Revealing Urban Morphology and Outdoor Comfort through Genetic Algorithm-Driven Urban Block Design in Dry and Hot Regions of China

Xiaodong Xu, Chenhuan Yin, Wei Wang, Ning Xu, Tianzhen Hong, Qi LiSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents an automated workflow for optimizing urban block design in dry and hot climates to improve outdoor thermal comfort. By using a genetic algorithm within Rhino and Grasshopper, they demonstrate a significant reduction in the Universal Thermal Climate Index (UTCI) and Mean Radiation Temperature (MRT), offering a data-driven approach for more livable urban environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban environments, especially in dry and hot regions, often suffer from extreme thermal conditions due to factors like intense solar radiation, high temperatures, and low humidity. These conditions significantly reduce outdoor thermal comfort, impacting human well-being and the overall livability of cities. While urban morphology is known to influence these microclimates, there's a need for systematic, data-driven methods to optimize urban block design specifically for these challenging climates. Existing research often focuses on broader urban scales or specific climatic zones, leaving a gap in tailored, block-level optimization strategies for dry and hot regions, particularly in rapidly urbanizing areas like Western China.

Methods

The study proposes an automatic workflow for optimizing urban spatial forms to enhance outdoor thermal comfort. This workflow integrates several key components:

  • Parameterized Urban Block Generation: Using Rhino and Grasshopper, urban blocks are generated based on four generic building types (pillar, strip, dot, and courtyard) with varying fragmentation degrees. These blocks are then assembled into grid layouts.
  • Simulation Platform: The integrated platform uses Rhinoceros and Grasshopper, with plugins like Ladybug for weather and comfort visualization (UTCI), EnergyPlus for solar radiation simulation (including Mean Radiation Temperature - MRT), and Butterfly for CFD analysis (wind speed).
  • Genetic Algorithm Optimization: A genetic algorithm (implemented via the Galapagos module in Grasshopper) is employed to iteratively optimize urban block design parameters. The primary objective is to minimize the UTCI, representing outdoor thermal comfort. Key design parameters optimized include building form, height, open space layout, and street orientation.
  • Ideal and Actual Case Studies: The methodology is applied to both an "ideal" urban block model (for exploring optimization performance) and an "actual" urban block in Kashgar, China (for validating the optimization in a real-world context).

Datasets

The study utilizes meteorological data for Kashgar, China, specifically focusing on July, the hottest month. This data, including wind direction, wind speed, average temperature, average humidity, and MRT, was obtained from the EPWmap website for the hours between 10:00 and 16:00. This data serves as the basis for the climate simulations and comfort assessments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Block-Level Optimization is Crucial: The research highlights that optimizing urban block morphology at a granular level can significantly improve thermal comfort, even when plot ratio and building density are fixed.
  • Building Type Matters: Different building types (pillar, strip, dot, courtyard) exhibit distinct responses to thermal conditions, with dot and courtyard types generally showing better performance in reducing MRT.
  • Compactness and Narrow Streets Enhance Comfort: In dry and hot climates, a highly-dense, compact urban form with narrow streets appears to be an effective strategy for improving thermal comfort, likely by reducing direct solar exposure and enhancing shading.
  • Strategic Open Space Design: The location and distribution of open spaces are critical. Placing them in areas that benefit from shading by surrounding buildings or facilitate airflow can significantly impact comfort.
  • Genetic Algorithms as Powerful Design Tools: The study demonstrates the efficacy of genetic algorithms in navigating complex design spaces to find optimal urban forms that balance multiple climatic factors.

Key Results

  • UTCI Reduction: The optimization process successfully reduced the average UTCI from 31.17 °C to 27.43 °C in the actual urban block case study, a decrease of approximately 3.74 °C.
  • MRT Reduction: Mean Radiation Temperature (MRT) was reduced from 43.94 °C to 41.29 °C, a decrease of about 2.65 °C.
  • Wind Speed Impact: While the primary goal was comfort improvement, the average wind speed slightly decreased by about 0.07 m/s in the optimized actual urban block.
  • Ideal Model Performance: For the ideal models, the dot-type and courtyard-type blocks generally achieved lower average UTCI values compared to pillar-type and strip-type blocks.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Building Types: The study focused on a simplified set of generic building types and did not cover the full diversity of real-world urban forms or their variations.
  • Block-Scale Focus: The research concentrated on the block scale and did not account for larger urban scales, single building impacts, or landscape elements like vegetation, water bodies, or pavements.
  • Seasonal Limitations: The climate analysis was based on July data (hottest month) and did not consider winter or transitional seasons in dry and hot regions.
  • Single Optimization Objective: The genetic algorithm was optimized solely for UTCI. Future work could explore other optimization algorithms (e.g., heuristic, Q-learning) and incorporate additional indices like PET, indoor comfort, and energy consumption.

Future work could also include integrating green spaces and leveraging advancements in urban computing and simulation tools to further refine optimization strategies for urban planning and design.

Summary updated

Abstract

In areas with a dry and hot climate, factors such as strong solar radiation, high temperature, low humidity, dazzling light, and dust storms can tremendously reduce people’s thermal comfort. Therefore, researchers are paying more attention to outdoor thermal comfort in urban environments as part of urban design. This study proposed an automatic workflow to optimize urban spatial forms with the aim of improvement of outdoor thermal comfort conditions, characterized by the universal thermal climate index (UTCI). A city with a dry and hot climate—Kashgar, China—is further selected as an actual case study of an urban block and Rhino & Grasshopper is the platform used to conduct simulation and optimization process with the genetic algorithm. Results showed that in summer, the proposed method can reduce the averaged UTCI from 31.17 to 27.43 °C, a decrease of about 3.74 °C, and reduce mean radiation temperature (MRT) from 43.94 to 41.29 °C, a decrease of about 2.65 °C.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2019revealing,
  author = {Xiaodong Xu and Chenhuan Yin and Wei Wang and Ning Xu and Tianzhen Hong and Qi Li},
  title = {{Revealing Urban Morphology and Outdoor Comfort through Genetic Algorithm-Driven Urban Block Design in Dry and Hot Regions of China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11133683},
}
Figure