Abstract
As the carbon intensity of global energy grids decreases, the environmental impact of computing is shifting from operational power consumption to the "embodied carbon" generated during manufacturing. REFRESH (Revisiting Expanding FPGA Real-estate for Environmentally Sustainable Heterogeneous-Systems) proposes a circular economy approach for high-performance reconfigurable logic. By recycling retired FPGA dies into new 2.5D chiplet architectures, the REFRESH framework aims to extend the functional life of silicon, amortizing its manufacturing footprint over a longer period and offering a more sustainable alternative to the frequent replacement cycles typical of modern data centers.
Introduction: The Shift to Embodied Carbon
Historically, the "greenness" of a computing system was measured primarily by its energy efficiency. However, as renewable energy becomes a larger part of the power mix, the industry is reaching a critical tipping point. In leading hyperscale data centers, embodied carbon—the greenhouse gases emitted during mining, manufacturing, and transport—can now account for up to 82% of a system's total carbon footprint.
Field-Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) are particularly susceptible to this sustainability challenge. Despite having long functional lifespans, FPGAs in data centers are often retired every two years to keep pace with performance demands. This rapid turnover results in a massive waste of the environmental "investment" required to manufacture the silicon. The REFRESH project addresses this by reimagining retired dies not as waste, but as the building blocks for new, large-scale heterogeneous systems.
The REFRESH Architecture
The core of the REFRESH concept is the integration of recently retired FPGA dies onto an inexpensive interposer using 2.5D packaging. This allows multiple older, smaller dies to function as a single, larger, and more capable fabric.
Technical Innovations
To make this recycling viable, the authors introduce several architectural innovations:
- Super Duper Long Lines (SDLLs): Standard multi-die FPGAs use Super Long Lines (SLLs) for inter-die communication. However, because REFRESH utilizes dies that were previously packaged as standalone chips, it must leverage existing I/O pins originally intended for package-level connections. SDLLs are designed to manage these constraints, providing the necessary connectivity across the interposer.
- Sustainability Modeling: The framework utilizes "indifference" and "break-even" calculations. These metrics determine the point at which a brand-new, more power-efficient device finally offsets its high manufacturing carbon cost compared to a recycled, less efficient alternative.
- Design Automation: The paper emphasizes the need for specialized CAD tools capable of partitioning designs across heterogeneous, recycled chiplet boundaries while navigating restricted interconnect bandwidth and fixed I/O patterns.
Sustainability Analysis and Results
The researchers evaluated the REFRESH concept using Lifecycle Assessment (LCA) data and hardware benchmarks, comparing a new 7nm Versal VM1802 FPGA against a REFRESH FPGA composed of four 16nm Ultrascale+ (ZCU102) dies.
The Indifference Point
A key finding is that the "indifference point"—the moment a new device becomes more environmentally friendly than a recycled one—is highly dependent on the energy grid. In a standard grid environment (e.g., California), it takes roughly one year of operation for the high-efficiency VM1802 to "pay off" its manufacturing carbon. However, when the operational power is derived from 90% renewable sources, the REFRESH FPGA remains the more sustainable choice for two to three years. As the grid becomes greener, the argument for using recycled hardware grows stronger.
Diminishing Returns of Scaling
The study also highlights the diminishing returns of traditional silicon scaling. Moving from 28nm (Virtex-7) to 7nm (Versal) for a 32-bit floating-point matrix multiplication benchmark yielded only a 50% improvement in latency, while static power consumption increased significantly (from 0.8W to nearly 10W). This suggests that the performance leaps of new silicon generations may not always justify the associated environmental costs.
Challenges and Future Work
While the REFRESH model presents a compelling path toward sustainable computing, several hurdles remain:
- Die Aging and Reliability: Further research is required to understand the failure rates and performance degradation of "second-life" silicon.
- Interconnect Constraints: Creating high-bandwidth topologies on an interposer using fixed I/O patterns from retired dies is a significant architectural challenge.
- Fault Tolerance: Systems must be designed to be resilient, ensuring that a defect in one recycled die does not compromise the entire 2.5D assembly.
Conclusion
REFRESH FPGAs challenge the industry's "newer is always better" mantra. By prioritizing the reduction of embodied carbon through silicon reuse, this research provides a blueprint for a more sustainable, circular approach to high-performance hardware design. As the environmental cost of manufacturing continues to outweigh operational energy savings, recycling silicon may become a technical and ecological necessity.
Summary updated