Regularized Non-Negative Spectral Embedding for Clustering

Yifei Wang, Rui Liu, Yong Chen, Hui Zhang, Zhiwen Ye

TL;DR

This paper introduces Regularized Non-negative Spectral Embedding (RNSE), an end-to-end, single-stage clustering method that learns the data's similarity matrix and performs embedding simultaneously. By integrating non-negativity constraints and global priors, RNSE overcomes the sub-optimality issues of traditional multi-stage spectral clustering, achieving superior performance on various datasets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional spectral clustering methods, while powerful for discovering complex cluster structures, often suffer from sub-optimal performance due to their multi-stage nature. These stages, including similarity matrix construction, dimensionality reduction (embedding), and final clustering (e.g., K-Means), can lead to a mismatch between intermediate steps. The paper aims to address this by proposing a unified, end-to-end framework that learns the similarity matrix and performs the embedding in a single, integrated process, directly mapping data points to cluster labels.

Methods

The core of the proposed method, RNSE, is an optimization problem that jointly learns the similarity matrix ($S$) and the embedding matrix ($P$). It extends spectral clustering by:

  • Adaptive Similarity Matrix Learning: Instead of pre-defining the similarity matrix (e.g., via k-nearest neighbors), RNSE learns it directly from the data in a self-adaptive manner.
  • End-to-End Single-Stage Learning: The entire process, from data to clustering labels, is performed in one go, avoiding the potential mismatches of multi-stage approaches.
  • Non-Negative Constraints: The embedding matrix $P$ is constrained to be non-negative, which is crucial for directly interpreting its columns as cluster indicators.
  • Global Priors/Regularization: RNSE incorporates two key regularizers:
  • Doubly Stochastic Constraint: The similarity matrix $S$ is regularized to be doubly stochastic, a known technique to improve spectral clustering performance.
  • Non-Negative Low-Rank Constraint: This constraint on $P$ helps capture the underlying clustering structure.
  • Optimization Strategy: The complex optimization problem is tackled using successive alternating projection and strategic multiplicative updates, breaking it down into two subproblems: optimizing $S$ while keeping $P$ fixed, and optimizing $P$ while keeping $S$ fixed.

Datasets

The paper evaluates RNSE on both synthetic and real-world datasets:

  • Synthetic Datasets:
    • A block-diagonal synthetic dataset designed to test the ability to recover clear cluster structures under varying noise levels.
  • A two-moon dataset to evaluate performance on non-convex cluster shapes.
  • Real-world Datasets: Eight publicly available datasets are used:
  • diabetes
    • arcene
    • mnist (top 100 samples per digit)
    • alpha_digit
    • yeast_uni
    • PCMAC
    • waveform-21
    • gisette

No new benchmarks were introduced; standard datasets were used for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unifying Similarity Learning and Embedding: The most significant insight is that learning the similarity matrix and performing spectral embedding can be effectively integrated into a single optimization problem. This end-to-end approach avoids the limitations of sequential, multi-stage methods.
  • Power of Non-Negativity in Embedding: Constraining the embedding matrix $P$ to be non-negative allows its columns to directly represent cluster indicators, simplifying the final clustering step and potentially leading to more interpretable results.
  • Robustness to Noise: RNSE demonstrates robustness to noise in synthetic data, maintaining its ability to identify underlying cluster structures even when the original graph representation becomes blurred.
  • Handling Complex Manifolds: The method shows promise in handling non-convex cluster shapes (like the two-moon dataset) better than traditional K-Means, highlighting its ability to capture more intricate data structures.

Key Results

  • Superior Performance: RNSE consistently achieved the best or competitive results in terms of Accuracy (ACC) and Purity across all tested real-world datasets, outperforming methods like K-Means, PCA, LRR, NMF, NCuts, SDS, CAN, and CLR.
  • Fast Convergence: The optimization algorithm for RNSE converges quickly, typically within 20 iterations, making it computationally efficient.
  • Computational Efficiency: The overall complexity of RNSE is $O(MN^2 + CN^2)$, which is noted as being faster than many competitors, especially for larger datasets where $M, C \ll N$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scalability for Extremely Large Datasets: While RNSE is faster than many competitors, the authors acknowledge that for extremely large datasets (e.g., millions of samples), its efficiency might decrease, posing a challenge for future work.
  • Parameter Tuning: Although RNSE performs well with parameters $\alpha=1$ and $\beta=1$, empirical tuning is still required for optimal performance on different datasets.
  • Further Exploration of Priors: The paper suggests that exploring other global priors or regularization techniques could further enhance RNSE's capabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spectral Clustering is a popular technique to split data points into groups, especially for complex datasets. The algorithms in the Spectral Clustering family typically consist of multiple separate stages (such as similarity matrix construction, low-dimensional embedding, and K-Means clustering as post-processing), which may lead to sub-optimal results because of the possible mismatch between different stages. In this paper, we propose an end-to-end single-stage learning method to clustering called Regularized Non-negative Spectral Embedding (RNSE) which extends Spectral Clustering with the adaptive learning of similarity matrix and meanwhile utilizes non-negative constraints to facilitate one-step clustering (directly from data points to clustering labels). Two well-founded methods, successive alternating projection and strategic multiplicative update, are employed to work out the quite challenging optimization problems in RNSE. Extensive experiments on both synthetic and real-world datasets demonstrate RNSE's superior clustering performance to some state-of-the-art competitors.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2019regularized,
  author = {Yifei Wang and Rui Liu and Yong Chen and Hui Zhang and Zhiwen Ye},
  title = {{Regularized Non-Negative Spectral Embedding for Clustering}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1911.00179},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1911.00179},
}
Figure