RF Chain Reduction for MIMO Systems: A Hardware Prototype

Tierui Gong, Nir Shlezinger, Shahar Stein Ioushua, Moshe Namer, Zhijia Yang, Yonina C. Eldar

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel hardware prototype for reducing the number of radio frequency (RF) chains in massive MIMO systems, a key challenge for next-generation wireless communication. By developing a configurable analog combiner and an efficient design algorithm, they demonstrate near-optimal channel estimation accuracy with significantly reduced hardware complexity and cost.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern wireless systems, particularly those aiming for higher throughput, are leveraging technologies like massive MIMO (multiple-input multiple-output) and millimeter-wave frequencies. While these offer significant advantages, they come with a major drawback: the cost and power consumption of RF chains, which are essential for processing signals. In massive MIMO systems, where base stations are equipped with a large number of antennas, the number of RF chains can become prohibitively expensive, especially at high frequencies. This paper addresses the challenge of reducing the number of RF chains in MIMO systems while minimizing the impact on crucial performance metrics like channel estimation accuracy. The goal is to achieve a cost-effective solution that doesn't significantly compromise performance.

Methods

The core of this work lies in two main contributions: a novel algorithm for designing analog combiners and a corresponding hardware prototype.

  • Analog Combiner Design Algorithm: The authors propose an alternating optimization algorithm to design analog combiners, specifically focusing on phase-shifter-only (PSOAC) architectures. This algorithm aims to minimize the mean-squared error (MSE) in channel estimation. It improves upon existing methods by exploiting the non-uniqueness of optimal complex-gain combiners to find a feasible PSOAC that closely approximates the unconstrained optimum. This is achieved by iteratively optimizing the combiner weights, phase shifters, and gain values.
  • Hardware Prototype: A configurable analog combiner hardware board was designed and implemented. This prototype operates in the sub-6 GHz frequency range and supports both complex-gain analog combiners (CGAC) and phase-shifter-only analog combiners (PSOAC). It features a flexible architecture that allows for experimentation with different RF chain reduction strategies. The system integrates a Matlab-based host application, an FPGA board for digital-analog conversion and control, and the custom analog combiner board. A "virtual channel extension" approach is also described, enabling the testing of systems with more antennas and RF chains than the physical hardware supports.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments utilize simulated channel models and generated pilot sequences.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Analog Combining as a Practical Solution: The paper strongly advocates for analog combining as a viable and effective method for RF chain reduction, demonstrating its practical implementation and performance.
  • Algorithm Superiority: The proposed alternating optimization algorithm for PSOAC design significantly outperforms existing methods like MaGiQ in approximating the optimal unconstrained combiner, leading to better channel estimation accuracy.
  • Hardware Realization is Key: The development of a dedicated, configurable hardware prototype is crucial for validating theoretical designs and evaluating performance with real-world signals, bridging the gap between simulation and practice.
  • Trade-off Management: The work highlights that while fully-digital receivers offer the best performance, hybrid architectures with analog combining can achieve performance very close to the theoretical limit with substantial hardware savings.
  • Phase Resolution Matters: The use of high-resolution vector multipliers in their prototype is identified as a key factor in achieving improved phase control and thus better channel estimation accuracy compared to systems with cruder phase shifters.

Key Results

The experimental results demonstrate that the proposed PSOAC design algorithm, implemented on their hardware prototype, achieves channel estimation accuracy that is within a small gap of the performance of costly fully-digital receivers. Specifically:

  • The PSOAC designed using their algorithm performs nearly as well as the unconstrained complex-gain analog combiner (CGAC) in terms of normalized MSE.
  • Both the proposed PSOAC and CGAC significantly outperform random antenna selection methods.
  • In scenarios with a high rank of the receive side correlation matrix, an error floor is observed for analog combining methods at high SNRs, attributed to model mismatch from dimensionality reduction. However, when the rank is not larger than the number of RF chains, the analog combiner performance matches that of fully-digital receivers.
  • As the number of RF chains increases, the normalized MSE of the hybrid architectures approaches that of the fully-digital receiver, with performance gaps becoming negligible when the reduction rate is high (e.g., Nrf/Nbs > 62.5%).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Physical Hardware Limitations: The current prototype has a limited number of input and output ports (4 inputs, 2 outputs), necessitating the "virtual channel extension" for testing larger systems.
  • Focus on Channel Estimation: While the paper focuses on channel estimation accuracy, the authors note that the prototype can be used to evaluate other performance metrics like bit error rate by processing the combiner output differently.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their prototype can be used to evaluate various other performance measures and that the proposed design algorithm can be extended to other objectives, such as maximizing achievable rate or signal recovery. The flexibility of the hardware also allows for testing different analog combiner architectures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Radio frequency (RF) chain circuits play a major role in digital receiver architectures, allowing passband communication signals to be processed in baseband. When operating at high frequencies, these circuits tend to be costly. This increased cost imposes a major limitation on future multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) communication technologies. A common approach to mitigate the increased cost is to utilize hybrid architectures, in which the received signal is combined in analog into a lower dimension, thus reducing the number of RF chains. In this work we study the design and hardware implementation of hybrid architectures via minimizing channel estimation error. We first derive the optimal solution for complex-gain combiners and propose an alternating optimization algorithm for phase-shifter combiners. We then present a hardware prototype implementing analog combining for RF chain reduction. The prototype consists of a specially designed configurable combining board as well as a dedicated experimental setup. Our hardware prototype allows evaluating the effect of analog combining in MIMO systems using actual communication signals. The experimental study, which focuses on channel estimation accuracy in MIMO channels, demonstrates that using the proposed prototype, the achievable channel estimation performance is within a small gap in a statistical sense from that obtained using a costly receiver in which each antenna is connected to a dedicated RF chain.
BibTeX
@article{gong2020rf,
  author = {Tierui Gong and Nir Shlezinger and Shahar Stein Ioushua and Moshe Namer and Zhijia Yang and Yonina C. Eldar},
  title = {{RF Chain Reduction for MIMO Systems: A Hardware Prototype}},
  journal = {IEEE Syst. j},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/jsyst.2020.2975653},
}
Figure