Center-surround interactions underlie bipolar cell motion sensitivity in the mouse retina

Sarah Strauß, Maria M. Korympidou, Yanli Ran, Katrin Franke, Timm Schubert, Tom Baden, Philipp Berens, Thomas Euler, Anna VlasitsNature Communications 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Motion sensing is a critical aspect of vision. We studied the representation of motion in mouse retinal bipolar cells and found that some bipolar cells are radially direction selective, preferring the origin of small object motion trajectories. Using a glutamate sensor, we directly observed bipolar cells synaptic output and found that there are radial direction selective and non-selective bipolar cell types, the majority being selective, and that radial direction selectivity relies on properties of the center-surround receptive field. We used these bipolar cell receptive fields along with connectomics to design biophysical models of downstream cells. The models and additional experiments demonstrated that bipolar cells pass radial direction selective excitation to starburst amacrine cells, which contributes to their directional tuning. As bipolar cells provide excitation to most amacrine and ganglion cells, their radial direction selectivity may contribute to motion processing throughout the visual system.

Introduction

Motion detection is a fundamental computation in the visual system, traditionally attributed to specialized circuits involving Starburst Amacrine Cells (SACs) and Retinal Ganglion Cells (RGCs). However, the role of Bipolar Cells (BCs)—the primary excitatory interneurons of the retina—has remained a subject of debate. Are they simple relays of light intensity, or do they perform their own motion computations? This study investigates whether BCs possess "radial direction selectivity" (rDS), a preference for motion originating within their receptive field center, and how this property influences the broader retinal circuit.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-disciplinary approach to track glutamate release at high resolution. They utilized 2-photon imaging of the fluorescent glutamate sensor iGluSnFR across the Inner Plexiform Layer (IPL) of the mouse retina, allowing them to monitor the synaptic output of thousands of individual BC terminals.

Spatio-temporal receptive fields (RFs) were mapped for over 3,000 regions of interest (ROIs) using 1D noise stimuli. To test for motion sensitivity, the researchers presented small bar stimuli moving in trajectories defined as "Originates" (starting in the RF center), "Terminates" (ending in the center), or "Passes through" (crossing the center).

Experimental design for testing radial direction selectivity (rDS) using different motion trajectories relative to the receptive field center.

Computational linear convolution models were developed to predict BC responses based on their RF properties. Additionally, biophysical "ball-and-stick" models of SAC dendrites were used to simulate how these cells integrate BC inputs. Pharmacological blockers for $GABA_C$ (TPMPA) and glycine (strychnine) receptors were applied to assess the role of inhibitory feedback in shaping BC motion sensitivity.

Key Results

Functional imaging revealed that the majority of BC types exhibit a significant preference for motion originating in their RF center compared to motion terminating there. This preference was quantified using a d' metric, with the population showing a clear shift toward positive values for "Originates vs. Terminates" comparisons, while showing no such bias for simple directional comparisons (e.g., Right vs. Left).

Cumulative distribution of preference (d') for motion originating vs. terminating (O vs. T, black) and right vs. left (R vs. L, grey). The rightward shift of the black curve indicates a population-level preference for originating motion.

The Mechanism of rDS

The study identified that rDS is an emergent property of the classic center-surround RF architecture. Because the inhibitory surround is spatially offset and temporally delayed relative to the excitatory center, it suppresses inward motion (surround-to-center) more effectively than outward motion (center-to-surround).

A strong negative correlation (Spearman $\rho = -0.89$) was found between the latency of the surround response and the strength of rDS; longer surround delays resulted in more robust motion selectivity. Furthermore, blocking $GABA_C$ receptors weakened the surround and reduced rDS in specific BC clusters, proving that lateral inhibition from amacrine cells actively sharpens this sensitivity.

Discussion and Implications

These findings suggest that downstream neurons like SACs do not compute direction selectivity from scratch but rather "inherit" a pre-filtered excitatory signal from BCs. Connectomic-based models demonstrated that the specific anatomical wiring of BCs onto SAC dendrites, combined with BC rDS, creates a robust preference for centrifugal motion (from the SAC soma to the dendritic tips).

By filtering for coherent motion at the very first synapse in the inner retina, BCs act as active motion processors rather than passive relays. This radial direction selectivity likely contributes to motion processing throughout the visual system. Future work will explore how these center-surround interactions behave under the complex conditions of natural visual environments and whether similar mechanisms exist in other species, such as primates.

Summary updated

Abstract

Motion sensing is a critical aspect of vision. We studied the representation of motion in mouse retinal bipolar cells and found that some bipolar cells are radially direction selective, preferring the origin of small object motion trajectories. Using a glutamate sensor, we directly observed bipolar cells synaptic output and found that there are radial direction selective and non-selective bipolar cell types, the majority being selective, and that radial direction selectivity relies on properties of the center-surround receptive field. We used these bipolar cell receptive fields along with connectomics to design biophysical models of downstream cells. The models and additional experiments demonstrated that bipolar cells pass radial direction selective excitation to starburst amacrine cells, which contributes to their directional tuning. As bipolar cells provide excitation to most amacrine and ganglion cells, their radial direction selectivity may contribute to motion processing throughout the visual system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{strau2022center,
  author = {Sarah Strauß and Maria M. Korympidou and Yanli Ran and Katrin Franke and Timm Schubert and Tom Baden and Philipp Berens and Thomas Euler and Anna Vlasits},
  title = {{Center-surround interactions underlie bipolar cell motion sensitivity in the mouse retina}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-022-32762-7},
}
Figure