Reliability Improved Cooperative Communication over Wireless Sensor Networks

Zhuangbin Chen, Ming Ma, Xiao Liu, Anfeng Liu, Ming Zhao

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Reliability Improved Cooperative Communication" (RICC) scheme for Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs). RICC dynamically adjusts transmission power to leverage residual energy in less-used network areas, significantly boosting data reliability and energy efficiency without sacrificing network lifetime.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) are crucial for data collection in various applications, but they face significant challenges:

  • Lossy Wireless Channels: Data packets are prone to errors and loss, leading to high delays and retransmissions.
  • Energy Constraints: Sensor nodes have limited power, making energy-efficient communication paramount.
  • Network Lifetime: Traditional methods to improve reliability (like increasing transmission power) often deplete node energy faster, shortening the network's operational lifespan.
  • Unbalanced Energy Consumption: Nodes closer to the sink (hotspot areas) consume more energy, leading to an "energy hole" phenomenon where nodes further away have substantial residual energy.

The paper aims to bridge the gap between achieving high data reliability and ensuring a long network lifetime in WSNs, particularly in the context of cooperative communication and random network coding.

Methods

The core of the proposed RICC scheme lies in its adaptive transmission power strategy:

  • Cooperative Communication: Sensors work together to transmit data, leveraging redundancy and shared resources. This is built upon a foundation of random network coding, where data packets are encoded with random vectors.
  • Wireless Software-Defined Networks (WSDNs): The paper assumes a WSDN environment where sensor software can be updated, enabling dynamic adaptation of communication strategies.
  • Adaptive Transmission Power: This is the key innovation.
  • Non-Hotspot Areas: Nodes in areas with significant residual energy (far from the sink) use higher transmission power. This increases the probability of successful data transmission, thereby improving reliability.
  • Hotspot Areas: Nodes closer to the sink use relatively lower transmission power, similar to existing schemes. This conserves their limited energy, helping to maintain the overall network lifetime.
  • Data Transmission Model: The paper models data transmission in three stages: Source Cluster routing, Transitional Cluster routing, and Destination Cluster routing, consistent with existing network coding-based cooperative communication schemes.
  • Reliability and Energy Models: Mathematical models are developed to analyze packet loss probability, signal-to-noise ratio, and energy consumption per bit for both transmission and reception.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is based on simulations using the Omnet++ simulator.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leveraging Residual Energy: The most significant insight is the strategic use of abundant residual energy in non-hotspot areas to boost reliability. Instead of letting this energy go to waste, RICC repurposes it for higher transmission power.
  • Balancing Act: RICC demonstrates that it's possible to achieve both high reliability and a long network lifetime simultaneously, a trade-off that has historically been difficult to manage.
  • Dynamic Power is Key: The adaptive nature of RICC, adjusting power based on node location and residual energy, is crucial for its success. A one-size-fits-all power strategy is suboptimal.
  • Energy Hole Mitigation: By increasing transmission power in areas with more energy, RICC indirectly helps to balance energy consumption across the network, mitigating the "energy hole" problem.

Key Results

The simulation results highlight the effectiveness of RICC:

  • Improved Reliability: RICC reduces the end-to-end Message Fail Delivering Ratio (MFR) by 59.4%–62.8% compared to existing schemes (specifically, Network Coding-based Cooperative Communications - NCCC) under the same network lifetime.
  • Enhanced Energy Utilization: The average enhanced energy utilization ratio of the network is improved by 59.4% to 62.8%.
  • Balanced Energy Consumption: Figures show that RICC leads to a more balanced energy distribution across nodes, with nodes further from the sink consuming more energy, thus creating a more uniform energy usage pattern.
  • Weighted End-to-End MFR Reduction: The weighted end-to-end MFR is reduced by at least 50%, indicating a significant improvement in overall network reliability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper acknowledges that while RICC improves energy utilization, it's not perfectly balanced. The use of a more even energy utilization strategy for better network performance is left for future work.
  • The study focuses on simulation results, and real-world deployment challenges are not explicitly addressed.
  • Future Work:
    • Investigate techniques to achieve more even energy utilization across the network.
  • Explore new techniques to improve communication reliability and lifetime, especially in the context of energy harvesting sensor networks.
  • Apply these findings to practical applications, particularly those involving energy harvesting.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the development of smart devices and connection technologies, Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) are becoming increasingly intelligent. New or special functions can be obtained by receiving new versions of program codes to upgrade their software systems, forming the so-called smart Internet of Things (IoT). Due to the lossy property of wireless channels, data collection in WSNs still suffers from a long delay, high energy consumption, and many retransmissions. Thanks to wireless software-defined networks (WSDNs), software in sensors can now be updated to help them transmit data cooperatively, thereby achieving more reliable communication. In this paper, a Reliability Improved Cooperative Communication (RICC) data collection scheme is proposed to improve the reliability of random-network-coding-based cooperative communications in multi-hop relay WSNs without reducing the network lifetime. In WSNs, sensors in different positions can have different numbers of packets to handle, resulting in the unbalanced energy consumption of the network. In particular, nodes in non-hotspot areas have up to 90% of their original energy remaining when the network dies. To efficiently use the residual energy, in RICC, high data transmission power is adopted in non-hotspot areas to achieve a higher reliability at the cost of large energy consumption, and relatively low transmission power is adopted in hotspot areas to maintain the long network lifetime. Therefore, high reliability and a long network lifetime can be obtained simultaneously. The simulation results show that compared with other scheme, RICC can reduce the end-to-end Message Fail delivering Ratio (MFR) by 59.4%–62.8% under the same lifetime with a more balanced energy utilization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2017reliability,
  author = {Zhuangbin Chen and Ming Ma and Xiao Liu and Anfeng Liu and Ming Zhao},
  title = {{Reliability Improved Cooperative Communication over Wireless Sensor Networks}},
  booktitle = {Symmetry},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=xsgShw0Nun},
}
Figure