Robotic Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery: A Journey from “Back to the Future”

Vineet Gauhar, Olivier Traxer, Sung Yong Cho, Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh, Alba Sierra, Vishesh Gauhar, Kemal Sarıca, Bhaskar Somani, Daniele CastellaniJournal of Clinical Medicine 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This review explores the burgeoning field of robotic-assisted flexible ureteroscopy (R-URS) for kidney stone treatment. It highlights how robotic systems are enhancing surgeon ergonomics, precision, and potentially patient outcomes by reducing radiation exposure and fatigue, paving the way for more efficient and effective stone management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditionally, flexible ureteroscopy (F-URS) for kidney stones involves manual manipulation of a flexible scope, which can be physically demanding for surgeons, leading to fatigue and potential for reduced precision, especially during complex or lengthy procedures. This manual approach also exposes surgeons to fluoroscopic radiation. The paper addresses the need for improved ergonomics, enhanced control, and reduced radiation exposure in F-URS by examining the integration of robotic platforms into this surgical domain.

Methods

The paper is a review that surveys existing and emerging robotic platforms for flexible ureteroscopy. It discusses the design principles, operational mechanics, and clinical applications of three specific systems:

  • Roboflex Avicenna®: This system features a surgeon's console and a robotic arm that manipulates the flexible ureteroscope. It aims to improve ergonomics and precision through joystick control for scope movement and integrated functions for laser fiber manipulation.
  • EasyUretero®: A master-slave robotic system developed in Korea, it utilizes a 32-inch touch screen console and a robotic arm. Key features include automated navigation capabilities, recording and replaying of movements, and compatibility with various commercially available flexible ureteroscopes.
  • ILY® Robot: This system acts as a ureteroscope holder with multiple degrees of freedom, telemanipulated via a wireless controller resembling a PlayStation joystick. It emphasizes surgeon distance from radiation and offers a unique control interface.

The authors describe the advantages and limitations of each system based on published studies and clinical experiences.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review of existing technologies and clinical applications, not a study that utilizes specific datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ergonomics as a Game Changer: A primary driver for robotic adoption in F-URS is the significant improvement in surgeon ergonomics, reducing musculoskeletal fatigue and allowing for more comfortable, prolonged procedures.
  • Precision and Control Enhancement: Robotic systems offer graduated movements and enhanced stability, potentially leading to more precise manipulation of the ureteroscope and laser fiber, which can be crucial for fragmenting stones and minimizing damage to the renal collecting system.
  • Radiation Exposure Reduction: By allowing surgeons to operate from a console away from the patient, robotic platforms significantly reduce the surgeon's exposure to ionizing radiation during fluoroscopy.
  • Potential for Improved Outcomes: The combination of better ergonomics, precision, and reduced fatigue could translate to improved stone-free rates, reduced operative times, and a better overall patient experience.
  • Evolution of Control Interfaces: The field is exploring diverse control methods, from traditional joysticks to game-controller-like interfaces, each with its own learning curve and advantages.

Key Results

The paper presents qualitative findings and reported benefits from clinical studies:

  • Roboflex Avicenna®: Studies reported significantly improved ergonomics (e.g., total questionnaire scores) and that surgeons could perform robot-assisted F-URS safely and in a reasonable timeframe after a short introduction. Benefits included lesser scope damage and improved precision.
  • EasyUretero®: An animal study showed feasibility and safety in retrieving renal stones. Clinical trials reported successful completion, with the system offering automated navigation and replay functions.
  • ILY® Robot: This system is highlighted for its compatibility with all types of ureteroscopes and sheaths. While its game-controller interface may require a learning curve, it offers enhanced maneuverability and surgeon comfort.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Cost and Accessibility: The high cost of robotic systems is a significant barrier, limiting their accessibility to well-funded centers.
  • Tactile Feedback: A lack of tactile feedback in some systems can be a limitation, although some platforms aim to compensate for this through advanced control mechanisms.
  • Learning Curve: Some robotic interfaces, particularly those deviating from traditional controls (e.g., ILY®'s game controller), present a learning curve for surgeons.
  • Partial Undocking: Robotic F-URS may require partial undocking of the device, which can be cumbersome and time-consuming.

Future Work:

  • Miniaturization: The development of smaller, more integrated camera robots and microrobots is envisioned for future applications.
  • Intelligent Systems: Future systems could incorporate intra-renal pressure monitoring, optimization algorithms, and intelligent sensing for enhanced performance.
  • Automated Functions: Development of automated navigation within the renal calyces and respiration-adjusted stone fragmentation is a promising area.
  • Telerobotics: The integration of 5G technology could enable remote robotic F-URS, expanding access to specialized care.
  • Improved Instruments: Designing instruments specifically for robotic platforms, mirroring the success of the Da Vinci system, is crucial for enhancing performance and ergonomics.
  • AI Integration: Artificial intelligence applications for sized detection, laser settings, and electromagnetic targeting are being explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

The introduction of robotics has revolutionized surgery. Robotic platforms have also recently been introduced in clinical practice specifically for flexible ureteroscopy. In this paper, we look at the robotic platforms currently available for flexible ureteroscopy, describing their advantages and limitations. The following robotic platforms are discussed: Roboflex Avicenna<sup>®</sup>, EasyUretero<sup>®</sup>, and ILY<sup>®</sup> robot. Finally, potential future advancements in this field are presented.
BibTeX
@article{gauhar2022robotic,
  author = {Vineet Gauhar and Olivier Traxer and Sung Yong Cho and Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh and Alba Sierra and Vishesh Gauhar and Kemal Sarıca and Bhaskar Somani and Daniele Castellani},
  title = {{Robotic Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery: A Journey from “Back to the Future”}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm11185488},
}
Figure