Reinforcement Learning with Logarithmic Regret and Policy Switches

Grigoris Velegkas, Zhuoran Yang, Amin Karbasi

Introduction

This paper bridges the gap between theoretical reinforcement learning (RL) and practical efficiency by demonstrating that RL algorithms can achieve logarithmic regret even when utilizing general function approximation. By assuming a small "gap" exists between the best and second-best actions in any given state, the authors show that agents can learn near-optimal behavior with exponentially fewer errors than worst-case theory suggests. Crucially, they achieve this while rarely needing to update their underlying policy, drastically reducing computational and operational overhead.

The Challenge: Pessimistic Bounds and High Switching Costs

In Reinforcement Learning, "regret" measures the difference between the reward an agent actually accumulates and what it could have obtained by following an optimal strategy. Most existing theoretical frameworks focus on "worst-case" scenarios, where regret grows at a rate of $O(\sqrt{T})$ (where $T$ is the number of interactions). While mathematically robust, this bound is often too pessimistic for real-world environments that are not actively adversarial.

Furthermore, many theoretical RL algorithms require updating the agent's policy after every single episode. In practical applications—such as medical trials, robotics, or personalized recommendations—changing a policy is expensive, risky, or computationally taxing. The authors tackle two primary questions:

  1. Can we achieve much lower (logarithmic) regret by focusing on specific, "benign" problem instances?
  2. Can we accomplish this while keeping the "switching cost" (the frequency of policy updates) exceptionally low?

Methodology

The authors present a unified framework applicable to both model-free (learning the value of actions directly) and model-based (learning the environment's transition dynamics) RL.

General Function Approximation

Instead of assuming a simple, finite state space (tabular RL), the framework accommodates complex function classes, such as neural networks or kernels. The complexity of these classes is measured using the Eluder Dimension, allowing the theory to scale to sophisticated modern RL setups.

Online Sub-sampling for Low Adaptivity

To minimize switching costs, the algorithm avoids updating its policy after every episode. Instead, it employs a "sensitivity" check. The agent only adds new data to its training set and recomputes its policy if a new interaction provides significant, novel information that the current model hasn't yet captured.

The Peeling Technique

To mathematically prove their bounds, the authors utilize a "peeling technique." This involves slicing the possible sub-optimality gaps into intervals, allowing them to separately bound the number of times an agent chooses a "slightly bad" action versus a "very bad" action.

Key Insights and Results

  • The Power of the "Gap": The core insight is that if there is a clear distinction (a "gap") between the best and second-best actions, the agent eventually stops making mistakes entirely. This transforms the regret from a square-root curve into a much flatter logarithmic curve. The authors prove that for both model-free and model-based settings, the regret is bounded by $O(\text{poly}(d_{\mathcal{F}}, H, \log T) / \text{gap}_{\min})$.
  • Lazy is Better: By being "lazy" and only updating the policy when data is sufficiently novel, the authors achieve an adaptivity complexity (number of policy switches) bounded by $O(\text{poly}(d_{\mathcal{F}}, H) \log^2 T)$. In a million episodes, the agent might only change its strategy a handful of times.
  • Theoretical Lower Bounds: The authors complement their upper bounds by proving that even in the simplest tabular settings, it is impossible to achieve regret lower than $O(\log T)$. This confirms that their algorithm is essentially as efficient as theoretically possible.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the theoretical guarantees are strong, they rely on a few key assumptions. First, the results depend on $\text{gap}_{\min} > 0$. If an environment features actions that are infinitely close in value but not identical, the logarithmic guarantee does not hold in the same way.

Second, there is a computational bottleneck. While the algorithm is highly sample efficient, the computational cost involves solving a least-squares optimization over general function classes. For highly complex models like deep neural networks, this optimization can be intractable to solve perfectly in practice. Finally, in the model-based setting, the authors assume the reward function is known or easily estimated. Future work could explore unknown, complex reward structures in tandem with general transition dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we study the problem of regret minimization for episodic Reinforcement Learning (RL) both in the model-free and the model-based setting. We focus on learning with general function classes and general model classes, and we derive results that scale with the eluder dimension of these classes. In contrast to the existing body of work that mainly establishes instance-independent regret guarantees, we focus on the instance-dependent setting and show that the regret scales logarithmically with the horizon $T$, provided that there is a gap between the best and the second best action in every state. In addition, we show that such a logarithmic regret bound is realizable by algorithms with $O(\log T)$ switching cost (also known as adaptivity complexity). In other words, these algorithms rarely switch their policy during the course of their execution. Finally, we complement our results with lower bounds which show that even in the tabular setting, we cannot hope for regret guarantees lower than $O(\log T)$.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{velegkas2022reinforcement,
  author = {Grigoris Velegkas and Zhuoran Yang and Amin Karbasi},
  title = {{Reinforcement Learning with Logarithmic Regret and Policy Switches}},
  booktitle = {Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=g2cM5983pw},
}
Figure