REMATCH: Robust and Efficient Matching of Local Knowledge Graphs to Improve Structural and Semantic Similarity

Zoher Kachwala, Jisun An, Haewoon Kwak, Filippo Menczer

TL;DR

This paper introduces rematch, a novel and efficient metric for comparing Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) graphs, which are structured representations of text meaning. rematch significantly outperforms existing metrics in both semantic similarity and computational efficiency, while also introducing RARE, a new benchmark for evaluating structural similarity in AMR.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Knowledge graphs (KGs), like those generated by the Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) framework, are crucial for tasks like question answering and fact-checking. Evaluating the quality of these KGs often involves comparing them to each other (structural similarity) and to the original text (semantic similarity). However, existing AMR similarity metrics are computationally inefficient, especially for large KGs, and struggle to accurately capture semantic nuances. Furthermore, there's a lack of a standardized benchmark for systematically evaluating the structural similarity of AMR graphs. This paper aims to address these limitations by proposing a new, efficient metric (rematch) and a new evaluation benchmark (RARE).

Methods

The core of this paper is the introduction of rematch, a novel AMR similarity metric. rematch operates in two steps:

  1. Motif Generation: It extracts three types of "motifs" from AMR graphs:
  2. Attribute Motifs: Pairs of attributes and their associated constants (e.g., negation for a verb).
  3. Instance Motifs: Core semantic concepts, potentially combined with their attribute motifs.
  4. Relation Motifs: Combinations of source instance motifs, relation labels, and target instance motifs. These motifs capture meaning at different semantic levels: specific facts, main concepts, and relationships.

  5. Jaccard Similarity: The similarity between two AMRs is calculated using the Jaccard similarity of their respective sets of motifs. This approach avoids the computationally expensive node alignment required by many existing metrics.

Additionally, the paper introduces RARE (Randomized AMRs with Rewired Edges), a new benchmark for structural similarity. RARE is generated by systematically rewiring edges in existing AMR graphs while preserving node degrees. This allows for controlled evaluation of how well similarity metrics capture structural changes.

Datasets

  • AMR Annotation 3.0: This dataset was used to generate the RARE benchmark and for evaluating the efficiency of the proposed metric.
  • STS-B (Semantic Textual Similarity Benchmark): Used to evaluate semantic consistency.
  • SICK-R (Sentences Involving Compositional Knowledge): Also used to evaluate semantic consistency.
  • BAMBOO (Benchmark for AMR Metrics Based on Overt Objectives): Used to evaluate hybrid consistency, which assesses how well metrics handle semantic similarity when AMR structures are modified.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Motifs as a Bridge: The paper's key insight is that by breaking down AMR graphs into structured "motifs" (attribute, instance, relation), they can capture semantic and structural information more effectively and efficiently than traditional node-alignment approaches.
  • Efficiency Through Abstraction: rematch's motif-based approach bypasses the need for complex graph isomorphism or subgraph isomorphism tests, leading to significant speedups.
  • The Need for Structural Evaluation: The introduction of RARE highlights the critical gap in evaluating how well AMR metrics handle structural variations, which is crucial for understanding the robustness of KG representations.
  • Semantic Nuance in Negation: The paper demonstrates that rematch's motif structure, particularly the handling of attribute motifs like polarity, allows it to better capture subtle semantic differences, such as negation.

Key Results

  • Semantic Similarity: rematch ranks first on the STS-B and SICK-R benchmarks, outperforming other AMR metrics by 1-5 percentage points.
  • Structural Similarity: On the newly introduced RARE benchmark, rematch ranks second, closely following smatch.
  • Efficiency: rematch is approximately five times faster than the next most efficient metric (sembleu), with a linear time complexity compared to the quadratic complexity of node-alignment methods like smatch and s2match.
  • Hybrid Consistency: rematch performs well on the BAMBOO benchmark, achieving the best results in three out of twelve tests and performing slightly behind s2match on average.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Word-Level Similarity: rematch currently struggles to capture similarity between sentences with different wordings but equivalent meanings, as it doesn't directly compare word embeddings. Future work could explore integrating word embeddings or using metrics like AMRSim that leverage self-supervised learning.
  • Short-Text Focus: The current motif approach is based on single edges (paths of length one), which might not fully capture the complex semantics of AMRs derived from longer documents.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest exploring the full potential of AMRs for Natural Language Inference (NLI) and developing methods that perform NLI solely through AMR matching. They also propose further research into improving AMR matching to benefit downstream applications like semantic textual similarity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Knowledge graphs play a pivotal role in various applications, such as question-answering and fact-checking. Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) represents text as knowledge graphs. Evaluating the quality of these graphs involves matching them structurally to each other and semantically to the source text. Existing AMR metrics are inefficient and struggle to capture semantic similarity. We also lack a systematic evaluation benchmark for assessing structural similarity between AMR graphs. To overcome these limitations, we introduce a novel AMR similarity metric, rematch, alongside a new evaluation for structural similarity called RARE. Among state-of-the-art metrics, rematch ranks second in structural similarity; and first in semantic similarity by 1--5 percentage points on the STS-B and SICK-R benchmarks. Rematch is also five times faster than the next most efficient metric.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kachwala2024rematch,
  author = {Zoher Kachwala and Jisun An and Haewoon Kwak and Filippo Menczer},
  title = {{REMATCH: Robust and Efficient Matching of Local Knowledge Graphs to Improve Structural and Semantic Similarity}},
  booktitle = {Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.18653/v1/2024.findings-naacl.64},
}
Figure