Identification of multiple transcription factor genes potentially involved in the development of electrosensory versus mechanosensory lateral line organs

Martin Minařík, Melinda S. Modrell, J. Andrew Gillis, Alexander S Campbell, Isobel Fuller, Rachel Lyne, Gos Micklem, David Gela, Martin Pšenička, Clare V. H. BakerbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

Abstract

In electroreceptive jawed vertebrates, embryonic lateral line placodes give rise to electrosensory ampullary organs as well as mechanosensory neuromasts. Previous reports of shared gene expression suggest that conserved mechanisms underlie electroreceptor and mechanosensory hair cell development and that electroreceptors evolved as a transcriptionally related 'sister cell type' to hair cells. We previously identified only one transcription factor gene, Neurod4, as ampullary organ-restricted in the developing lateral line system of a chondrostean ray-finned fish, the Mississippi paddlefish (Polyodon spathula). The other 16 transcription factor genes we previously validated in paddlefish were expressed in both ampullary organs and neuromasts. Here, we used our published lateral line organ-enriched gene-set, together with a candidate gene approach, to identify 23 transcription factor genes expressed in the developing lateral line system of a more experimentally tractable chondrostean, the sterlet (Acipenser ruthenus), and/or that of paddlefish. Twelve are expressed in both ampullary organs and neuromasts, consistent with conservation of molecular mechanisms. Six are electrosensory-restricted on the head (Irx5, Insm1, Sp5, Satb2, MafA and Rorc), and five are the first-reported mechanosensory-restricted transcription factor genes (Foxg1, Sox8, Isl1, Hmx2 and Rorb). However, as previously reported, Sox8 is expressed in ampullary organs as well as neuromasts in a shark (Scyliorhinus canicula), suggesting the existence of lineage-specific differences between cartilaginous and ray-finned fishes. Overall, our results support the hypothesis that ampullary organs and neuromasts develop via largely conserved transcriptional mechanisms, and identify multiple transcription factors potentially involved in the formation of electrosensory versus mechanosensory lateral line organs.

Introduction

Most aquatic vertebrates possess a mechanosensory lateral line system composed of neuromasts that detect water displacement. However, ancestral lineages—including sharks, sturgeons, and paddlefish—also possess an electrosensory system of ampullary organs. Both organ types originate from the same embryonic lateral line placodes. This shared developmental origin has led to the hypothesis that electroreceptors are "sister cell types" to mechanosensory hair cells. This study seeks to identify the specific genetic "switches"—transcription factors—that determine whether a precursor cell differentiates into a mechanoreceptor or an electroreceptor.

Methods and Developmental Mapping

The research focused primarily on the sterlet (Acipenser ruthenus), a small sturgeon that serves as an experimentally tractable model for primitive ray-finned fish. Researchers utilized a candidate gene approach, cross-referencing previously published RNA-seq data with known transcription factors. They employed in situ hybridization (ISH) to visualize gene expression patterns across critical developmental stages (S35 to S45).

Figure 1: Developmental timeline of lateral line marker expression and organ distribution in the sterlet.

Key Insights: Shared Toolkits and Divergent Switches

The study successfully expanded the known genetic map of this system from 17 to 40 transcription factors, revealing a complex interplay of shared and restricted genetic instructions.

The Shared "Sister Cell" Toolkit

Twelve of the identified transcription factors were expressed in both neuromasts and ampullary organs. This includes well-known "master regulators" of hair cell development such as Atoh1, Pou4f3, and Gfi1. The presence of these genes in both organ types strongly supports the theory that electroreceptors and hair cells share a deeply conserved developmental program.

Molecular Divergence

The researchers identified 11 transcription factors that act as organ-specific markers:

  • Electrosensory-Restricted: Six genes (Irx5, Satb2, Insm1, Sp5, MafA, Rorc) were found to be specific to the developing ampullary organs on the head.
  • Mechanosensory-Restricted: Five genes (Foxg1, Sox8, Isl1, Hmx2, Rorb) were identified as the first-ever reported mechanosensory-restricted transcription factors in these species.
Figure 2: High-magnification view of transcription factor expression distinguishing neuromasts (black arrowheads) from ampullary organs (white arrowheads) at stage 45.

Evolutionary Implications and Future Directions

The discovery of reciprocal markers, such as the nuclear receptors Rorb (mechanosensory) and Rorc (electrosensory), suggests a binary fate-determination mechanism where related genes have been co-opted for different sensory roles. Furthermore, the observation that Sox8 is mechanosensory-restricted in sturgeons but shared in sharks highlights how evolutionary lineages can "rewire" conserved genetic building blocks over hundreds of millions of years.

While this study provides a comprehensive spatial and temporal map of gene expression, the researchers emphasize that these findings are currently descriptive. The next phase of research will involve functional validation using CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing in the sterlet to determine if knocking out these specific transcription factors disrupts the formation of one sensory system while leaving the other intact. Such studies will be essential to confirm the precise roles of these genes in sensory evolution.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract In electroreceptive jawed vertebrates, embryonic lateral line placodes give rise to electrosensory ampullary organs as well as mechanosensory neuromasts. Previous reports of shared gene expression suggest that conserved mechanisms underlie electroreceptor and mechanosensory hair cell development and that electroreceptors evolved as a transcriptionally related ’sister cell type’ to hair cells. We previously identified only one transcription factor gene, Neurod4 , as ampullary organ-restricted in the developing lateral line system of a chondrostean ray-finned fish, the Mississippi paddlefish ( Polyodon spathula ). The other 16 transcription factor genes we previously validated in paddlefish were expressed in both ampullary organs and neuromasts. Here, we used our published lateral line organ-enriched gene-set (arising from differential bulk RNA-seq in late-larval paddlefish), together with a candidate gene approach, to identify 23 transcription factor genes expressed in the developing lateral line system of a more experimentally tractable chondrostean, the sterlet ( Acipenser ruthenus , a small sturgeon), and/or that of paddlefish. Twelve are expressed in both ampullary organs and neuromasts, consistent with conservation of molecular mechanisms. Six are electrosensory-restricted on the head (Irx5 , Insm1 , Sp5 , Satb2 , MafA and Rorc ), and five are the first-reported mechanosensory-restricted transcription factor genes ( Foxg1 , Sox8 , Isl1 , Hmx2 and Rorb ). However, as previously reported, Sox8 is expressed in ampullary organs as well as neuromasts in a shark ( Scyliorhinus canicula ), suggesting the existence of lineage-specific differences between cartilaginous and ray-finned fishes. Overall, our results support the hypothesis that ampullary organs and neuromasts develop via largely conserved transcriptional mechanisms, and identify multiple transcription factors potentially involved in the formation of electrosensory versus mechanosensory lateral line organs.
BibTeX
@misc{minarik2023identification,
  author = {Martin Minařík and Melinda S. Modrell and J. Andrew Gillis and Alexander S Campbell and Isobel Fuller and Rachel Lyne and Gos Micklem and David Gela and Martin Pšenička and Clare V. H. Baker},
  title = {{Identification of multiple transcription factor genes potentially involved in the development of electrosensory versus mechanosensory lateral line organs}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.04.14.536701},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure