Robust $k$-Center with Two Types of Radii

Deeparnab Chakrabarty, Maryam Negahbani

TL;DR

This paper tackles the "Robust Non-Uniform k-Center" problem, a challenging variant of facility location where we need to cover points with balls of two different sizes, and some points can be ignored (outliers). The authors introduce a novel "ellipsoid method inside the ellipsoid method" approach to achieve a constant-factor approximation, overcoming technical hurdles that previously prevented solutions for this robust version.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The standard k-center problem aims to find $k$ centers to cover all points in a metric space with the smallest possible radius. This paper deals with a more complex version called the Non-Uniform k-Center (NUkC) problem, where we can use balls of different radii ($r_1 > r_2$) with associated budgets ($k_1, k_2$). A further complication is the "Robust" aspect, meaning we can discard up to $z$ points (outliers) while still covering the remaining points. This is modeled as a 3-radii problem where one radius is effectively zero.

The core challenge is to find a placement of $k_1$ balls of radius $r_1$ and $k_2$ balls of radius $r_2$ such that all non-outlier points are covered, and the maximum radius used (scaled by the number of centers) is minimized. Previous work by Chakrabarty, Goyal, and Krishnaswamy (CGK) provided a constant-factor approximation for the non-robust NUkC problem with two radii. However, extending this to the robust case proved difficult due to integrality gaps in the underlying linear programming relaxations, particularly when dealing with outliers. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a constant-factor approximation for the robust 2-NUkC problem.

Methods

The paper's main technical contribution is a novel "ellipsoid method inside the ellipsoid method" strategy, which can be thought of as a multi-layered "round-or-cut" framework.

  1. Outer Round-or-Cut: The algorithm first attempts to solve the problem using a standard approach. If this fails, it uses the ellipsoid method to find a separating hyperplane, effectively refining the search space.
  2. Inner Ellipsoid Method (for Well-Separated Instances): A key insight is that if the $r_1$-radius centers are "well-separated" (meaning they are at least $4r_1$ apart), a simpler, more efficient algorithm can be applied. This inner algorithm, based on a previous work by the authors, uses the ellipsoid method to find a 4-approximation for these well-separated instances.
  3. Connecting to Firefighter Problem: The CGK approach for the non-robust case relies on reducing the NUkC problem to a "firefighter problem on trees." The authors leverage this connection but encounter issues when outliers are present, as the firefighter LP relaxation becomes non-integral.
  4. Handling Non-Well-Separated Instances: When the $r_1$-centers are not well-separated, the paper uses ideas from recent work on fair colorful clustering. They show that if the $r_1$-centers are too close, one can effectively "save" budget on the number of balls needed. This savings allows them to adapt the firefighter LP relaxation to obtain an integral solution, or to generate multiple "well-separated" instances that can then be solved by the inner ellipsoid method.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The problem is defined on abstract metric spaces.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Ellipsoid Method Inside the Ellipsoid Method": This nested application of the ellipsoid method is the core algorithmic innovation, allowing them to handle the complex interplay between outliers and the need for well-separated centers.
  • Well-Separated Instances as a Key: The paper identifies "well-separated" instances (where $r_1$-centers are far apart) as a tractable subproblem. This allows them to break down the general problem into manageable pieces.
  • Leveraging "Slack" in LP Relaxations: The authors exploit the concept of "slack" in LP relaxations, particularly in the context of the firefighter problem. When there's enough slack (i.e., the fractional solution is far from the budget constraints), they can guarantee an integral solution.
  • Bridging the Gap for Robustness: The paper successfully addresses a critical technical bottleneck that prevented previous methods from handling outliers in the non-uniform k-center problem.

Key Results

  • 10-Approximation for Robust 2-NUkC: The paper presents a polynomial-time algorithm that provides a 10-approximation for the robust Non-Uniform k-Center problem with two types of radii. This is a significant improvement over previous approaches that struggled with the robust version.
  • 4-Approximation for Well-Separated Instances: A key subroutine provides a 4-approximation for the specific case where the $r_1$-centers are well-separated.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Constant Number of Radii: While this paper solves the robust problem for two types of radii, the authors note that their approach does not directly generalize to a constant number of radii ($t > 2$). The challenge lies in handling cases where some layers have slack and others do not, and they believe new ideas are needed to resolve the full conjecture for $t > 2$.
  • Generalization to $t > 2$: The paper explicitly leaves open the problem of achieving constant-factor approximations for the NUkC problem with a constant number of radii greater than two, even without outliers.
  • Technical Complexity: The proposed algorithm involves nested applications of the ellipsoid method, indicating a high degree of technical sophistication.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the non-uniform $k$-center problem, the objective is to cover points in a metric space with specified number of balls of different radii. Chakrabarty, Goyal, and Krishnaswamy [ICALP 2016, Trans. on Algs. 2020] (CGK, henceforth) give a constant factor approximation when there are two types of radii. In this paper, we give a constant factor approximation for the two radii case in the presence of outliers. To achieve this, we need to bypass the technical barrier of bad integrality gaps in the CGK approach. We do so using "the ellipsoid method inside the ellipsoid method": use an outer layer of the ellipsoid method to reduce to stylized instances and use an inner layer of the ellipsoid method to solve these specialized instances. This idea is of independent interest and could be applicable to other problems. Keywords: Approximation, Clustering, Outliers, and Round-or-Cut.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chakrabarty2021robust,
  author = {Deeparnab Chakrabarty and Maryam Negahbani},
  title = {{Robust $k$-Center with Two Types of Radii}},
  booktitle = {Math. Program},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Kos282wSRo},
}
Figure