Abstract
In mammals, starburst amacrine cells are centrally involved in motion vision and a new study in PLOS Biology, by Yan and colleagues finds that zebrafish have them, too. They coexist with a second pair of starburst-like neurons, but neither appears to be strongly motion selective.
Introduction
For over a century, the basic "blueprint" of the vertebrate retina—comprising five classes of neurons arranged in three nuclear layers—has been well-recognized. However, the extent to which specific microcircuits within these layers are conserved across the evolutionary tree remains a fundamental question in neurobiology. In mammals, the ability to detect motion direction (direction selectivity) is primarily mediated by Starburst Amacrine Cells (SACs). These unique, axonless neurons are characterized by their radial, star-like morphology and the co-release of GABA and acetylcholine. Given the critical survival value of motion detection, researchers have long hypothesized that these circuits represent an ancestral trait. A recent study by Yan and colleagues investigates whether zebrafish possess orthologous circuits and if these circuits serve the same functional purpose.
Methodology
To bridge the gap between mammalian and teleost neurobiology, the researchers employed a multi-disciplinary approach:
- Immunoreactivity: Staining for choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) identified cholinergic strata in the inner retina, revealing the structural organization of these circuits.
- Morphological Analysis: High-resolution imaging allowed for the comparison of dendritic structures, such as the "curvy" dendrites typical of mammals versus the "straight" dendrites seen in zebrafish.
- Transcriptomics: Single-cell RNA sequencing was used to identify genetic "fingerprints," linking cell types across species as diverse as lampreys and mammals.
- Functional Imaging: Calcium imaging in larval zebrafish dendrites measured responses to moving stimuli to assess direction selectivity.
Comparative Morphology and Function
The study confirmed that zebrafish possess "On" and "Off" SACs that correspond directly to mammalian versions, indicating these cells originated at least 400 million years ago. However, zebrafish also possess an additional class of cholinergic neurons: the bhlhe22 cells. These cells exhibit a radial organization even more pronounced than that of SACs but are notably absent in the mammalian lineage.
Interestingly, the study found that form does not always dictate function. In mammals, the radial symmetry of SACs is essential for high direction selectivity. In contrast, zebrafish SACs and bhlhe22 cells exhibit only weak directional signals. Furthermore, despite the small size of the larval zebrafish, their SACs cover a significantly larger portion of the visual field (~15°) compared to mammalian SACs (~2°).
Key Results and Evolutionary Implications
The findings highlight several critical points:
- Conservation of Cell Types: SACs are an ancient feature of the vertebrate retina, present in both ray-finned fish and tetrapods.
- Lineage-Specific Specialization: The discovery of bhlhe22 cells suggests that ancestral fish may have had a more diverse repertoire of cholinergic neurons, some of which were lost in mammals.
- Functional Divergence: The weak direction selectivity in zebrafish SACs suggests that the computational role of these cells has shifted over time. In fish, motion detection may rely on different, perhaps more primitive, neural mechanisms.
Conclusion and Future Directions
While technical constraints in imaging tiny larval dendrites might partially explain the weak directional responses, the results suggest a significant evolutionary divergence in circuit function. If SACs are not the primary drivers of motion vision in fish, their actual role remains to be discovered. Future research focusing on the bhlhe22 neurons and the ancestral mechanisms of direction selectivity will be essential to understanding how neural circuits evolve to meet the visual demands of different species.
Summary updated