Risk factors of LEEP margin positivity and optimal length of cervical conization in cervical intraepithelial neoplasia

Qing Cong, Yi Yu, Yu Xie, Yanyun Li, Long SuiFrontiers in Oncology 2023 · DOI

Abstract

A cervical excision length of 10-15 mm is reasonable for TZ1 and TZ2 patients, while 17-25 mm is optimal for TZ3 excision with more negative internal margins.

Introduction

Cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) represents a spectrum of precancerous changes that, if left untreated, can progress to cervical cancer. The Loop Electrosurgical Excision Procedure (LEEP) is a standard surgical intervention used to remove these lesions. The primary goal of LEEP is to achieve "negative margins"—ensuring that the edges of the removed tissue are free of abnormal cells.

However, clinicians face a "Goldilocks" dilemma. Removing insufficient tissue increases the risk of residual disease and recurrence. Conversely, excessive tissue removal is associated with adverse obstetric outcomes, such as cervical insufficiency and preterm birth in future pregnancies. This balance is further complicated by the anatomical variation of the Transformation Zone (TZ), the area where CIN typically originates. In TZ1 and TZ2, the zone is visible on the ectocervix, whereas in TZ3, it extends deep into the endocervical canal. This study aims to establish evidence-based guidelines for optimal excision lengths tailored to these specific anatomical types.

Methods

This multi-center prospective case-control study analyzed data from 618 women across five medical centers in Shanghai, China, between 2016 and 2019. Participants included women with confirmed or suspected high-grade cervical lesions (HSIL, ASC-H, or AGC).

Patients were categorized by their TZ type (TZ1, TZ2, or TZ3) via colposcopy. A critical component of the methodology was the precise definition of margin status. The researchers distinguished between "internal" margins (comprising the endocervical and stromal edges) and "external" margins (the ectocervical edge).

Histopathological definitions of LEEP margin status, showing negative margins (A), positive internal margins (B), positive external margins (C), and positive stromal margins (D).

Multivariate logistic regression was employed to identify independent risk factors for margin positivity, adjusting for age, HPV status, cytology, and parity.

Key Results and Insights

Optimal Excision Lengths by TZ Type

The study found that the required depth of excision is highly dependent on the location of the transformation zone:

  • TZ1 and TZ2: An excision length of 10–15 mm was found to be sufficient to ensure negative margins while minimizing tissue loss.
  • TZ3: Because lesions are often hidden deeper in the endocervical canal, a more substantial excision of 17–25 mm is required.

The impact of adhering to these lengths was most dramatic in the TZ3 group. When the excision length was increased from 15 mm to the 17–25 mm range, the rate of positive internal margins dropped from 10.0% to just 1.0%.

Biological Risk Factors

Beyond physical measurements, the study identified key clinical predictors of positive margins:

  • Cytology: Patients with high-grade cytology (≥HSIL) were 3.82 times more likely to have positive internal margins (p = 0.002).
  • Age: Risk increased with age; for every additional year, the likelihood of a positive internal margin rose by approximately 11% (OR 1.11, p < 0.001). This suggests that older patients may harbor deeper lesions that require more careful surgical planning.

The Importance of Internal Margins

The researchers emphasize that internal margins (endocervical and stromal) are the primary clinical concern. While external margins are more accessible, positive internal margins are strongly linked to persistent high-grade disease and the need for subsequent intervention.

Discussion and Limitations

While providing clear guidelines, the authors note several areas for further research. The sample sizes for specific millimeter-by-millimeter excision lengths were relatively small, which may affect the precision of the recommended ranges. Additionally, the study's geographic focus on Shanghai suggests that future research should include more diverse populations to confirm these findings globally. Finally, long-term follow-up is necessary to fully evaluate the impact of deeper excisions (17–25 mm) on future pregnancy outcomes and long-term recurrence rates.

In conclusion, tailoring LEEP excision length to the patient's TZ type—specifically targeting 17–25 mm for TZ3—can significantly improve the rate of negative margins and optimize patient care.

Summary updated

Abstract

A cervical excision length of 10-15 mm is reasonable for TZ1 and TZ2 patients, while 17-25 mm is optimal for TZ3 excision with more negative internal margins.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cong2023risk,
  author = {Qing Cong and Yi Yu and Yu Xie and Yanyun Li and Long Sui},
  title = {{Risk factors of LEEP margin positivity and optimal length of cervical conization in cervical intraepithelial neoplasia}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Oncology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fonc.2023.1209811},
}
Figure