Retrofitting FSO Systems in Existing RF Infrastructure: A Non-Zero Sum Game Technology

Abderrahmen Trichili, Amr Ragheb, Dmitrii Briantcev, Maged Abdullah Esmail, Majid Altamimi, Islam Ashry, Boon S. Ooi, Saleh Al-Shebeili, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

Retrofitting FSO Systems in Existing RF Infrastructure: A Non-Zero Sum Game Technology

Introduction: The Bandwidth Crunch

As global data demands surge toward the 6G era, traditional Radio Frequency (RF) spectrum faces an unprecedented "bandwidth crunch." Data-hungry applications like 8K streaming and virtual reality are making traditional RF spectrum overcrowded and expensive to license. While optical fiber remains the gold standard for backhaul, its deployment is often economically unfeasible in rural areas or dense urban "last-mile" environments due to massive civil engineering costs.

Free Space Optics (FSO) presents a compelling alternative, offering Terabit-per-second potential by transmitting data via narrow infrared beams through the air. However, FSO has a significant Achilles' heel: extreme sensitivity to atmospheric conditions such as fog and turbulence.

Atmospheric impairments such as fog, rain, and turbulence significantly impact FSO link reliability.

Architectural and Algorithmic Strategies

To mitigate these vulnerabilities, this research explores the synergy of retrofitting FSO terminals onto existing RF masts. This "plug-and-play" approach avoids the costs of new permits and trenching while creating a robust hybrid system. The paper identifies several key integration strategies:

  • Hybrid Architectures: Systems can be configured as Serial Dual-Hop (consecutive relay stages) or Parallel Configurations (simultaneous links between two points).
  • Switching Mechanisms: Reliability is managed through Hard Switching (threshold-based), Soft Switching (using joint channel coding like Raptor codes to utilize both links), or ML-Based Switching (utilizing LSTMs and GANs to proactively predict and react to atmospheric changes).

The Physics of Weather Complementarity

The core innovation of this approach lies in the "non-zero-sum" relationship between RF and FSO. Their failure modes are naturally complementary due to the physics of light scattering.

Mie scattering occurs when particle sizes are comparable to the wavelength, such as infrared light in fog, whereas Rayleigh scattering involves much smaller particles.

Fog particles are roughly the same size as infrared wavelengths, causing massive Mie scattering that can sever an FSO link. Conversely, raindrops are much larger than infrared waves but closer in size to RF wavelengths, which primarily affects RF performance. Because these technologies fail under different environmental conditions, a hybrid link is statistically much more robust than either alone, often achieving over 99.98% availability in field trials.

Key Results and Future Outlook

Beyond reliability, FSO offers significant advantages in capacity and security. FSO beams are three orders of magnitude narrower than RF beams, providing inherent physical layer security and allowing for smaller apertures. Commercial retrofitted units already provide 10–30 Gbps with sub-millisecond latency (as low as 0.1 msec), meeting the rigorous demands of 5G and 6G networks.

Despite this promise, challenges remain in Pointing and Tracking (PAT), as narrow beams require high-precision alignment. Future research is also exploring the "THz Gap" to bridge the bandwidth-resilience divide and the development of self-powered nodes that use solar panels as low-speed optical antennas, potentially creating fully autonomous communication infrastructure.

Summary updated

Abstract

Progress in optical wireless communication (OWC) has unleashed the potential to transmit data in an ultra-fast manner without incurring large investments and bulk infrastructure. OWC includes wireless data transmissions in three optical sub-bands; ultraviolet, visible, and infrared. This paper discusses installing infrared OWC, known as free space optics (FSO), systems on top of installed radio frequency (RF) networks for outdoor applications to benefit from the reliability of RF links and the unlicensed broad optical spectrum, and the large data rates carried by laser beams propagating in free space. We equally review commercially available solutions and the hardware requirements for RF and FSO technology co-existence. The potential of hybrid RF/FSO for space communication is further discussed. Finally, open problems and future research directions are presented.
BibTeX
@article{trichili2021retrofitting,
  author = {Abderrahmen Trichili and Amr Ragheb and Dmitrii Briantcev and Maged Abdullah Esmail and Majid Altamimi and Islam Ashry and Boon S. Ooi and Saleh Al-Shebeili and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Retrofitting FSO Systems in Existing RF Infrastructure: A Non-Zero Sum Game Technology}},
  journal = {IEEE Open J. Commun. Soc.},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=gGTIgUYkh_B},
}
Figure