TL;DR
This paper introduces RobustSentEmbed, a novel self-supervised framework that generates robust sentence embeddings by combining adversarial perturbations with contrastive learning and a replaced token detection objective. It significantly improves resilience against adversarial attacks, outperforming existing methods in both robustness and generalization benchmarks.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) like BERT and GPT have revolutionized natural language processing, achieving state-of-the-art results on various tasks. However, despite their impressive generalization capabilities, PLM-based sentence embeddings often exhibit a critical vulnerability: poor robustness against adversarial attacks. These attacks involve making small, imperceptible modifications to input text that can drastically alter the model's output, leading to incorrect predictions. Existing research has highlighted this limitation, showing that current embeddings can be easily deceived. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method to create sentence embeddings that are both highly generalizable and robust to these adversarial manipulations.
Methods
The core of RobustSentEmbed lies in its novel approach to generating adversarial perturbations and integrating them into a self-supervised learning framework. The method involves an iterative process between an adversarial perturbation generator and the PLM encoder.
- Adversarial Perturbation Generator: This component generates "high-risk" perturbations at both the token and sentence levels. It extends existing token-level perturbation methods by incorporating sentence-level perturbations. The generator uses a combination of the Fast Gradient Sign Method (FGSM) and Projected Gradient Descent (PGD) techniques to systematically create adversarial examples.
- Robust Contrastive Learning Objective: The framework utilizes a contrastive learning objective that encourages similarity between the original sentence embedding and its adversarial counterpart. Crucially, it also incorporates the adversarial example as part of the "positive pair" in the contrastive loss, directly pushing the adversarial embedding closer to the original.
- Replaced Token Detection (RTD) Objective: Complementing the contrastive learning, RobustSentEmbed employs an adversarial version of the RTD task. This involves training a discriminator to distinguish between original and perturbed tokens. By making it harder for the discriminator to detect these perturbations, the encoder is encouraged to produce more informative and robust representations.
- Total Loss Function: The final loss combines the robust contrastive learning objective and the adversarial RTD objective, with weighting coefficients to balance their contributions.
Datasets
The paper utilizes the following datasets:
- Training Data: English Wikipedia sentences (provided by the SimCSE framework).
- Evaluation Datasets:
- Adversarial Attacks: MRPC, YELP, IMDb, MR, SST2, SNLI, MNLI (for text classification and natural language inference tasks).
- Adversarial Semantic Textual Similarity (AdvSTS): AdvSTS-B (derived from STS Benchmark) and AdvSICK-R (derived from SICK-Relatedness).
- Semantic Textual Similarity (STS) Tasks: STS datasets from 2012-2016, STS Benchmark, and SICK-Relatedness.
- Transfer Tasks: CR, SUBJ, MPQA, SST2, MRPC (for sentiment analysis and paraphrase identification).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Adversarial Examples as Positive Pairs: A key insight is treating adversarial perturbations not just as something to defend against, but as a form of "positive pair" in contrastive learning. This directly encourages the model to learn representations that are invariant to these small changes.
- Dual-Level Perturbations: Generating perturbations at both the token and sentence levels is crucial for comprehensive robustness. This ensures that the model is resilient to attacks that target individual words as well as those that subtly alter the overall sentence structure or meaning.
- RTD for Enhanced Robustness: The adversarial RTD objective acts as a powerful regularizer, forcing the encoder to learn representations that are less susceptible to token-level manipulations, thereby improving overall robustness.
- Trade-off Between Robustness and Generalization: The paper demonstrates that by focusing on adversarial robustness, they do not sacrifice generalization performance. In fact, their robust embeddings often show improved performance on downstream tasks.
Key Results
RobustSentEmbed demonstrates significant improvements in robustness and generalization:
- Adversarial Attack Reduction: The framework achieves a substantial reduction in adversarial attack success rates. For BERTAttack, the success rate is reduced by almost half (from 75.51% to 38.81%). On adversarial STS tasks, the reduction is from 71.86% to 12.80%.
- STS Performance: RobustSentEmbed achieves the highest average Spearman's correlation score on STS tasks, outperforming the second-best method (USCAL) by 1.59% when using a BERT encoder.
- Transfer Tasks: The framework shows improvements of 0.23% on transfer tasks (using BERT encoder), achieving the highest score in four out of six classification tasks.
- Outperforming Baselines: Across various adversarial attacks and tasks, RobustSentEmbed consistently outperforms established methods like SimCSE and USCAL, often by a significant margin.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- Descriptive vs. Generative Models: The framework is primarily tailored for descriptive models like BERT. Its direct application to generative models like GPT might present challenges, potentially limiting its effectiveness in enhancing generalization and robustness for text generation tasks.
- Computational Resources: Pre-training large models requires substantial GPU resources. The authors had to use smaller batch sizes due to GPU constraints, which might have impacted optimal performance.
- Future Work:
- The authors aim to investigate the use of "hard negative examples" to further enhance the effectiveness of text representations.
Summary updated