Responses of a Coronal Hole to a Fast Flare-driven Coronal Wave

Xiaofan Zhang, Huadong Chen, Guiping Zhou, Li Feng, Yang Su, Jinhan Guo, Leping Li, Wei Lin, Suli Ma, Yuandeng Shen, Ruisheng Zheng, Suo Liu, Xianyong Bai, Yuanyong Deng, Jingxiu Wang

This study, recently published by Zhang et al., provides a rare, multi-instrument look at how a massive solar "tsunami"—a coronal wave—interacts with a coronal hole (CH). By combining data from the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) and the newer Advanced Space-based Solar Observatory (ASO-S), the team quantified the energy injected into these open-magnetic-field regions, revealing that such waves might play a significant role in heating the corona and accelerating the solar wind.

TL;DR

Researchers observed a fast coronal wave from an X5.0 flare "crashing" into a coronal hole, causing an immediate 9% temperature spike and a subsequent 14% drop in plasma density. The study quantifies a massive energy injection ($2.2 \times 10^8$ erg cm⁻²), suggesting these waves are key drivers of thermodynamic changes in the solar atmosphere.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coronal waves are large-scale disturbances in the Sun's atmosphere, often triggered by solar flares or Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs). While we’ve known they exist for decades, their interaction with Coronal Holes (CHs)—regions of "open" magnetic fields that act as the source of fast solar wind—remains poorly understood.

The central challenge is the "energy budget." Scientists want to know exactly how much energy these waves transfer to the CHs and how that energy alters the plasma's temperature and density. Previous studies focused on wave kinematics (speed and direction); this paper shifts the focus to the thermodynamic "makeover" the coronal hole undergoes during and after the wave's passage.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-wavelength approach to track the event on December 31, 2023:

  • Imaging: They used EUV data from SDO/AIA and, crucially, Lyman-alpha observations from the Solar Disk Imager (SDI) aboard ASO-S. Lyman-alpha observations are a relatively new frontier for tracing these disturbances across different atmospheric layers.
  • Differential Emission Measure (DEM): This mathematical technique allowed the team to derive the plasma's temperature ($T$) and electron density ($n_e$) from multi-band EUV images.
  • Energy Budget Analysis: The researchers didn't just look at temperature; they calculated the total energy change by accounting for thermal energy, radiative losses, and heat conduction.
  • Time-Distance Mapping: By slicing the imaging data, they measured the precise velocities of the wave components as they traversed the solar disk.

Datasets

The study integrated data from several high-profile solar missions:

  • SDO/AIA & HMI: For EUV imaging and magnetic field mapping.
  • ASO-S/SDI & HXI: For Lyman-alpha imaging and Hard X-ray data (to locate the flare's energy source).
  • CHASE: H-alpha data from the Chinese H$\alpha$ Solar Explorer to identify filament structures.
  • GOES-18: For soft X-ray flux to classify the flare (X5.0).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Dual-Wave Phenomenon: The wave wasn't a single wall of energy. It split into two components: a fast component (~950 km/s) that successfully traversed the coronal hole and a slow component (~470 km/s) that "piled up" at the hole's boundary, forming a stationary-mode wave.
  • Thermodynamic Transformation: The coronal hole didn't simply return to its original state. After the wave passed, the hole reached a new equilibrium: it was slightly hotter but significantly less dense (a 14% decrease).
  • Energy Reflection: While the energy input was massive, the authors estimate that ~70% of the wave's kinetic energy was actually reflected away or converted at the CH boundary, rather than being absorbed.
  • Solar Wind Link: The sharp decrease in density suggests the wave's energy might "propel" plasma out of the coronal hole, potentially contributing to the acceleration of the solar wind.

Key Results

  • Temperature Spike: The CH temperature rose from 1.31 MK to 1.43 MK during the wave's passage.
  • Density Fluctuations: Initial density rose from $1.62 \times 10^8$ to $1.76 \times 10^8$ cm⁻³ (due to compression) before dropping to a new, lower baseline.
  • Total Energy Input: The wave delivered an average energy of $2.2 \times 10^8$ erg cm⁻² to the coronal hole.
  • Wave Speed: The fast component moved at ~948 km/s, nearly matching the local Alfvén speed, suggesting it was a shocked magnetosonic wave.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that deriving temperature from DEM involves inherent uncertainties (they used Monte Carlo simulations to validate their signals). They also noted that the "blacked out" regions in some data sets (due to extreme flare brightness) required them to exclude certain data points.

Future Work: The team suggests that higher-resolution observations are needed to confirm if these temperature elevations are a universal feature of wave-CH interactions. They also aim to further explore how this energy injection specifically feeds into the acceleration mechanisms of the fast solar wind.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Coronal waves, significant solar phenomena, act as diagnostic tools for scientists studying solar atmosphere properties. Here, we present a novel observation detailing how a coronal wave event, associated with an X5.0 class flare, influenced the properties of an adjacent coronal hole (CH) through interaction. The coronal wave was observed in both extreme-ultraviolet (EUV) observations from the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly on board the Solar Dynamics Observatory and Ly α observations from the Solar Disk Imager on board the Advanced Space-based Solar Observatory. Utilizing the method of differential emission measure, we found that as the coronal wave passed through, the adjacent CH experienced an increase in temperature from 1.31 to 1.43 MK and a rise in density from ∼1.62 × 10 8 to 1.76 × 10 8 cm −3 within the rising period of ∼7 minutes. Subsequently, after the wave passed, the entire CH transitioned to a new state with a slight temperature increase and a 14% decrease in density, with more pronounced changes observed at the CH’s boundary. Taking into account the impacts of radiative loss and heat conduction, the coronal wave was estimated to provide an average energy of 2.2 × 10 8 erg cm −2 to the CH during the short rising period. This study highlights the identification of the coronal wave in both EUV and Ly α observations, shedding light on the significant energy input, particularly within the CH. These findings provide new insights into better understanding kinematics of fast coronal waves, energy transfer processes open versus closed magnetic topologies, and the possible acceleration of solar winds.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2025responses,
  author = {Xiaofan Zhang and Huadong Chen and Guiping Zhou and Li Feng and Yang Su and Jinhan Guo and Leping Li and Wei Lin and Suli Ma and Yuandeng Shen and Ruisheng Zheng and Suo Liu and Xianyong Bai and Yuanyong Deng and Jingxiu Wang},
  title = {{Responses of a Coronal Hole to a Fast Flare-driven Coronal Wave}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3847/2041-8213/ade38c},
}

Loading related content...

Figure