S3: Learnable Sparse Signal Superdensity for Guided Depth Estimation

Yu-Kai Huang, Yueh-Cheng Liu, Tsung-Han Wu, Hung-Ting Su, Yu-Cheng Chang, Tsung-Lin Tsou, Yu-An Wang, Winston H. Hsu

Abstract

Dense depth estimation plays a key role in multiple applications such as robotics, 3D reconstruction, and augmented reality. While sparse signal, e.g., LiDAR and Radar, has been leveraged as guidance for enhancing dense depth estimation, the improvement is limited due to its low density and imbalanced distribution. To maximize the utility from the sparse source, we propose Sparse Signal Superdensity (S3) technique, which expands the depth value from sparse cues while estimating the confidence of expanded region. The proposed S3 can be applied to various guided depth estimation approaches and trained end-to-end at different stages, including input, cost volume and output. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness, robustness, and flexibility of the S3 technique on LiDAR and Radar signal.

Introduction: The Challenge of Sparse Guidance

Dense depth estimation—the task of calculating the distance to every pixel in an image—is fundamental for autonomous systems. While RGB images provide rich semantic context, depth estimation from a single view is inherently ill-posed. To mitigate this, researchers often incorporate sparse depth measurements from sensors like LiDAR or Radar as "anchors."

However, these sparse signals suffer from two primary limitations:

  1. Low Density: In standard benchmarks like KITTI, LiDAR data covers only about 4% of the image, and Radar is even sparser. When sparse points contradict a network's RGB-based prediction, the model often ignores the sparse guidance.
  2. Imbalanced Distribution: Sensors do not sample space uniformly. LiDAR's horizontal scanning pattern and Radar's poor horizontal resolution often result in "streaky" or non-smooth depth maps, where corrections only occur near the physical scan lines.

Methodology: Sparse Signal Superdensity ($S^3$)

The proposed $S^3$ (Sparse Signal Superdensity) framework is a "plug-and-play" module designed to transform individual sparse points into dense, reliable guidance patches.

Learnable Expansion

Unlike traditional methods that use fixed geometric rules, $S^3$ employs a lightweight U-Net to perform semantic-aware expansion. By analyzing a small RGB patch surrounding a sparse point, the module learns how depth should "flow" to neighboring pixels based on image features like edges and textures. This ensures that pixels belonging to the same object share similar depth expansion properties.

Confidence-Weighted Guidance

A critical component of $S^3$ is its ability to output a confidence map alongside the expanded depth. This map informs the primary depth-estimation model of the reliability of the expanded signal at every pixel. This is particularly vital at object boundaries, where depth changes are abrupt and expansion might otherwise introduce errors.

Versatile Integration

$S^3$ is highly flexible and can be integrated at various stages of a depth-estimation pipeline. It can replace raw sparse points at the input/output stages, guide the matching process in stereo vision cost volumes, or provide additional constraints for graph-based optimization in 3D space.

Experimental Results

The $S^3$ module was evaluated on industry-standard benchmarks, including SceneFlow, KITTI Stereo 2012/2015 (LiDAR), and nuScenes (Radar).

Qualitative comparison of depth estimation methods showing how S3 addresses low density and imbalanced distribution issues.

Key Findings

  • LiDAR Performance: On KITTI 2015, adding $S^3$ to a Guided Stereo Matching (GSM) baseline reduced the Average Disparity Error from 1.698 to 1.027, a significant improvement in precision.
  • Radar Robustness: $S^3$ effectively handled the noise and extreme sparsity of Radar data on nuScenes, reducing the Root Mean Squared (RMS) error from 6.62 to 3.64 when using LiDAR-like guidance.
  • Efficiency in Sparsity: Ablation studies revealed that $S^3$ with only 0.28% signal density outperformed standard methods using 20 times more data, demonstrating its extreme efficiency in data-poor environments.

Conclusion and Future Work

$S^3$ successfully bridges the gap between sparse sensor data and dense depth estimation by strengthening the guidance signal. While it significantly improves results, challenges remain in handling Radar's lack of elevation information and perfectly resolving razor-thin occlusion boundaries. Future research may explore incorporating temporal information from video sequences to further stabilize the superdensity maps.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dense depth estimation plays a key role in multiple applications such as robotics, 3D reconstruction, and augmented reality. While sparse signal, e.g., LiDAR and Radar, has been leveraged as guidance for enhancing dense depth estimation, the improvement is limited due to its low density and imbalanced distribution. To maximize the utility from the sparse source, we propose Sparse Signal Superdensity (S3) technique, which expands the depth value from sparse cues while estimating the confidence of expanded region. The proposed S3 can be applied to various guided depth estimation approaches and trained end-to-end at different stages, including input, cost volume and output. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness, robustness, and flexibility of the S3 technique on LiDAR and Radar signal.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2021s,
  author = {Yu-Kai Huang and Yueh-Cheng Liu and Tsung-Han Wu and Hung-Ting Su and Yu-Cheng Chang and Tsung-Lin Tsou and Yu-An Wang and Winston H. Hsu},
  title = {{S3: Learnable Sparse Signal Superdensity for Guided Depth Estimation}},
  booktitle = {IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=xfLvjOlXkq},
}
Figure