Rescuing Palindromic Universes with Improved Recombination Modelling

Metha Prathaban, Will Handley

Abstract

We explore the linearly quantised primordial power spectra associated with palindromic universes. Extending the results of Lasenby et al. [1] and Bartlett et al. [2], we improve the modelling of recombination and include higher orders in the photonic Boltzmann hierarchy. In so doing, we find that the predicted power spectra become largely consistent with observational data. The improved recombination modelling involves developing further techniques for dealing with the future conformal boundary, by integrating the associated perturbation equations both forwards and backwards in conformal time. The resulting wavevector quantisation gives a lowest allowed wavenumber $k_0 = 9.93 \times 10^{-5} \text{Mpc}^{-1}$ and linear spacing $\Delta k = 1.63 \times 10^{-4} \text{Mpc}^{-1}$, providing fits consistent with observational data equivalent in quality to the $\Lambda$CDM model.

Introduction: The Future Conformal Boundary

In modern cosmology, a universe dominated by dark energy (represented by the cosmological constant $\Lambda$) undergoes accelerated expansion. This expansion is so rapid that it creates a "future conformal boundary" (FCB)—a finite limit in conformal time $\eta$ that effectively marks the end of the causal universe. While standard $\Lambda$CDM cosmology treats this as a simple temporal limit, the "palindromic universe" hypothesis proposes that physics is symmetric around this boundary. In this view, the universe effectively "reflects" at the FCB, leading back toward a symmetric "Big Crunch."

This symmetry requirement imposes significant constraints on cosmological perturbations. Much like a particle in a quantum mechanical infinite potential well, the seeds of large-scale structure in a palindromic universe cannot take any arbitrary value; they must exist in specific, quantized wave numbers ($k$).

The Quantization Challenge

Previous attempts to model these quantized states faced a significant hurdle: the "lowest allowed wave number" ($k_0$) derived from simpler models was far too large. This resulted in a predicted Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) power spectrum that lacked power at large scales, creating a glaring discrepancy with the observations from the Planck satellite. To "rescue" the theory, it was necessary to refine the underlying physics of the early universe, specifically how we model the transition from a hot plasma to a neutral gas (recombination).

Improved Modelling: Boltzmann Hierarchy and Recombination

The researchers improved upon earlier "imperfect fluid" approximations by implementing a more rigorous treatment of the photonic Boltzmann hierarchy. Rather than truncating the description of photon movement and scattering after the first few terms, they included higher-order components. This captures the nuanced behavior of radiation as the universe becomes transparent.

Furthermore, the model moves away from the assumption of instantaneous recombination. By treating recombination as a finite process, higher-order perturbation modes are allowed to grow from zero to finite values, providing the mathematical flexibility needed to satisfy boundary conditions at the FCB with a much smaller, more realistic $k_0$.

Evolution of cosmological perturbations across the palindromic timeline.

To find the allowed quantized states, the team employed a "backwards integration" technique. They integrated the perturbation equations from the future boundary back toward the moment of recombination. Symmetry constraints were strictly enforced: all even-order modes must be symmetric and all odd-order modes antisymmetric about the FCB to ensure physical quantities remain finite at the "end" of time.

Results: Observational Consistency

The inclusion of higher-order terms and refined recombination physics successfully lowered the fundamental quantized mode. The new lowest allowed wave number is $k_0 = 9.93 \times 10^{-5} \text{Mpc}^{-1}$, with a steady linear spacing of $\Delta k = 1.63 \times 10^{-4} \text{Mpc}^{-1}$.

When compared against the Planck 2018 dataset, the results are striking. The CMB power spectrum residuals for the TT, TE, and EE correlations show that the quantized model is now largely consistent with observational data. The authors note that the quality of the fit is now equivalent to the standard $\Lambda$CDM model, effectively resolving the previous large-scale power deficit.

CMB power spectrum residuals compared to Planck 2018 data.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

By refining the treatment of the Boltzmann hierarchy and recombination, the palindromic universe model has been successfully reconciled with modern cosmological observations. The "reflecting" boundary at the FCB, once a source of theoretical tension, now provides a robust framework for a discrete set of allowed vibration modes in the early universe.

Future work will focus on performing a full Bayesian evidence calculation to determine if this quantized model is statistically preferred over $\Lambda$CDM. Additionally, the researchers aim to explore alternative integral equation methods to improve computational efficiency, allowing for even higher-order testing and a deeper investigation into low-multipole anomalies in the CMB.

Summary updated

Abstract

We explore the linearly quantised primordial power spectra associated with palindromic universes. Extending the results of Lasenby et al. [1] and Bartlett et al. [2], we improve the modelling of recombination and include higher orders in the photonic Boltzmann hierarchy. In so doing, we find that the predicted power spectra become largely consistent with observational data. The improved recombination modelling involves developing further techniques for dealing with the future conformal boundary, by integrating the associated perturbation equations both forwards and backwards in conformal time. The resulting wavevector quantisation gives a lowest allowed wavenumber ${k_0 = 9.93 \times 10^{-5} \textrm{Mpc}^{-1}}$ and linear spacing ${Δk = 1.63 \times 10^{-4} \textrm{Mpc}^{-1}}$, providing fits consistent with observational data equivalent in quality to the $Λ$CDM model.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{prathaban2022rescuing,
  author = {Metha Prathaban and Will Handley},
  title = {{Rescuing Palindromic Universes with Improved Recombination Modelling}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.105.123508},
}
Figure