Refining conformational ensembles of flexible proteins against small-angle x-ray scattering data

Francesco Pesce, Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new computational framework, iBME, to better model the flexibility of proteins using small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) data. By self-consistently refining protein conformations and key SAXS parameters related to hydration, the method provides more robust and accurate structural ensembles for intrinsically disordered and flexible proteins.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Characterizing the dynamic and heterogeneous nature of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and flexible regions within larger proteins is crucial for understanding their biological function. While small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) is a powerful experimental technique for probing protein solutions, interpreting SAXS data for flexible systems is challenging. Standard computational approaches often struggle with accurately modeling the contribution of the protein's hydration layer and displaced solvent to the scattering signal. Furthermore, fitting parameters related to these effects can easily lead to overfitting, especially when dealing with large conformational ensembles. This paper addresses the need for a more robust method to simultaneously refine both the conformational ensemble and the parameters describing the protein's interaction with its solvent environment.

Methods

The core of the paper is the development of an iterative Bayesian/Maximum-Entropy (iBME) approach. This method builds upon existing Bayesian/Maximum-Entropy (BME) reweighting techniques, which adjust the probabilities of different protein conformations to match experimental data. The novelty of iBME lies in its ability to iteratively refine not only the conformational weights but also two key parameters that influence SAXS calculations:

  • Effective atomic radius ($r_0$): This parameter influences the overall excluded volume of the protein.
  • Hydration layer contrast ($\delta\rho$): This parameter describes the difference in scattering density between the protein's hydration layer and bulk solvent.

The iBME scheme works by:

  1. Calculating SAXS profiles for an initial ensemble of protein conformations using a range of $r_0$ and $\delta\rho$ values.
  2. Using a weighted least-squares fit to estimate a scale factor and constant background from the experimental SAXS data.
  3. Applying BME reweighting to the ensemble using the calculated SAXS profiles, incorporating the estimated scale factor and background.
  4. Repeating steps 2 and 3 iteratively until convergence is reached, effectively finding the best-fit ensemble and parameters.

This iterative process allows for a self-consistent determination of both the conformational ensemble and the solvent-related parameters, mitigating the risk of overfitting.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available SAXS experimental data for the following proteins:

  • Histatin 5 (Hst5)
  • Sic1
  • Tau (full-length)
  • TIA-1 (without its flexible low-complexity domain)
  • $\alpha$-Synuclein (for additional robustness testing)

Conformational ensembles were generated using Flexible-meccano, and for $\alpha$-Synuclein, previously generated molecular dynamics simulations were also used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The crucial role of solvent parameters: The study highlights that the choice of parameters describing the protein's hydration layer ($\delta\rho$) and excluded volume ($r_0$) significantly impacts the resulting conformational ensembles, even when the overall fit to SAXS data is good.
  • Self-consistent refinement is key: Simply fitting these solvent parameters to individual conformations or assuming fixed, literature-derived values can lead to inaccurate ensembles. The iBME approach, by simultaneously refining ensemble weights and solvent parameters, addresses this.
  • IDPs are particularly sensitive: The ensembles of intrinsically disordered proteins were found to be more sensitive to variations in $\delta\rho$ compared to more structured proteins.
  • A universal parameter set is possible: The researchers identified a set of default parameters ($r_0 \approx 1.68$ Å, $\delta\rho \approx 3.34$ e/nm$^3$) that provided good results across multiple diverse proteins, suggesting a degree of transferability.
  • Prior distribution matters, but less than expected: While the initial conformational ensemble (the "prior") influences the optimal parameter values, the final reweighted ensembles were remarkably similar across different priors, indicating the robustness of the SAXS fitting process.

Key Results

  • The iBME method successfully refined conformational ensembles for four different proteins, achieving good agreement with experimental SAXS data.
  • The study demonstrated that different combinations of $r_0$ and $\delta\rho$ could yield similar SAXS fits, but resulted in distinct conformational ensembles.
  • A global minimum for a combined scoring function ($\gamma$) was identified, indicating a balance between fitting the data and maintaining the integrity of the prior ensemble.
  • The proposed default parameter set ($r_0 = 1.681$ Å, $\delta\rho = 3.34$ e/nm$^3$) provided comparable results to optimized parameters for the tested proteins.
  • Comparisons between calculated radii of gyration ($R_g$) from ensembles and experimental estimates from Guinier analysis showed reasonable agreement, though with noted caveats regarding the influence of parameter choices.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational cost: The grid search for $r_0$ and $\delta\rho$ can be computationally intensive, especially for large ensembles. The authors suggest precomputing partial SAXS intensities as a potential optimization.
  • Parameter transferability: While a default parameter set was found, the authors suggest that further studies are needed to better understand the physical origins of these effects and their transferability across a wider range of protein types and conditions.
  • Hydration layer modeling: The paper notes that improvements in predicting hydration layer contributions directly, rather than relying on fitting parameters, could further enhance accuracy.
  • Future directions: The authors propose that the iBME framework could be extended to other types of experimental data (e.g., NMR, EPR, CD) that also involve estimating scale factors or background contributions. They also suggest that the work provides a useful starting point for benchmarking molecular simulations against SAXS data.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Intrinsically disordered proteins and flexible regions in multi-domain proteins display substantial conformational heterogeneity. Characterizing the conformational ensembles of these proteins in solution typically requires combining one or more biophysical techniques with computational modelling or simulations. Experimental data can either be used to assess the accuracy of a computational model or to refine the computational model to get a better agreement with the experimental data. In both cases, one generally needs a so-called forward model, i.e. an algorithm to calculate experimental observables from individual conformations or ensembles. In many cases, this involve one or more parameters that need to be set, and it is not always trivial to determine the optimal values or to understand the impact on the choice of parameters. For example, in the case of small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) experiments, many forward models include parameters that describe the contribution of the hydration layer and displaced solvent to the background-subtracted experimental data. Often, one also needs to fit a scale factor and a constant background for the SAXS data, but across the entire ensemble. Here, we present a protocol to dissect the effect of free-parameters on the calculated SAXS intensities, and to identify a reliable set of values. We have implemented this procedure in our Bayesian/Maximum Entropy framework for ensemble refinement, and demonstrate the results on four intrinsically disordered proteins and a three-domain protein connected by flexible linkers. Our results show that the resulting ensembles can depend on the parameters used for solvent effects, and suggests that these should be chosen carefully. We also find a set of parameters that work robustly across all proteins. SIGNIFICANCE The flexibility of a protein is often key to its biological function, yet understanding and characterizing its conformational heterogeneity is difficult. We here describe a robust protocol for combining small-angle X-ray scattering experiments with computational modelling to obtain a conformational ensemble. In particular, we focus on the contribution of protein hydration to the experiments and how this is included in modelling the data. Our resulting algorithm and software should make modelling intrinsically disordered proteins and multi-domain proteins more robust, thus aiding in understanding the relationship between protein dynamics and biological function.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pesce2021refining,
  author = {Francesco Pesce and Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen},
  title = {{Refining conformational ensembles of flexible proteins against small-angle x-ray scattering data}},
  booktitle = {Biophysical},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.bpj.2021.10.003},
}
Figure