Abstract
Reinforcement learning (RL) agents often fail when deployed in real-world environments that differ from their training simulators. While Robust Markov Decision Processes (RMDPs) offer a theoretical framework to handle such model mismatches by optimizing for worst-case scenarios, they have historically been limited to small, tabular state spaces. This paper presents Robust Least Squares Policy Iteration (RLSPI), a model-free algorithm that combines RMDP theory with linear function approximation. We introduce Robust Least Squares Policy Evaluation (RLSPE($\lambda$)) to handle the nonlinearities of robust operators and provide convergence proofs and error bounds. Empirical results across several OpenAI Gym benchmarks demonstrate that RLSPI maintains performance under environmental perturbations where standard RL methods fail.
1. Introduction
The "sim-to-real" gap remains a significant hurdle in reinforcement learning. Agents trained in high-fidelity simulators often rely on specific environmental parameters—such as friction coefficients, mass distribution, or actuator response times—that may vary in the physical world. When these parameters shift, the performance of standard RL policies typically degrades.
Robust Reinforcement Learning aims to bridge this gap by training agents to be resilient against uncertainty. The Robust Markov Decision Process (RMDP) framework formalizes this by considering a set of possible transition models rather than a single fixed one. However, traditional RMDP solvers are computationally expensive and generally restricted to tabular settings. This paper introduces RLSPI, a scalable, model-free approach designed to bring robust RL to larger, continuous state spaces.
2. The Robust MDP Framework and the Scalability Challenge
In an RMDP, the transition probabilities are assumed to lie within an uncertainty set. The goal is to find a policy that maximizes the expected return under the worst-case transition model within that set. While this provides a safety margin, the "Robust Bellman Operator" used to solve these problems is nonlinear.
Standard Least Squares Policy Iteration (LSPI) relies on the linearity of the standard Bellman operator to solve for value function parameters using efficient linear algebra. The nonlinearity of the robust version prevents a direct application of least-squares methods, creating a bottleneck for scaling robust RL to high-dimensional problems that require function approximation.
3. Methodology: RLSPE($\lambda$) and RLSPI
The authors address the nonlinearity hurdle by proposing two interconnected algorithms:
3.1 Robust Least Squares Policy Evaluation (RLSPE($\lambda$))
To estimate the value of a policy under worst-case conditions, the authors define an approximate robust operator. This operator is designed to be compatible with linear function approximation, allowing the agent to learn a parameter vector $\theta$ that represents the robust value function. RLSPE($\lambda$) is an online, multi-step algorithm that iteratively updates these parameters.
3.2 Robust Least Squares Policy Iteration (RLSPI)
RLSPI uses the evaluation step as a foundation for policy improvement. The algorithm follows an iterative process:
- Policy Evaluation: Use RLSPE($\lambda$) to estimate the robust value of the current policy.
- Policy Improvement: Update the policy by selecting actions that maximize the robust value, accounting for potential environmental perturbations.
A key contribution of this work is the theoretical grounding. The authors provide rigorous proofs for the convergence of RLSPE($\lambda$) and establish an upper bound on the approximation error of the final RLSPI policy, ensuring that the learned strategy remains close to the theoretical robust optimum.
4. Experimental Evaluation
The effectiveness of RLSPI was tested on several classic control tasks from the OpenAI Gym library: CartPole, MountainCar, Acrobot, and a discrete FrozenLake8x8 grid-world.
4.1 Robustness to Parameter Perturbations
To simulate model mismatch, the researchers varied physical parameters during testing that were held constant during training. These included changes in gravity and pole length for CartPole, variations in engine power and hill steepness for MountainCar, and adjustments to friction and link mass for Acrobot.
4.2 Action Robustness
The agents were also subjected to adversarial action noise, where the environment occasionally forced a "wrong" action to simulate faulty hardware or external interference, such as wind gusts.
5. Results and Discussion
The experimental results highlight three primary advantages of the RLSPI approach:
- Stability: While standard LSPI and Q-learning achieved high rewards in the "nominal" (unperturbed) environments, their performance dropped sharply when parameters were changed. RLSPI, conversely, maintained consistent performance across a wide range of perturbations.
- Reliability: In the presence of action noise, RLSPI demonstrated significantly higher average rewards than non-robust baselines, proving its utility for safety-critical applications.
- Efficiency: Despite the added complexity of robustness, RLSPI demonstrated rapid convergence, making it a practical choice for engineering tasks where computational resources or training time may be limited.
6. Limitations and Future Directions
While RLSPI represents a significant step forward, the authors identify several areas for improvement. The reliance on linear function approximation means the algorithm may not scale directly to tasks involving raw image data, which typically require deep neural networks. Furthermore, the choice of the uncertainty radius ($r$) is vital; a radius that is too large can lead to overly conservative behavior, where the agent becomes so "paranoid" about worst-case scenarios that it fails to achieve the primary goal efficiently.
Future research will likely focus on extending these robust least-squares techniques to nonlinear function approximators and developing automated methods for tuning the uncertainty parameters based on real-world data.
7. Conclusion
RLSPI provides a mathematically sound and computationally viable framework for robust reinforcement learning. By bridging the gap between RMDP theory and least-squares function approximation, this work enables the development of RL agents that are not only high-performing in simulation but also resilient in the face of real-world uncertainty.
Summary updated