Reproducible coactivation patterns of functional brain networks reveal the aberrant dynamic state transition in schizophrenia

Hang Yang, Hong Zhang, Xin Di, Shuai Wang, Chun Meng, Lin Tian, Bharat B. Biswal

TL;DR

This study introduces a robust method for analyzing dynamic brain states (Coactivation Patterns or CAPs) and reveals that individuals with schizophrenia exhibit altered temporal dynamics in their brain networks. These alterations are not only reproducible across different analytical approaches and datasets but also correlate with symptom severity, offering new insights into the neurobiological underpinnings of the disorder.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The human brain is a dynamic system, with functional connectivity between brain regions constantly changing over time. While resting-state fMRI (rs-fMRI) has been instrumental in mapping these connections, traditional methods often assume stationarity, meaning they treat connectivity as fixed. More recent approaches, like dynamic functional connectivity (dFC), aim to capture these temporal fluctuations. However, a key challenge in this field is understanding the reproducibility and generalizability of findings, especially when analyzing complex disorders like schizophrenia. Previous studies have identified altered brain network dynamics in schizophrenia, but a standardized and robust method to characterize these changes and ensure their reliability across different analyses and populations has been lacking. This paper addresses this gap by developing and validating a Coactivation Pattern (CAP) analysis framework to identify reproducible brain states and then applying it to investigate aberrant dynamics in schizophrenia.

Methods

The core of this study is the Coactivation Pattern (CAP) analysis. This data-driven method identifies recurring brain states by clustering time points with similar whole-brain coactivation patterns. Unlike some other dFC methods, CAP analysis is less reliant on mathematical assumptions and is free from the confounding influence of sliding window length.

Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • CAP Identification: Resting-state fMRI data from healthy controls (HC) were used to identify reliable CAP states. This involved:
  • Preprocessing rs-fMRI data using standard pipelines (including nuisance regression and band-pass filtering).
  • Extracting BOLD signals from 408 regions of interest (ROIs), combining cortical regions from Yeo's 7-network parcellation and subcortical regions from the AAL template.
  • Applying k-means clustering to identify volumes with similar coactivation patterns.
  • A rigorous process of selecting the optimal number of clusters (K) was undertaken, ultimately settling on 6 CAP states based on silhouette scores, elbow criteria, and prior literature.
  • State Temporal Dynamics: For each individual, four metrics were calculated to describe the dynamics of these CAP states:
  • Fraction of time: The proportion of total time spent in a particular state.
  • Persistence: The average duration a state is maintained before transitioning.
  • Counts (Number of states): How many times a state occurred.
  • Transition probability matrix: The likelihood of transitioning from one state to another.
  • Reproducibility and Generalizability: The authors systematically evaluated the robustness of their CAP analysis by:
  • Testing different preprocessing pipelines (resting-state with and without global signal regression, and a task-based pipeline).
  • Varying the number of ROIs used (100, 200, 400, 1000).
  • Examining different cluster numbers (K).
  • Applying the identified CAPs from one cohort (WuXi) to two independent open-access cohorts (COBRE and UCLA) to assess cross-cohort generalizability.
  • Schizophrenia Analysis: The validated CAP analysis framework was then applied to compare the temporal dynamics of brain states between schizophrenia patients (SZ) and age- and gender-matched HC across the three cohorts. Associations between these aberrant dynamics and clinical symptom severity (e.g., PANSS scores) were also investigated.

Datasets

The study utilized three independent cohorts:

  • WuXi cohort: This was the primary cohort used for identifying the reliable CAP states.
  • COBRE cohort: An open-access dataset used for verification and generalizability testing.
  • UCLA cohort: Another open-access dataset used for verification and generalizability testing.

Detailed demographic information for these cohorts is provided in Table 1.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Reproducible Brain States: The CAP analysis successfully identified six reliable and reproducible brain states in healthy adults, demonstrating consistency across different preprocessing pipelines, ROI resolutions, and even across independent cohorts. This is a crucial step towards establishing a standardized method for analyzing dynamic brain activity.
  • Opposite CAP Pairs: A fascinating finding is the identification of three pairs of CAP states exhibiting opposite spatial coactivation patterns. This suggests a push-pull dynamic between certain brain networks.
  • Aberrant Dynamics in Schizophrenia: Schizophrenia patients showed significant deviations in their brain's temporal dynamics. They spent less time in states associated with the fronto-parietal network (FPN) and default mode network (DMN) and more time in states involving the salience network (SN) and DMN.
  • Clinical Relevance: The aberrant temporal dynamics in schizophrenia were not just statistical differences; they were meaningfully linked to symptom severity. For instance, specific state transitions and time spent in certain states correlated with positive symptoms and overall disease severity.
  • Triple Network and Beyond: While the study confirms the importance of the "triple network" (DMN, FPN, SN) in schizophrenia, it also highlights that primary networks (visual, somatomotor) and higher-order networks (dorsal attention) also exhibit altered dynamics.

