints.
Furthermore, the computational overhead of the scenario approach is manageable. The number of required noise samples ($m_t$) scales linearly with desired accuracy ($\nu$) but only logarithmically with the confidence level ($\kappa$), allowing for extremely high confidence (e.g., 99.9%) without excessive computation.
Discussion and Limitations
While the proposed framework is robust, it relies on the ability to sample from the noise distribution. This requires either a high-fidelity simulator or sufficient prior data to construct a "noise oracle." Additionally, the inherent caution required to ensure safety under complex noise models may result in slower exploration compared to algorithms that assume simpler noise structures.
Future work will focus on developing data-driven noise oracles that can learn noise models online during the optimization process. We also aim to further optimize the growth rate of confidence parameters to enhance convergence speed without compromising safety.
Summary updated