Research on Risk Evaluation of Community Group Buying Supply Chain

Weigang Zhang, Min HuangAdvances 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

Community Group Buying (CGB) has rapidly evolved from a niche retail model into a trillion-RMB industry in China. Driven by the "14th Five-Year Plan for Modern Logistics" and shifts in consumer behavior, this "online pre-sale + offline pickup" model relies on a decentralized network of "group leaders"—typically local shop owners—to manage the final mile of delivery. However, the reliance on perishables like fresh produce and non-professional logistics points creates a fragile supply chain. This paper establishes a quantitative framework to evaluate these risks, moving beyond qualitative descriptions to provide actionable insights for platform stability.

Methodology

The study utilizes a hybrid multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) approach to quantify supply chain vulnerabilities:

  1. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): A hierarchical structure was developed consisting of 6 primary indicators and 24 secondary indicators. Expert rankings were used to construct a judgment matrix, allowing for the calculation of specific weights for each factor. A consistency check was performed to ensure the reliability of these inputs.
  2. Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation (FCE): To address the subjective nature of "risk," FCE was employed to process expert survey data. This method converts qualitative assessments into a quantitative membership degree matrix, resulting in a final numerical risk score.
Hierarchical structure of risk indicators for the CGB supply chain.

Analysis of Risk Weights

The AHP analysis revealed significant disparities in the importance of different risk categories. As shown in the judgment matrix, the "Warehousing and Distribution Risk" (A2) was assigned the highest weight of 0.372. This confirms that in a model centered on fresh produce, the efficiency and reliability of the cold chain are the primary determinants of success.

AHP judgment matrix and calculated weights for primary risk indicators.

Conversely, "Information Technology Risk" (A4) received the lowest weight (0.035) and a relatively low risk score. This suggests that the digital infrastructure—including apps and payment systems—is considered mature and stable compared to physical logistics operations.

Key Insights and Results

The study calculated an overall supply chain risk score of 60.709, placing the CGB sector in a "medium-high" risk category. The evaluation highlighted three primary areas of concern:

  • Procurement Supply Risk (A1): Scored 63.602, driven by challenges in vendor selection and product quality maintenance.
  • External Environment Risk (A6): Scored 63.412, reflecting intense peer competition and a shifting regulatory landscape.
  • Service Risk (A5): While not the highest weighted, the "Group Leader" model introduces significant human-centric risks, such as moral hazard and inconsistent after-sales handling, which can jeopardize brand reputation.

Conclusion

While the digital foundations of Community Group Buying are robust, the physical supply chain remains vulnerable. Management intervention should prioritize the "physical" side of the operation—specifically vendor management and cold storage logistics—to mitigate the high risks identified in procurement and warehousing. Future research should examine the effectiveness of specific mitigation strategies, such as standardized training for group leaders or the integration of blockchain for real-time tracking, to lower these fuzzy risk scores over time.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024research,
  author = {Weigang Zhang and Min Huang},
  title = {{Research on Risk Evaluation of Community Group Buying Supply Chain}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2991/978-94-6463-570-6\_3},
}
Figure