Retirement Expectations vs. Reality: If COVID-19 Did Not Impact Retirement Expectations Significantly, What Did?

Zhikun Liu, David Blanchett, Qi Sun, Naomi FinkFinancial 2025 · DOI

This study, recently published in Financial Services Review, investigates a surprising stability in American financial planning: despite the global upheaval of the pandemic, retirement expectations remained remarkably "sticky." By analyzing two massive datasets, the researchers demonstrate that while COVID-19 was a statistical "nonevent" for retirement timing, the gap between when people think they will retire and when they actually do remains a significant risk to financial security.

TL;DR

Americans' retirement expectations are largely immune to the COVID-19 pandemic, remaining anchored to Social Security milestones. However, reality often intervenes; over half of workers retire earlier than planned, driven primarily by health shocks and wealth changes rather than global crises.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Financial planning is built on a foundation of "expected retirement age." If a worker expects to retire at 67 but is forced out at 62, their savings may be insufficient to cover the extra five years of decumulation.

The authors set out to solve two puzzles:

  1. The COVID Effect: Did the pandemic—with its dual health and economic shocks—fundamentally shift how older Americans (age 50+) envision their final working years?
  2. The Expectation-Reality Gap: What specific socioeconomic factors cause the discrepancy between a person’s "planned" retirement and their "actual" retirement?

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged statistical approach to validate their findings across different populations:

  • Cross-Sectional Analysis: Using OLS (Ordinary Least Squares) regressions on recent survey data to look for "breaks" in trends during the pandemic.
  • Difference-in-Difference (DID): A quasi-experimental technique used to compare retirement expectations before and after the onset of COVID-19.
  • Longitudinal Fixed-Effects & Ordered Probit Regressions: These models were applied to the long-term HRS data to track how changes in an individual's life (e.g., getting a new diagnosis or gaining wealth) shifted their retirement trajectory over decades.

Datasets

The study leverages two distinct data sources:

  1. Prudential Financial Wellness Survey: A massive industry dataset containing over 241,000 responses (filtered to ~154,000 and ~87,000 for specific waves) collected between 2017 and 2021. This provided high-frequency data during the pandemic.
  2. Health and Retirement Study (HRS): The "gold standard" of longitudinal aging data. It tracks over 37,000 individuals over age 50 from 1992 to 2020, allowing the authors to compare expectations set in the 1990s with actual outcomes decades later.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Expectations are Bimodal, Reality is Left-Skewed: People tend to plan their retirement around "anchor ages"—specifically 62 (early Social Security) and 65/67 (Full Retirement Age/Medicare eligibility). However, actual retirement ages follow a "left-skewed" distribution, meaning the "tail" of people retiring much earlier than expected is much larger than the tail of those retiring later.
  • The Wealth Paradox: Interestingly, a wealth increase often leads people to expect to retire later (perhaps because they feel more capable and engaged), but it actually increases the likelihood of an earlier actual retirement (the "I have enough" effect).
  • COVID-19 as a "Nonevent": Despite headlines about the "Great Resignation," the data shows no statistically significant shift in retirement expectations due to the pandemic. The authors suggest that for older cohorts, retirement plans are "sticky" and resistant to temporary market or health volatility.
  • Health is the Great Accelerator: While many factors influence retirement, a major illness diagnosis is the most powerful driver for retiring earlier than planned.

Key Results

  • The Accuracy Problem: Only 1 in 6 (16%) of retirees actually retired in the exact year they predicted when they were in their 50s.
  • The Early Exit: More than 50% of participants retired earlier than they expected.
  • Quantifying the Gap: For some age cohorts, the average gap between reality and expectation was as high as 11.5 years.
  • Predictors of Delay: Factors that statistically correlate with retiring later than expected include improved health (+), getting married (+), and higher education levels (+).
  • Predictors of Early Exit: Factors correlating with retiring earlier than expected include wealth increases (-), disability (-), and major illness diagnosis (-).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that "retirement" is increasingly difficult to define. Many individuals "retire" only to re-enter the workforce part-time or in a different capacity (the "unretirement" trend). This study primarily focuses on the first recorded retirement.

Future research could explore the "well-being" outcomes of these gaps—does retiring five years early due to a health shock lead to significantly higher rates of poverty in late old age? Additionally, the authors suggest that financial planning tools need to move away from "point estimates" (e.g., "I will retire at 65") and toward probabilistic models that account for the high likelihood of an unexpected early exit.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using two data sets (a Prudential Financial Wellness Survey and the Health and Retirement Study), this study demonstrates that although there is generally a natural upward trend for older (age 50+) Americans to progressively delay their expected retirement age, this trend has no statistically significant relationship with the COVID-19 pandemic. The distribution of older Americans’ expected retirement ages is bimodal, often centered around two Social Security Benefit claiming ages – the early retirement age and full retirement age. However, actual retirement ages are more likely to follow a left-skewed distribution, whereby people appear to retire earlier than expected. The most significant factors that influence participants’ retirement decisions relative to expectations are health (+), wealth (-), age (+), change of marital status (+), mortality expectations (+), education levels (+), disability (-), and major illness diagnosis (-). Focusing on these factors can help the retirement benefits community explore strategies to mitigate the negative consequences of gaps between retirement expectations and reality. * “(-)” means the impact is negative, i.e., retire earlier than expected, and “(+)” means the impact is positive.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2025retirement,
  author = {Zhikun Liu and David Blanchett and Qi Sun and Naomi Fink},
  title = {{Retirement Expectations vs. Reality: If COVID-19 Did Not Impact Retirement Expectations Significantly, What Did?}},
  booktitle = {Financial},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.61190/fsr.v33i1.4052},
}
Figure