Research on the Matching of Academic Passion Levels of University Teachers in Different Positions in China

Li Sun, Ma. Esperanza S. Malang -Journal of Education and Educational Research 2025 · DOI

Abstract

This study aims to explore the differences in academic passion among university teachers in different types of positions and to verify whether the classification evaluation system advocated by the Ministry of Education of China can effectively identify the academic passion levels of teachers. A questionnaire survey yielded 373 valid responses from teachers at three universities in China. This study examined the influence of demographic factors, including gender, age, educational background, teaching experience, family income, and position type, on academic passion. Data analysis revealed significant differences in academic passion across various dimensions for teachers in different positions. Teaching-oriented teachers exhibited high levels of teaching passion, while research-oriented teachers showed more prominent research passion. Teaching and research-oriented teachers demonstrated a balance between the two. Additionally, factors such as age, degree, and years of teaching experience had significant effects on different dimensions of academic passion. The findings provide empirical evidence for the application of the classification evaluation system in identifying academic passion among university teachers and offer insights for optimizing education policies.

Introduction

For years, university faculty evaluation in China followed a relatively uniform path. However, starting in 2018, the Ministry of Education introduced a "classification evaluation system," splitting faculty into three tracks: teaching-focused, research-focused, and balanced. The core question addressed by this research is whether this bureaucratic categorization reflects the internal psychological reality of teachers. If a teacher is labeled "research-focused" but possesses a deep, harmonious passion for teaching, the system fails. This study seeks to verify if these policy-driven labels accurately "match" the academic passion levels of individuals, while exploring how demographic variables influence these dimensions of passion.

Methodology

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using a questionnaire survey of 373 full-time teachers at three universities in China. The study is grounded in Vallerand’s Dualistic Model of Passion, which distinguishes between Harmonious Passion (autonomous internalization and high satisfaction) and Obsessive Passion (driven by external pressures or self-esteem).

The "Academic Passion Scale," adapted from Yan and Min (2020), was used to measure both harmonious and obsessive passion across teaching and research domains. Because the data did not follow a normal distribution, non-parametric methods were utilized: the Kruskal-Wallis H test for multi-group comparisons (e.g., age, position type) and the Mann-Whitney U test for gender differences.

Results and Analysis

Policy-Reality Alignment

A primary finding of this study is that the "categorized evaluation" system is scientifically valid. Administrative job classifications largely align with teachers' actual psychological passion. As shown in the data regarding work interest, teachers in teaching-oriented roles demonstrate significantly higher teaching passion (Mean Rank 241.4), while research-oriented teachers exhibit higher research passion (Mean Rank 219.45).

Kruskal-Wallis H test results for work interest across passion dimensions

Demographic Influences on Passion

The study identified several distinct "passion profiles" based on demographic factors:

  • The "Mid-Career Bottleneck": Teachers aged 31–50 exhibited lower levels of both teaching and research passion compared to their younger (<30) and older (≥51) colleagues. For instance, teachers aged 51+ had the highest teaching passion (Mean Rank 244.41), while those under 30 had the highest research passion (Mean Rank 237.75). This suggests a "bottleneck" period where professional burnout or life pressures may stifle academic enthusiasm.
  • The Education Paradox: Higher educational attainment (Doctorates) correlates strongly with research passion but shows a negative correlation with teaching passion. Conversely, those with Bachelor’s degrees showed the highest harmonious teaching passion.
  • Gender Nuance: While overall passion levels were similar, women demonstrated significantly higher harmonious teaching passion (p = 0.030) than men, suggesting a more autonomous and identity-integrated approach to the classroom.
Kruskal-Wallis H test results for age across passion dimensions

Discussion and Conclusion

This research validates China’s shift toward "categorized evaluation" for university faculty, proving that administrative job classifications largely align with teachers' actual psychological passion. However, the findings also highlight that demographic factors like age and education level create distinct challenges that require targeted institutional support.

Limitations and Future Directions

The study is limited by its sample scope (three universities) and its cross-sectional design, which captures only a "snapshot" in time. There is also a potential for self-reporting bias. Future work should include qualitative interviews to understand the mechanisms behind passion formation and longitudinal studies to track how passion evolves over a career. Additionally, exploring how passion levels differ across specific academic disciplines would provide deeper insights for optimizing education policies.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study aims to explore the differences in academic passion among university teachers in different types of positions and to verify whether the classification evaluation system advocated by the Ministry of Education of China can effectively identify the academic passion levels of teachers. A questionnaire survey yielded 373 valid responses from teachers at three universities in China. This study examined the influence of demographic factors, including gender, age, educational background, teaching experience, family income, and position type, on academic passion. Data analysis revealed significant differences in academic passion across various dimensions for teachers in different positions. Teaching-oriented teachers exhibited high levels of teaching passion, while research-oriented teachers showed more prominent research passion. Teaching and research-oriented teachers demonstrated a balance between the two. Additionally, factors such as age, degree, and years of teaching experience had significant effects on different dimensions of academic passion. The findings provide empirical evidence for the application of the classification evaluation system in identifying academic passion among university teachers and offer insights for optimizing education policies.
BibTeX
@article{sun2025research,
  author = {Li Sun and Ma. Esperanza S. Malang -},
  title = {{Research on the Matching of Academic Passion Levels of University Teachers in Different Positions in China}},
  journal = {Journal of Education and Educational Research},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.54097/yfmfe127},
}
Figure