Research on the Evaluation of the Implementation Effectiveness of Huizhou's Talent Policies

Xin Dong, Yong Li, Chunming Hou, Zeng MiaoInternational Academic Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper evaluates the effectiveness of talent-attraction policies in Huizhou, a key node city within China’s Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area (GBA). By comparing Huizhou against heavyweights like Shenzhen and Guangzhou, the authors reveal a significant "policy gap" and propose a "Four Attractions" strategy to help the city overcome the "siphon effect" of its more powerful neighbors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the hyper-competitive landscape of the GBA, cities are locked in a "talent war." While Huizhou is designated as an "important node city," it sits in the shadow of global innovation hubs like Shenzhen and Guangzhou. The challenge is twofold:

  1. The Siphon Effect: Larger cities with higher GDPs and better infrastructure naturally "suck" talent and resources away from smaller neighbors.
  2. Policy Efficacy: While Huizhou has introduced numerous talent support policies (like the "1 + 2 + N" system), it wasn't clear how these stacked up quantitatively against competitors or if they were actually moving the needle on high-tech growth.

The authors aim to identify why Huizhou’s talent ecosystem remains relatively weak despite active government intervention and what specific strategic pivots are needed to build a sustainable "talent highland."

Methods

The researchers employed a dual-track comparative approach:

  • Longitudinal Analysis: Tracking Huizhou’s internal progress over time (e.g., R&D growth from 2018–2022).
  • Horizontal Comparison: Benchmarking Huizhou against Guangzhou, Shenzhen, and Dongguan across metrics like GDP, population density, and enterprise support.

The "Secret Sauce": Unlike traditional policy reviews that rely solely on government manifestos, this study utilizes the Qizhidao platform. This platform leverages big data, cloud computing, and AI to aggregate real-world data on enterprise-benefiting policies and the actual number of businesses receiving support. This provides a more objective "ground-truth" view of policy implementation.

Datasets

The study draws from several key sources:

  • Qizhidao Platform: Used for tracking policy-supported enterprises and subsidy amounts across the four cities.
  • Hongheiku Website: For standardized urban development data (population, GDP, disposable income).
  • Government Reports: Including the "Outline Development Plan for the GBA" and Huizhou’s specific "1 + 2 + N" policy documents.
  • Statistical Yearbooks: For R&D expenditure and patent counts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Scale Disparity: The gap isn't just a few percentage points; it’s orders of magnitude. For example, the highest single subsidy in Huizhou is 10 million yuan, while Shenzhen offers up to 220 million yuan. This makes it incredibly difficult for Huizhou to compete for "top-tier" global talent.
  • The Innovation Foundation Gap: Talent doesn't exist in a vacuum. Huizhou has only 5 universities and a fraction of the R&D institutions found in Guangzhou. This lack of an "educational-scientific-talent" trinity limits the city's ability to cultivate its own talent internally.
  • Policy "Flatness": While Shenzhen and Dongguan saw explosive growth in policy-supported enterprises between 2020 and 2021, Huizhou’s growth curve remained relatively flat. This suggests its policies lack the "aggressiveness" or "expansiveness" seen in its neighbors.
  • The Invention Patent Indicator: The authors highlight invention patents as the ultimate "quality" metric for talent. Huizhou’s count (23,934) is dwarfed by Shenzhen’s (591,231)—a staggering 24.7x difference that underscores a deep-seated deficit in high-end innovative capacity.

Key Results

  • Talent Density: By the end of 2023, Huizhou had 1.3 million talents (19.4% of its population), with 50,000 classified as "high-level."
  • Enterprise Support: Huizhou supported 1,115 enterprises through talent policies, whereas Shenzhen supported 48,096.
  • Economic Lag: Huizhou’s 2023 GDP (563.9 billion yuan) ranks last among the four comparison cities, significantly trailing Shenzhen’s 3.46 trillion yuan.
  • R&D Momentum: On a positive note, Huizhou’s R&D expenditure grew at an average annual rate of nearly 20% from 2018–2022, showing a strong commitment to catching up.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while the Qizhidao big data platform is powerful, the collection and classification of policy data may not be 100% exhaustive or perfectly accurate due to variations in how cities publish results.

Future Research Directions: * Expanding the Scope: Moving beyond the GBA to compare Huizhou with other high-level talent highlands across China. * Synergy Studies: Investigating the deep synergetic relationship between specific talent policies and the development of "strategic emerging industries" (like AI and biomedicine). * Long-term Tracking: Conducting follow-up studies to see if the proposed "Four Attractions" strategy (Spatial, Industrial, Inclusive, and Ecological) actually narrows the gap in the coming decade.

Summary updated

Abstract

As an important node city in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area, the implementation effect of Huizhou's talent policies is of great significance for building a high-level talent highland in the Greater Bay Area. In recent years, Huizhou has introduced a series of talent support policies and achieved phased results, such as significant improvements in the total number of scientific and technological innovation talents, scientific research investment, and the implementation of talent policies. However, due to limitations in some factors such as population, economy, and scientific and technological innovation foundation, Huizhou City still faces many challenges in the field of talent competition, such as relatively weak talent attraction, narrow policy coverage, and facing strong competition from adjacent cities such as Guangzhou, Shenzhen, and Dongguan. Therefore, this study suggests that Huizhou should adopt the "Four Attractions" talent strategy of innovating spatial carriers, optimizing the industrial structure, implementing inclusive talent policies, and innovating the ecological system to accelerate the improvement of the implementation effectiveness of talent policies, create a characteristic scientific and technological innovation talent highland in Huizhou, and contribute to the high-quality development of Huizhou City.
BibTeX
@article{dong2025research,
  author = {Xin Dong and Yong Li and Chunming Hou and Zeng Miao},
  title = {{Research on the Evaluation of the Implementation Effectiveness of Huizhou's Talent Policies}},
  journal = {International Academic Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.56028/iajhss.2.4.33.2024},
}

Loading related content...

Figure