Revealing Urban Public Space Patterns through Quantitative Comparison between the Old City of Nanjing and Zurich

Ning Xu, Jianguo Wang, Wei WangSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantitatively compares urban public space patterns in Zurich and Nanjing, revealing significant differences in their spatial distribution, type composition, and scale. By employing a location quotient method, the research highlights how European cities like Zurich tend to centralize public spaces, while Nanjing's public spaces are more concentrated on the periphery, impacting urban vitality and accessibility.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While green space accessibility has been extensively studied, the broader patterns of urban public space, including streets, have received less attention, especially in cross-national comparisons. This paper addresses this gap by investigating how the fundamental patterns of urban public space differ between a developed European city (Zurich) and a rapidly developing Chinese city (Nanjing). Understanding these patterns is crucial for sustainable urban development, as public spaces are vital for social interaction, urban vitality, and civic identity. The study aims to move beyond simple quantity metrics to analyze the spatial organization and characteristics of public spaces.

Methods

The study utilizes a quantitative comparative approach, employing Geographic Information System (GIS) tools and spatial analysis techniques. Key methods include:

  • Vectorized Digital Base Maps and Field Investigation: Data on urban public spaces and administrative divisions were compiled and verified.
  • ArcMap Attribute Statistics: This was used to derive basic spatial data like total area, quantity, average area, and perimeter of public spaces.
  • Compactness Formula (Batty's formula): Used to calculate the spatial compactness of urban public spaces.
  • Location Quotient (LQ) Method: This core method, adapted from regional analysis, quantifies the spatial distribution of public space by comparing the proportion of public space in a specific area (e.g., administrative district) to the overall city average. An LQ > 1 indicates a higher-than-average concentration.
  • Spatial Interpolation (Inverse Distance Weighted): Used to create raster graphics of LQ values.
  • Contour Line Extraction and 3D Modeling: Visualized the LQ distribution to reveal spatial patterns.
  • Type Classification: Public spaces were categorized into streets, squares, green space, and waterfront space, with specific criteria defined for each.
  • Scale Classification: Public spaces were categorized into small, medium, medium-large, large, and extra-large based on area.

Datasets

The study used vectorized digital base maps for Zurich and the old city of Nanjing. Specific data sources included:

  • Zurich: Zurich Urban Space Strategy (Stadträume 2010) and administrative district data from data.stadt-zuerich.ch.
  • Nanjing: Short-term Planning of the Optimal Layout of Green Space, Regulatory Plan of the Old City of Nanjing, Urban Master Plan of Nanjing (2018–2035), Urban Green Space System Planning of Nanjing (2013–2020), and site surveys.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Centralization vs. Peripherality: The most striking insight is the diametrically opposed spatial patterns of public space. Zurich's public spaces are concentrated in the urban core, exhibiting a decreasing trend towards the periphery. Conversely, Nanjing's public spaces are predominantly located on the periphery, with a concentration of high LQ values in these outer areas and a relative scarcity in the city center.
  • Street Space Deficit in Nanjing: A significant difference lies in the proportion and quantity of street space. Zurich has a much higher proportion of streets, which are crucial for linear public space and urban cohesion. Nanjing shows a distinct lack of linear street space, impacting its continuity and overall public space system.
  • Scale Gradient Polarization: Zurich exhibits a "fusiform" scale distribution, with a dominance of medium to large public spaces and fewer small and extra-large ones. Nanjing, however, shows a "bipolar" distribution, with a large number of small public spaces and a significant proportion of extra-large spaces, but a deficit in medium-sized ones.
  • Implications for Urban Life: The study suggests that Zurich's pattern aligns with a "concentric law" of human public behavior, fostering a friendly environment for walking and activities. Nanjing's peripheral concentration, however, is deemed less conducive to daily use and efficiency, potentially hindering public life and social integration.

Key Results

  • General Pattern: Zurich's public space covers 10.8% of its urban construction land, while Nanjing's covers 7.7%. Zurich has nearly twice the number of public space sites.
  • Location Quotient: Zurich's maximum LQ is 9.5 (urban core), with 63.3% of construction land having LQ > 1. Nanjing's maximum LQ is 8.5 (periphery), with only 30.8% of construction land having LQ > 1.
  • Street Space: Streets constitute 51.5% of Zurich's public space area and 51.2% of its quantity. For Nanjing, these figures are significantly lower at 22.6% and 17.5%, respectively.
  • Scale Pattern: In Zurich, medium, medium-large, and large public spaces account for over 92% of the total area and quantity. In Nanjing, these categories account for less than 77% (area) and 68% (quantity), with a larger proportion of small and extra-large spaces.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Western Bias: The study acknowledges a potential bias towards a Western cultural and social system framework, which might influence the interpretation of public space models. The adaptability of Zurich's model to China's context requires further verification.
  • Quantitative Reductionism: The reliance on quantitative methods, while providing clarity, may oversimplify the complex social and cultural factors influencing public space.
  • User Needs and Context: The research did not deeply consider the specific needs of different user groups or the unique historical, cultural, and spatial contexts of other cities, suggesting a need for more diverse case studies.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest investigating more urban cases to validate the method and conclusions across different contexts. They also emphasize the need to integrate public space into urban planning as an overarching factor for sustainable development, moving beyond mere quantity-based regulations. The optimization of Nanjing's public space pattern should focus on the concentric law of public activities and explore the potential of existing spaces, particularly linear street networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Urban public space is indispensable in a metropolitan environment. In recent years, green space, as an important part of that public space, has been studied in terms of its pattern and equity of accessibility. However, the pattern of urban public space, including streets, has not yet been studied, nor has it been studied among different countries. To resolve this gap in information, this study conducted a quantitative comparison on the general pattern, type pattern, and scale pattern of urban public space between Zurich in Switzerland and the old city of Nanjing in China. This study also explored using the location quotient method to quantify the pattern of urban public space and its physical structure characteristics. The results show the difference between urban public space in China and Europe exists not only in quantity, scale or type, but also in the pattern of the urban public space system, including the choice of location, distribution status, and service level of that public space. The maximum location quotient of Zurich’s public space is 9.5 for the areas located in the urban core area. Meanwhile, it is 8.5 for Nanjing for areas located in the periphery of the old city. Areas with a location quotient of greater than one cover 63.3% of the urban construction land in Zurich, while only 30.8% of the corresponding urban construction land is covered in Nanjing. The area and quantity of streets are quite different as well. The street areas of Zurich account for 51.5% of the total area of public space and the number of streets account for 51.2% of the total number of public space sites, while those numbers are only 22.6% and 17.5% for Nanjing, respectively. In addition, the scale gradient of public space is polarized. Both the area ratio and quantity ratio of medium, medium-large, and large public space in Zurich exceed 92%, while the area ratio and quantity ratio of Nanjing are less than 77% and 68%, respectively. This study provides important insights for revealing urban public space patterns to facilitate the sustainability development of urban public space.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2019revealing,
  author = {Ning Xu and Jianguo Wang and Wei Wang},
  title = {{Revealing Urban Public Space Patterns through Quantitative Comparison between the Old City of Nanjing and Zurich}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11133687},
}
Figure