Refined support and entropic uncertainty inequalities

Benjamin Ricaud, Bruno Torrésani

Abstract

Generalized versions of the entropic (Hirschman-Beckner) and support (Elad-Bruckstein) uncertainty principles are presented for frame representations. By introducing a generalization of mutual coherence, a sharpened version of the support inequality is obtained. In the finite-dimensional case, minimizers of these inequalities are shown to be constant functions on their support under specific conditions. Additionally, $\ell^p$-norm inequalities are derived as byproducts of the entropic inequalities.

Introduction

In signal processing and quantum mechanics, the Uncertainty Principle (UP) establishes a fundamental limit on the simultaneous concentration of a signal in two different domains. Traditionally, this is illustrated by the relationship between time and frequency: a signal cannot be localized as a sharp spike in both. Mathematically, these principles are often expressed through the $\ell^0$ "norm" (counting non-zero coefficients) or Shannon entropy.

While these inequalities are well-established for orthonormal bases, modern signal processing frequently utilizes frames. Frames are overcomplete systems that offer more flexibility than bases but complicate the application of standard uncertainty bounds. This research bridges that gap by providing tighter, generalized inequalities applicable to any pair of frames.

The Problem: Looseness in Overcomplete Representations

The classical Elad-Bruckstein inequality provides a lower bound on the product of the sparsity of a signal in two bases. However, when applied to frames—where the number of vectors exceeds the dimension of the space—these bounds often become "loose" or mathematically ill-defined. The challenge lies in the fact that the standard measure of similarity between bases, mutual coherence ($\mu$), does not capture the nuanced interactions within overcomplete systems. This research seeks to refine these bounds to better reflect the true uncertainty inherent in frame-based analysis.

Methodology

To address these limitations, the authors employ a combination of information theory and functional analysis:

  • Frame Theory: The study shifts focus from synthesis (building signals) to analysis, using frame operators to probe signal coefficients.
  • Mutual Coherence of Order $r$ ($\mu_r$): The authors introduce a generalization of standard mutual coherence. While the traditional $\mu$ only considers the maximum inner product between vectors, $\mu_r$ (for $r \in [1, 2]$) incorporates a weighted sum of these products, allowing for a more granular measurement of similarity.
  • Rényi and Shannon Entropies: Rényi entropy serves as a parameterized bridge to derive bounds for both the $\ell^0$ support and classical Shannon entropy.
  • Riesz-Thorin Interpolation: This operator theory theorem provides the mathematical framework necessary to prove the core entropic inequalities.

Key Insights and Results

1. Refined Support Inequality

The most significant contribution is the introduction of a "refined" coherence measure, $\mu_*$, obtained by optimizing over the parameter $r$. This leads to a sharper bound for the product of the number of non-zero coefficients in two frame representations:

$$\|Ux\|_0 \|Vx\|_0 \geq \frac{1}{\mu_*^2}$$

Numerical experiments using Random Gaussian Bases and Modified Discrete Cosine Transform (MDCT) bases demonstrate that this refined bound is strictly higher—and therefore more accurate—than the classical Elad-Bruckstein bound.

2. Entropic Bounds for Tight Frames

For tight frames (which preserve energy similarly to orthonormal bases), the authors established that the sum of Shannon entropies $S(a) + S(b)$ is bounded below by $-2 \ln(\mu_*)$. This provides a clear information-theoretic limit on how much information can be compressed when using frame-based analysis.

3. Geometry of Minimizers

In finite-dimensional spaces, the research identifies the signals that actually reach these lower bounds. These "minimizers" are signals whose coefficient sequences are constant on their support. This provides a geometric intuition: the most "certain" signals are those that distribute their energy perfectly evenly across their active coefficients.

Discussion and Limitations

While the mathematical framework is robust, certain challenges remain for practical application:

  • Infinite Dimensions: The "constant on support" property does not translate directly to infinite-dimensional spaces (e.g., continuous functions), leaving optimization in those spaces as an open question.
  • Non-Tight Frames: The entropic inequalities can become non-informative (tending toward $-\infty$) for general frames that lack the "tight" property, suggesting that different normalization techniques may be required.
  • Algorithmic Gap: The paper establishes the theoretical limits of signal separation and co-sparse recovery but does not provide the specific algorithms to achieve these bounds in real-time processing.

Conclusion

By generalizing the uncertainty principle to frames and introducing the refined coherence $\mu_*$, this work provides a more precise mathematical language for understanding signal sparsity. These sharpened inequalities offer a stronger foundation for co-sparse signal recovery and the analysis of overcomplete representations in modern signal processing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Generalized versions of the entropic (Hirschman-Beckner) and support (Elad-Bruckstein) uncertainty principle are presented for frames representations. Moreover, a sharpened version of the support inequality has been obtained by introducing a generalization of the coherence. In the finite dimensional case and under certain conditions, minimizers of this inequalities are given as constant functions on their support. In addition, $\ell^p$-norms inequalities are introduced as byproducts of the entropic inequalities.
BibTeX
@article{ricaud2013refined,
  author = {Benjamin Ricaud and Bruno Torrésani},
  title = {{Refined support and entropic uncertainty inequalities}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Information Theory},
  year = {2013},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=XrA8pPtyxcO},
}
Figure