Abstract
Are there common mechanisms of neurogenesis used throughout an entire nervous system? Making use of the well-defined and relatively small size of the nervous system of the nematode C. elegans, we explored to what extent canonical proneural class I/II bHLH complexes are responsible for neurogenesis throughout the entire C. elegans nervous system. Distinct, lineage-specific proneural “class II” bHLH factors are generally thought to operate via interaction with a common, “class I” bHLH subunit, encoded by Daughterless in flies, the E (E2A, E2-2, HEB) proteins in vertebrates, and hlh-2 in C. elegans. To eliminate function of all proneuronal class I/II bHLH complexes, we therefore genetically removed maternal and zygotic hlh-2 gene activity. We observed broad effects on neurogenesis, but still detected normal neurogenesis in many distinct neuron-producing lineages of the central and peripheral nervous system. Moreover, we find that hlh-2 selectively affects some aspects of neuron differentiation while leaving others unaffected. While our studies confirm the function of proneuronal class I/II bHLH complexes in many different lineages throughout a nervous system, we conclude that their function is not universal, but rather restricted by lineage, cell type and components of differentiation programs affected.
Introduction
A fundamental question in developmental biology is whether universal genetic programs govern the construction of an entire nervous system. For decades, the "proneural" basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) transcription factors have been the primary candidates for such a role. In most animal models, these factors function as heterodimers: a lineage-specific "Class II" factor partners with a broadly expressed "Class I" factor (such as Daughterless in Drosophila or E proteins in vertebrates).
In C. elegans, HLH-2 is the sole Class I bHLH factor. Because HLH-2 is the obligate partner for all known proneural specialists in the worm, it has long been assumed that its removal would effectively halt neurogenesis across the organism. This study utilizes the mapped-out nervous system of C. elegans to test whether this "universal" mechanism actually holds true across all neuronal lineages.
Methodology
To investigate the requirement of HLH-2, the researchers employed a combination of genetic ablation and high-resolution imaging:
- Maternal/Zygotic Knockout ($hlh-2^{m/z}$): To circumvent "maternal rescue"—where protein provided by the mother allows a mutant embryo to develop partially—the authors used an unstable transgenic array to generate embryos lacking both maternal and zygotic HLH-2 activity.
- 4D Lineage Tracing: Using SIMI BioCell software and time-lapse microscopy, the team tracked cell divisions in real-time, comparing mutant development against the established "Sulston" wild-type lineage map.
- Molecular Marker Battery: A comprehensive set of fluorescent reporters (fosmids and CRISPR-tagged alleles) was used to assess neuronal identity at multiple levels:
- Pan-neuronal markers: Genes expressed by all neurons (e.g., rab-3, ric-4).
- Neurotransmitter markers: Genes defining specific chemical identities (e.g., eat-4 for glutamate, cho-1 for acetylcholine).
- Terminal selectors: Master regulators that define unique neuron-type identities (e.g., ttx-3).
Results
Mosaic Neurogenesis
The most striking finding was that HLH-2 is not universally required for neurogenesis. Of the 221 neurons born during embryogenesis, approximately 122 (over 55%) appeared to be generated normally in terms of physical position and timing, even in the total absence of their supposed essential proneural partner.
Lineage Transformations and Apoptosis
In lineages where HLH-2 is required, its absence led to predictable "proneural" transformations. Specifically, 68 neurons failed to differentiate and instead transformed into hypodermal (skin) cells. Another 9 cells underwent programmed cell death (apoptosis). These results confirm that while HLH-2 is a major driver of the neural-versus-skin fate decision in many lineages, it is not the sole arbiter for the entire system.
Decoupling of Differentiation Programs
The study revealed a fascinating discrepancy in how neurons differentiate. In $hlh-2$ mutants, many cells retained the expression of "terminal selector" genes and neurotransmitter markers while failing to express "pan-neuronal" genes. For example:
- Pan-neuronal markers were severely depleted, with fewer than 20 cells expressing rab-3 compared to the expected 122.
- Neurotransmitter markers were more resilient, with roughly 70 cells maintaining expression.
- Terminal Selectors like ttx-3 remained present in specific cell pairs (e.g., AIY, AIA, AIN), proving these neurons do not require HLH-2 to initiate their specific functional programs.
This suggests that the "basic" neuronal toolkit and the "specialized" functional program are controlled by independent genetic modules.
Discussion
These findings overturn the assumption that canonical Class I/II bHLH complexes are the universal gatekeepers of neurogenesis. The persistence of neurons like the AIY interneuron in $hlh-2$ null mutants suggests the existence of non-canonical pathways—perhaps involving Class II factors acting as homodimers or partnering with unidentified non-bHLH factors.
While the morphological disorganization of $hlh-2$ mutant embryos presents challenges in identifying every surviving neuron, the data clearly indicates a mosaic developmental strategy. Future research must now identify the alternative drivers that allow over half of the C. elegans nervous system to develop independently of the canonical proneural machinery.
Summary updated