Research on Performance Optimization of Liquid Cooling and Composite Phase Change Material Coupling Cooling Thermal Management System for Vehicle Power Battery

Gang Wu, Feng Liu, Sijie Li, Na Luo, Zhiqiang Liu, Yuqaing LiJOURNAL 2022 · DOI

Abstract

The serpentine tube liquid cooling and composite PCM coupled cooling thermal management system is designed for 18650 cylindrical power batteries, with the maximum temperature and temperature difference of the power pack within the optimal temperature operating range as the target. The initial analysis of the battery pack at a 5C discharge rate, the influence of the single cell to cooling tube distance, the number of cooling tubes, inlet coolant temperature, the coolant flow rate, and other factors on the heat dissipation performance of the battery pack, initially determined a reasonable value for each design parameter. A control strategy is used to regulate the inlet flow rate and coolant temperature of the liquid cooling system in order to make full use of the latent heat of the composite PCM and reduce the pump’s energy consumption. The simulation results show that the maximum battery pack temperature of 309.8 K and the temperature difference of 4.6 K between individual cells with the control strategy are in the optimal temperature operating range of the power battery, and the utilization rate of the composite PCM is up to 90%.

Introduction

As electric vehicles (EVs) transition toward high-voltage DC fast charging and high-load driving scenarios—such as steep climbs or rapid acceleration—battery thermal management systems (BTMS) face unprecedented challenges. Batteries are frequently subjected to "5C" discharge rates or higher, generating massive amounts of heat in short durations. Failure to manage this heat leads to accelerated aging, reduced capacity, and potential thermal runaway.

Traditional cooling methods often present significant trade-offs. Air cooling is simple but lacks the thermal capacity for high-rate discharge. Pure Phase Change Materials (PCM) offer excellent temperature uniformity due to their latent heat storage, but their low thermal conductivity can lead to "saturation" where the material melts completely and loses effectiveness. Conversely, active liquid cooling is highly effective at heat removal but is energy-intensive and often creates large temperature gradients between the coolant inlet and outlet. This paper, published in the Journal of Renewable Materials, proposes a hybrid approach that couples the "thermal buffer" of composite phase change materials (CPCM) with the active heat removal of serpentine liquid cooling tubes.

Methodology

The study employs a numerical simulation approach, validated against experimental data from landmark studies (Lai et al., 2019 and Huang et al., 2020), to model a 24-cell battery pack utilizing 18650 cylindrical cells. The simulation incorporates detailed thermophysical properties for all battery components—including the shell, diaphragm, and electrolyte—as well as the specialized cooling materials.

System Architecture

The proposed system integrates batteries within a CPCM matrix, interspersed with serpentine liquid cooling tubes. The CPCM consists of paraffin wax enhanced with expanded graphite and polymer to boost thermal conductivity to approximately 10 W/m·K.

3D model of the hybrid battery thermal management system showing the arrangement of batteries, CPCM, and cooling tubes.

Design Optimization

Key geometric parameters were optimized through simulation. The researchers found a "sweet spot" for the distance ($d$) between the cells and the cooling tubes at $d=2$ mm. This distance ensures sufficient CPCM volume to act as a thermal buffer while allowing the liquid cooling to effectively "recharge" the material. To improve temperature uniformity, the team implemented an alternating flow scheme where adjacent tubes flow in opposite directions, mitigating the typical gradient seen in single-direction systems.

Smart Control Strategy

A core innovation of this research is the implementation of a smart control strategy via a User-Defined Function (UDF). Rather than operating the cooling pump at a constant high speed, the system monitors real-time temperatures. It allows the CPCM to absorb heat through phase change first, only ramping up coolant flow as the material nears its latent heat capacity. This approach maximizes the utilization of the passive material and reduces the overall energy consumption of the pump.

Results and Discussion

Under a rigorous 5C discharge rate simulation, the hybrid system demonstrated exceptional performance. The maximum battery temperature was maintained at 309.8 K (~36.6°C), comfortably within the ideal 20°C–40°C operating window. Furthermore, the temperature uniformity was highly controlled, with a maximum difference of only 4.6 K between cells, meeting the strict <5 K requirement for battery longevity.

The CPCM acts as a "thermal sponge," absorbing rapid heat spikes, while the liquid cooling effectively "squeezes the sponge" by removing that stored heat. Without the liquid cooling component, simulations showed the CPCM would melt completely by the 540-second mark, leading to a rapid temperature spike and a 9 K gradient across the pack. The smart control strategy achieved a 90% utilization rate of the CPCM's latent heat, proving the efficiency of the coupled approach.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that coupling CPCM with an optimized liquid cooling system and a smart control strategy provides a robust solution for high-load EV battery thermal management. By leveraging the strengths of both passive and active cooling, the system achieves high temperature uniformity and energy efficiency. Future work will involve hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) testing to validate the control strategy in physical environments and investigating the impact of contact resistance between system components during manufacturing.

Summary updated

Abstract

The serpentine tube liquid cooling and composite PCM coupled cooling thermal management system is designed for 18650 cylindrical power batteries, with the maximum temperature and temperature difference of the power pack within the optimal temperature operating range as the target. The initial analysis of the battery pack at a 5C discharge rate, the influence of the single cell to cooling tube distance, the number of cooling tubes, inlet coolant temperature, the coolant flow rate, and other factors on the heat dissipation performance of the battery pack, initially determined a reasonable value for each design parameter. A control strategy is used to regulate the inlet flow rate and coolant temperature of the liquid cooling system in order to make full use of the latent heat of the composite PCM and reduce the pump’s energy consumption. The simulation results show that the maximum battery pack temperature of 309.8 K and the temperature difference of 4.6 K between individual cells with the control strategy are in the optimal temperature operating range of the power battery, and the utilization rate of the composite PCM is up to 90%.
BibTeX
@article{wu2022research,
  author = {Gang Wu and Feng Liu and Sijie Li and Na Luo and Zhiqiang Liu and Yuqaing Li},
  title = {{Research on Performance Optimization of Liquid Cooling and Composite Phase Change Material Coupling Cooling Thermal Management System for Vehicle Power Battery}},
  journal = {JOURNAL},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.32604/jrm.2022.022276},
}
Figure