A Comparative Study on the Accuracy and Efficacy Between Dalton and CINtec® PLUS p16/Ki-67 Dual Stain in Triaging HPV-Positive Women

Ying Li, Yunfeng Fu, Cheng Bei, Xing Xie, Xinyu WangFrontiers in Oncology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Dalton presents the lower false positive rate and better efficacy in identifying high-grade CIN than CINtec® PLUS, suggesting that Dalton may be superior to CINtec® PLUS and an alternative technique for triaging primary HPV-positive women in cervical cancer screening.

Introduction

Primary Human Papillomavirus (HPV) testing has become a cornerstone of cervical cancer screening due to its high sensitivity. However, its lack of specificity often leads to unnecessary colposcopies for women with transient infections that would not progress to high-grade lesions. To mitigate this, a "triage" step is essential. While traditional liquid-based cytology is the standard, it is subjective and variable. Dual-staining (DS) for p16 and Ki-67 biomarkers offers a more objective diagnostic tool. This study evaluates the performance of the Dalton p16/Ki-67 Dual Stain kit against the clinically established industry leader, CINtec® PLUS.

Methodology

A prospective study was conducted at the Women’s Hospital, Zhejiang University, involving 717 HPV-positive women aged 20–69. Each participant underwent three parallel triage tests: liquid-based cytology, Dalton DS, and CINtec® PLUS DS. The researchers utilized a clinical dataset where HPV status was confirmed using either the HC2 assay or the Aptima assay. The study design and participant flow are detailed in Figure 1.

Figure 1: Flowchart of the study population and testing protocol.

A positive DS result was defined by the co-expression of p16 (brown cytoplasm) and Ki-67 (red nucleus) within the same cell. Histopathology from colposcopy biopsies served as the gold standard for clinical performance evaluation. The cohort included a range of outcomes: 468 normal cases, 169 CIN1, 43 CIN2, 29 CIN3, and 8 cases of invasive cancer.

Results

The comparative analysis revealed that Dalton DS outperformed CINtec® PLUS in several critical metrics for detecting high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN3+):

  • Specificity: Dalton achieved 75.29% compared to 69.26% for CINtec® PLUS (p = 0.013).
  • Accuracy: Dalton reached 76.29% versus 70.43% for CINtec® PLUS (p = 0.012).
  • Sensitivity: Both tests showed high and statistically similar sensitivity (Dalton 94.59% vs. CINtec® PLUS 91.89%).
  • Area Under the Curve (AUC): Dalton’s AUC was significantly higher (0.849) than that of CINtec® PLUS (0.806).

For CIN2+ detection, Dalton also maintained superior specificity (78.36% vs. 72.31%) and accuracy (78.94% vs. 73.36%). Notably, Dalton demonstrated a lower false-positive rate in the "normal" histopathology group (17.95% vs. 23.29%), suggesting it can more effectively clear healthy women from unnecessary follow-up procedures.

Discussion

The superior specificity and accuracy of Dalton may be attributed to the visual clarity of its staining. The co-expression of p16 and Ki-67 is a definitive marker of cell cycle deregulation by high-risk HPV, as these proteins are typically not expressed simultaneously in healthy cells.

Figure 5: Representative images of p16/Ki-67 dual staining. Positive cells exhibit brown cytoplasm and red nuclei.

The researchers noted that the Dalton kit's Ki-67 antibody might provide better visibility, reducing ambiguity for pathologists during interpretation. This objectivity is a significant advantage over traditional cytology, which showed high variability in this study. However, the authors acknowledge limitations, including potential selection bias from a clinical (rather than general) population and the need for longitudinal data to assess long-term risk.

Conclusion

The Dalton p16/Ki-67 Dual Stain kit is a highly effective triage tool for HPV-positive women. With its superior specificity and accuracy compared to CINtec® PLUS, Dalton offers a promising alternative that could reduce the burden of unnecessary colposcopies while maintaining high sensitivity for detecting high-grade lesions. Future longitudinal studies in broader screening populations are recommended to confirm these findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dalton presents the lower false positive rate and better efficacy in identifying high-grade CIN than CINtec<sup>®</sup> PLUS, suggesting that Dalton may be superior to CINtec<sup>®</sup> PLUS and an alternative technique for triaging primary HPV-positive women in cervical cancer screening.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022comparative,
  author = {Ying Li and Yunfeng Fu and Cheng Bei and Xing Xie and Xinyu Wang},
  title = {{A Comparative Study on the Accuracy and Efficacy Between Dalton and CINtec® PLUS p16/Ki-67 Dual Stain in Triaging HPV-Positive Women}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Oncology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fonc.2021.815213},
}
Figure