Resonance in rarefaction and shock curves: local analysis and numerics of the continuation method

Amaury Álvarez, Guilherme Tegoni Goedert, D. Marchesin

Abstract

In this paper, we describe certain crucial steps in the development of an algorithm for finding the Riemann solution in systems of conservation laws. We relax the classical hypotheses of strict hyperbolicity and genuine nonlinearity of Lax. First, we present a procedure for continuing wave curves beyond points where characteristic speeds coincide, i.e., at wave curve points of maximal codimensionality. This procedure requires strict hyperbolicity on both sides of the coincidence locus. Loss of strict hyperbolicity is regularized by a Generalized Jordan Chain, which serves to construct a four-fold submanifold structure on which wave curves can be continued. Second, we analyze the case of loss of genuine nonlinearity. We prove a new result: the existence of composite wave curves when the composite wave traverses either the inflection locus or an anomalous part of the non-local composite wave curve. In this sense, we find conditions under which the composite field is well defined and its singularities can be removed, allowing use of our continuation method. Finally, we present numerical examples for a non-strictly hyperbolic system of conservation laws.

Introduction

In fluid dynamics and physics, systems of conservation laws are fundamental for describing the transport of quantities like mass and momentum. Solving these systems often involves the "Riemann problem," which predicts the evolution of a medium when two distinct states meet. For decades, Lax’s theory has provided the standard framework for these solutions, based on the assumptions of strict hyperbolicity (unique wave speeds) and genuine nonlinearity (predictable wave sharpening or spreading).

However, many real-world models—such as multi-phase flow in porous media for oil recovery or carbon sequestration—violate these assumptions. In these cases, wave speeds can coincide (resonance) or nonlinearity can vanish (inflection points). These singularities cause standard numerical integrators to fail, as they cannot determine the correct path for wave curves at these critical junctures. This paper introduces a robust numerical algorithm designed to navigate these "speed bumps" by lifting calculations into higher-dimensional spaces.

Methodology

The proposed continuation method is designed to maintain numerical stability through mathematical singularities. Key components include:

  • Manifold Lifting: Instead of analyzing wave curves solely in the physical state space, the problem is lifted into an extended space that includes wave speeds ($\lambda$) as a coordinate. This transformation turns complex intersections into smooth, navigable surfaces.
  • Generalized Jordan Chains: At points where wave speeds coincide, matrices become singular. The authors employ Jordan chains to regularize these points, providing the directional information necessary for the algorithm to proceed.
  • Versal Deformation Theory: This is used to establish local coordinate systems near coincidence points, ensuring accuracy even as the mathematical discriminant approaches zero.
  • Event Detection: The algorithm identifies when a curve encounters a coincidence or inflection locus, triggering specialized logic to continue the solution.
Lifting wave curves into an extended state space (U, λ) to resolve speed coincidences.

Key Insights and Results

The research demonstrates that the "coincidence locus" where speeds match is not a dead end but a submanifold of codimension one. By understanding its geometry, the algorithm can predict how a rarefaction wave transforms into a different family or a shock wave upon crossing it. A significant finding is that singularities in the composite wave field can be removed through proper scaling of eigenvectors, allowing the use of standard ODE solvers in previously unstable regions.

Furthermore, the authors prove that when a rarefaction curve hits an inflection point, a "composite wave"—a hybrid of rarefaction and shock—must exist to continue the solution. The algorithm was validated using models such as the ICDOW system for chemical fluid flow and the Quadratic Corey Permeability model, which features an umbilic point where wave speeds coincide. The implementation in the RPN C++ library showed that the lifted coordinate system successfully avoids the error accumulation typical of solvers attempting to integrate nearly tangent curves.

Conclusion and Future Work

While this method provides a significant advancement for non-strictly hyperbolic systems, challenges remain. The method's sensitivity to the small parameter ($\epsilon$) used to jump past singularities requires careful balancing. Additionally, the current framework focuses on "codimension one" coincidences where two speeds match; systems where three or more speeds coincide (higher codimension) represent a more complex frontier for future research. Finally, moving toward a fully automated "black-box" solver will require further streamlining of the manual setup for model derivatives and Hessians.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we describe certain crucial steps in the development of an algorithm for finding the Riemann solution in systems of conservation laws. We relax the classical hypotheses of strict hyperbolicity and genuine nonlinearity of Lax. First, we present a procedure for continuing wave curves beyond points where characteristic speeds coincide, i.e., at wave curve points of maximal codimensionality. This procedure requires strict hyperbolicity on both sides of the coincidence locus. Loss of strict hyperbolicity is regularized a Generalized Jordan Chain, which serves to construct a four-fold submanifold structure on which wave curves can be continued. Second, we analyze the case of loss of genuine nonlinearity. We prove a new result: the existence of composite wave curves when the composite wave traverses either the inflection locus or an anomalous part of the non-local composite wave curve. In this sense, we find conditions under which the composite field is well defined and its singularities can be removed, allowing use of our continuation method. Finally, we present numerical examples for a non-strictly hyperbolic system of conservation laws.
BibTeX
@article{alvarez2020resonance,
  author = {Amaury Álvarez and Guilherme Tegoni Goedert and D. Marchesin},
  title = {{Resonance in rarefaction and shock curves: local analysis and numerics of the continuation method}},
  journal = {Journal of Hyperbolic Differential Equations},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1142/s0219891620500198},
}
Figure