Abstract
Third-party payment has become an important part of the current payment method in China. However, there are many risks associated with the development of the third-party payment network. The establishment of the Nets Union in 2017 had a significant impact on the standardization of the entire third-party payment market. By further researching the third-party payment risk under the background of Nets Union Clearing Platform, combining with the empirical analysis for the case of Alipay, this paper constructs the third-party payment risk model by AHP and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, then making some recommendations for Third-party payment risk control management.
Introduction
Before 2017, Chinese third-party payment providers (TPPs) like Alipay operated under a "direct connection" model, bypassing the central bank to connect directly with commercial banks. While efficient, this created a regulatory "black box" that obscured money laundering, fund misappropriation, and systemic financial risks. The establishment of the Nets Union Clearing Platform centralized these transactions, providing transparency but introducing new operational dynamics. This paper quantifies the risk landscape for industry leader Alipay within this centralized environment, moving from qualitative assessments to a structured mathematical framework.
Methodology
The study utilizes a two-stage multi-criteria decision-making approach to evaluate risk across five primary dimensions: Financial, Market, Credit, Policy/Regulation, and Security/Technology.
1. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)
AHP was employed to determine the relative importance (weight) of various risk factors. A hierarchy was constructed featuring 18 secondary indicators nested under the five primary categories. Expert comparisons on a 1–9 scale were used to calculate weights, ensuring mathematical consistency with a Consistency Ratio (CR) below 0.1.
2. Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation
To account for the inherent subjectivity in risk assessment, Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation maps expert survey results (from 40 scholars and financial practitioners) into "membership degrees" across five risk levels (Low, Relatively Low, Medium, Relatively High, High). This provides a nuanced risk profile rather than a binary output.
Key Results and Analysis
The model produced a quantitative risk profile for Alipay, revealing that while the overall risk is manageable, specific vulnerabilities persist.
- Financial Risk Dominance: In the AHP weighting, Financial Risk (X1) was assigned the highest weight (0.45), followed by Security/Technology Risk (X5) at 0.28. This indicates that experts prioritize the movement and "sedimentation" of funds as the most critical monitoring area.
- Security as the Weakest Link: Despite the regulatory shift, Security and Technology Risk emerged as the most significant threat. As shown in the evaluation matrix, it was the only primary indicator to reach the "Relatively High" tier.
- Market Stability: Market Risk (competition and customer loss) was rated "Relatively Low," suggesting that established players like Alipay face fewer existential threats from new entrants in the post-Nets Union era compared to technical or regulatory hurdles.
As seen in the matrix above, $B_5$ (Security and Technology Risk) shows a high membership degree of 0.741 in the fourth column (Relatively High), while $B_2$ (Market Risk) peaks at 0.435 in the second column (Relatively Low). The overall risk rating for Alipay was calculated as "Medium" with a membership degree of 0.406.
Conclusion
The transition to the Nets Union Clearing Platform has successfully increased financial transparency but has centralized operational risks. Security and technology vulnerabilities now represent the most acute threat to major TPPs. Future risk management should focus on technical standards and legislative clarity regarding the ownership of interest on "sedimentary" funds. While this study provides a robust snapshot, the rapid evolution of financial technology necessitates frequent recalibration of the risk model weights.
Summary updated