Regularity of rational vertex operator algebras

Chongying Dong, Haisheng Li, Geoffrey Mason

Abstract

A regular vertex operator algebra (VOA) is defined as a VOA where any weak module—regardless of grading—is a direct sum of ordinary irreducible modules. This paper establishes several sufficient conditions under which a rational vertex operator algebra is regular. We prove the regularity of the moonshine module vertex operator algebra $V^{\natural}$, the VOAs $L(l,0)$ associated with integrable representations of affine algebras of level $l$, the VOAs $L(c_{p,q},0)$ associated with the Virasoro algebra discrete series, and the VOAs $V_L$ associated with positive definite even lattices $L$. Furthermore, our results for $L(l,0)$ imply that any restricted integrable module of level $l$ for the corresponding affine Lie algebra is a direct sum of irreducible highest weight integrable modules. For cases where $L$ is not positive definite, we establish the complete reducibility of any weak module.

Introduction

Vertex Operator Algebras (VOAs) serve as the rigorous mathematical foundation for 2D Conformal Field Theory (CFT) and string theory. A central pursuit in the study of VOAs is the classification and understanding of their "modules"—the vector spaces upon which the VOA acts. Historically, researchers have distinguished between different classes of VOAs based on the behavior of these modules.

Two of the most critical properties are rationality and regularity. A VOA is considered rational if its "admissible" modules (those possessing a $\mathbb{Z}_+$-grading) are completely reducible into a direct sum of simple, irreducible pieces. However, there exists a broader, more complex class of "weak modules" that lack this inherent grading. A VOA is defined as regular if every weak module is completely reducible. Prior to this work, it was unclear whether regularity was a significantly rarer property than rationality. This paper bridges that gap by demonstrating that many of the most significant rational VOAs in mathematics are, in fact, regular.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The authors employ a purely algebraic approach to develop a framework of sufficient conditions that allow a VOA to be "upgraded" from rational to regular.

Sufficient Conditions for Regularity

The core technical contribution is Proposition 3.5, which proves that a rational VOA is regular if every non-zero weak module contains at least one simple ordinary submodule. This effectively reduces a global problem—the behavior of all possible weak modules—to a local existence proof. If one can find a single irreducible ordinary submodule within a weak module, the structure of the VOA ensures the entire module behaves predictably.

Subalgebra Analysis

The paper also demonstrates that regularity is "contagious." Specifically, if a VOA contains a regular subalgebra that shares the same Virasoro element, the larger VOA inherits that regularity. This allows the authors to extend proofs from simpler structures to more complex ones.

Case-Specific Proofs

For specific families of VOAs, the authors utilize specialized tools:

  • Affine Lie Algebras ($L(l, 0)$): The authors use singular vectors in Verma modules and the properties of integrable representations to identify the required simple submodules.
  • Lattice VOAs ($V_L$): The authors define a "vacuum space" within weak modules. By proving this space is never empty (Lemma 3.15), they provide the necessary anchor to establish complete reducibility.

Key Results

The paper successfully proves the regularity of four major classes of VOAs that are foundational to modern mathematical physics:

  1. The Moonshine Module ($V^\natural$): The VOA whose automorphism group is the Monster group, central to the "Monstrous Moonshine" conjectures.
  2. Affine Lie Algebra VOAs ($L(l, 0)$): Associated with integrable representations at positive integer levels. This result has a direct impact on Lie theory, implying that any restricted integrable module of level $l$ is a direct sum of irreducible highest weight modules.
  3. Virasoro Discrete Series ($L(c_{p,q}, 0)$): These represent the building blocks of minimal models in physics.
  4. Lattice VOAs ($V_L$): Associated with positive definite even lattices.

Additionally, the paper addresses even lattices $L$ that are not positive definite. While $V_L$ in these cases is a vertex algebra rather than a VOA in the strictest sense, the authors establish that their weak modules still possess the property of complete reducibility.

Discussion and the Regularity Conjecture

The most profound insight of this work is the suggestion that regularity may not be a separate, stronger category, but rather a natural consequence of rationality. The authors formalize this as the Regularity Conjecture: Any rational vertex operator algebra is regular.

While this paper proves regularity on a case-by-case basis for known families, the conjecture remains a major guiding hypothesis in the field. The results presented here have since been used to better understand fusion rules and the construction of tensor products of modules, providing a more robust framework for the representation theory of conformal field theories.

Summary updated

Abstract

A regular vertex operator algebra is a vertex operator algebra such that any weak module (without grading) is a direct sum of ordinary irreducible modules. In this paper we give several sufficient conditions under which a rational vertex operator algebra is regular. We prove that the moonshine module vertex operator algebra $V^{\natural},$ the vertex operator algebras $L(l,0)$ associated with the integrable representations of affine algebras of level $l,$ the vertex operator algebras $L(c_{p,q},0)$ associated with irreducible highest weight representations for the discrete series of the Virasoro algebra and the vertex operator algebras $V_L$ associated with positive definite even lattices $L$ are regular. Our result for $L(l,0)$ implies that any restricted integrable module of level $l$ for the corresponding affine Lie algebra is a direct sum of irreducible highest weight integrable modules. The space $V_L$ in general is a vertex algebra if $L$ is not positive definite. In this case we establish the complete reducibility of any weak module.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dong1997regularity,
  author = {Chongying Dong and Haisheng Li and Geoffrey Mason},
  title = {{Regularity of rational vertex operator algebras}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {1997},
  doi = {10.1006/aima.1997.1681},
}
Figure