Key Results

  • Six Reliable CAP States: The study identified six distinct and reproducible coactivation patterns representing functional brain states.
  • High Spatial Similarity: CAP states showed high spatial similarity across different preprocessing pipelines and ROI numbers, indicating robustness.
  • Generalizability: CAPs identified in the WuXi cohort were successfully applied to the COBRE and UCLA cohorts, demonstrating good generalizability.
  • Schizophrenia Group Differences: Significant differences in the "fraction of time," "persistence," and "counts" of CAP states were observed between SZ patients and HC. For example, SZ patients spent less time in states involving FPN/DMN and more time in SN/DMN states.
  • Transition Probability Alterations: SZ patients showed altered transition probabilities between states, with some transitions being lower and others higher compared to HC.
  • Symptom Correlation: Negative correlations were found between certain CAP metrics (e.g., fraction of time in State 6, counts in State 6) and positive PANSS scores, suggesting a link between aberrant dynamics and symptom severity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cluster Number Selection: The authors acknowledge that determining the optimal number of clusters (K) for CAP analysis remains a challenge, and the choice of K=6 was based on a combination of statistical criteria and qualitative assessment, aligning with prior studies. Future work could explore more objective methods for cluster number selection.
  • Limited Temporal Information: For smaller cohorts (COBRE and UCLA), increasing the cluster number led to fewer volumes per state, potentially limiting temporal information.
  • Cross-Cohort Repeatability: While generalizability was demonstrated, the spatial and temporal repeatability across cohorts was noted as relatively weaker compared to variations within a single cohort. Further refinement of methods might improve this.
  • Intervention Potential: The finding that state transitions might alleviate disease severity suggests potential avenues for developing targeted interventions for schizophrenia. Future research could explore how to modulate these state transitions.
  • Broader Network Dysfunction: The study's findings of widespread aberrant dynamics across multiple networks, not just the triple network, warrant further investigation into the interconnectedness of these alterations in schizophrenia.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract It is well documented that massive dynamic information is contained in the resting-state fMRI. Recent studies have identified recurring states dominated by similar coactivation patterns (CAP) and revealed their temporal dynamics. However, the reproducibility and generalizability of the CAP analysis is unclear. To address this question, the effects of methodological pipelines on CAP are comprehensively evaluated in this study, including preprocessing, network construction, cluster number and three independent cohorts. The CAP state dynamics are characterized by fraction of time, persistence, counts, and transition probability. Results demonstrate six reliable CAP states and their dynamic characteristics are also reproducible. The state transition probability is found to be positively associated with the spatial similarity. Furthermore, the aberrant CAP in schizophrenia has been investigated by using the reproducible method on three cohorts. Schizophrenia patients spend less time in CAP states that involve the fronto-parietal network, but more time in CAP states that involve the default mode and salience network. The aberrant dynamic characteristics of CAP are correlated with the symptom severity. These results reveal the reproducibility and generalizability of the CAP analysis, which can provide novel insights into the neuropathological mechanism associated with aberrant brain network dynamics of schizophrenia. Highlights Three coactivation patterns (CAPs) pairs with opposite coactivation profiles were identified, and the between-state transition probability was positively correlated with their spatial similarity. Good spatial and temporal reproducibility and generalizability of CAPs were achieved under varied analytic methods and independent cohorts. Schizophrenia patients showed altered temporal dynamics not only within the triple-network but also other primary and higher-order networks.
BibTeX
@article{yang2021reproducible,
  author = {Hang Yang and Hong Zhang and Xin Di and Shuai Wang and Chun Meng and Lin Tian and Bharat B. Biswal},
  title = {{Reproducible coactivation patterns of functional brain networks reveal the aberrant dynamic state transition in schizophrenia}},
  journal = {NeuroImage},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.neuroimage.2021.118193},
}
Figure